张书维,郭晟豪

• 1:中山大学中国公共管理研究中心/政治与公共事务管理学院
• 2:兰州大学管理学院
• 3:北京大学人力资源开发与管理研究中心

摘要(Abstract)：

公共组织行为是行为公共管理学的重要组成部分,是组织行为研究在公共管理领域的"延拓"。本文选取近期在国际公共管理研究顶级期刊Public Administration Review和Public Management Review上发表的4篇学术论文分别加以介绍。4篇论文聚焦公共部门的变革支持、战略规划及工作满意度,使用"计划行为理论"和"自我决定理论"作为理论基础和研究框架,充分展示了行为公共管理学把来自心理学乃至行为科学的相关认识整合进公共管理学中的特点。本文从三个方面对4篇论文进行评介:研究问题与假设、研究方法与结果、研究贡献与局限。最后对行为公共管理学的公共组织行为研究进行小结和展望。

关键词(KeyWords)： 计划行为理论;自我决定理论;意向;行为;公共服务动机;工作满意度

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金青年项目“基层干部何以担当作为?动机与影响因素的研究”（项目批准号:71904071）;国家自然科学基金面上项目“基于虚拟仿真技术的社会信任机制实验研究”（项目批准号:71873149）资助;; 国家社会科学基金青年项目“行为公共管理学视角下群体性事件的‘输入-输出’机制研究”（项目批准号:18CGL043）

作者(Author): 张书维,郭晟豪

参考文献(References)：

• 代涛涛,陈志霞.2019.行为公共管理研究中的实验方法:类型与应用[J].公共行政评论,12(6):166-185,203.Dai T T,Chen Z X.2019.Experimental methods in behavioral public administration:Types and applications[J].Journal of Public Administration,12(6):166-185,203.(in Chinese)
• 邓崧.2020.差异与互适:行为公共管理的演进脉络[J].广州大学学报(社会科学版),19(6):118-125.Deng S.2020.Difference and adaptation:The evolution of behavioral public management[J].Journal of Guangzhou University (Social Science Edition),19(6):118-125.(in Chinese)
• 段文婷,江光荣.2008.计划行为理论述评[J].心理科学进展,16(2):315-320.Duan W T,Jiang G R.2008.A review of the theory of planned behavior[J].Advances in Psychological Science,16(2):315-320.(in Chinese)
• 郭晟豪.2020.基层干部何以担当作为?测量、动机与前因机制[J].心理科学进展,28(6):924-934.Guo S H.2020.How to drive street-level cadres to take charge?A study on measurements,motivations,and antecedents[J].Advances in Psychological Science,28(6):924-934.(in Chinese)
• 郭晟豪.2021.基层干部的担当作为:基于角色认同中介的动机与行为关系研究[J].公共管理与政策评论,10(1):66-80.Guo S H.2021.Taking charge of street-level cadres:A study on motivation and behavior with the mediation of role identity[J].Public Administration and Policy Review,10(1):66-80.(in Chinese)
• 贾海薇.2018.公共管理心理学[M].2版.北京:科学出版社.Jia H W.2018.Public management psychology[M].2nd ed.Beijing:Science Press.(in Chinese)
• 李德国,甘巧婷,蔡晶晶.2021.行为公共管理学的理论溯源、实践议题与本土展望[J].上海行政学院学报,22(2):36-45.Li D G,Gan Q T,Cai J J.2021.Theoretical origins,practical issues and local prospects of behavioral public administration[J].The Journal of Shanghai Administration Institute,22(2):36-45.(in Chinese)
• 李晓倩.2018.行为公共管理学实验:基于SSCI期刊(1978-2016)相关文献的分析[J].公共行政评论,11(1):37-61.Li X Q.2018.Experimental research in behavioral public administration:An analysis of related literature based on SSCI-Indexed journals (1978-2016)[J].Journal of Public Administration,11(1):37-61.(in Chinese)
• 刘帮成,陈家喜.2019.专栏导语:理解新时代“好干部”的工作行为、动机与选拔标准[J].公共行政评论,12(6):1-5.Liu B C,Chen J X.2019.Introduction:Understanding the work behaviors,motivations,and selection standards of good cadres in the new era[J].Journal of Public Administration,12(6):1-5.(in Chinese)
• 苗青.2019.公共服务动机理论的中国场景:新框架和新议程[J].公共管理与政策评论,8(5):18-22.Miao Q.2019.Contextualizing public service motivation theory in China:A new framework and research agenda[J].Public Administration and Policy Review,8(5):18-22.(in Chinese)
• 王永贵,汪寿阳,吴照云,等.2021.深入贯彻落实习近平总书记在哲学社会科学工作座谈会上的重要讲话精神加快构建中国特色管理学体系[J].管理世界,37(6):1-35.Wang Y G,Wang S Y,Wu Z Y,et al.2021.Implementing the spirit of the important speech of general secretary Xi Jinping at the symposium on philosophy and social sciences,speeding up the construction of management system with Chinese characteristics[J].Management World,37(6):1-35.(in Chinese)
• 张春虎.2019.基于自我决定理论的工作动机研究脉络及未来走向[J].心理科学进展,27(8):1489-1506.Zhang C H.2019.Streams and future directions of research on work motivation based on the self-determination theory[J].Advances in Psychological Science,27(8):1489-1506.(in Chinese)
• 张书维.2018.专栏导语:行为公共管理学:用“心”求“理”[J].公共行政评论,11(1):1-6.Zhang S W.2018.Symposium introduction-Behavioral public administration:A bridge linking public administration and psychology[J].Journal of Public Administration,11(1):1-6.(in Chinese)
• 张书维,李纾.2018.行为公共管理学探新:内容、方法与趋势[J].公共行政评论,11(1):7-36.Zhang S W,Li S.2018.Exploring behavioral public administration:Content,method and trend[J].Journal of Public Administration,11(1):7-36.(in Chinese)
• 张书维,顾琼,杨黎婧.2019.对党忠诚与建言行为:公职人员的“忠谏”之路[J].公共行政评论,12(6):38-62.Zhang S W,Gu Q,Yang L J.2019.Loyalty and voice of civil servant:Mediation and moderation[J].Journal of Public Administration,12(6):38-62.(in Chinese)
• 张志学,鞠冬,马力.2014.组织行为学研究的现状:意义与建议[J].心理学报,46(2):265-284.Zhang Z X,Ju D,Ma L.2014.Organizational behavior research in 2008-2011:A brief review and future direction for Chinese research[J].Acta Psychologica Sinica,46(2):265-284.(in Chinese)
• Aguinis H,Glavas A.2019.On corporate social responsibility,sensemaking,and the search for meaningfulness through work[J].Journal of Management,45(3):1057-1086.
• Ahmad A B,Liu B C,Butt A S.2020a.Scale development and construct clarification of change recipient proactivity[J].Personnel Review,49(8):1619-1635.
• Ahmad A B,Liu B C,Butt A S.2020b.Predictors and outcomes of change recipient proactivity in public organizations of the Kurdistan region of Iraq[J].International Public Management Journal,23(6):823-851.
• Ahmad A B,Straatmann T,Mueller K,et al.2021.Employees.change support in the public sector-A multi-time field study examining the formation of intentions and behaviors[J].Public Administration Review,81(2):231-243.
• Ajzen I.1991.The theory of planned behavior[J].Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,50(2):179-211.
• Ajzen I.2011.The theory of planned behaviour:Reactions and reflections[J].Psychology and Health,26(9):1113-1127.
• Armitage C J,Conner M.2001.Efficacy of the theory of planned behaviour:A meta-analytic review[J].British Journal of Social Psychology,40(4):471-499.
• Barak-Corren,N.&Kariv-Teitelbaum,Y.2021.Behavioral responsive regulation:Bringing together responsive regulation and behavioral public policy[J].Regulation&Governance,doi:10.1111/rego.12429.
• Battaglio R P Jr,Belardine P,BelléN,et al.2019.Behavioral public administration ad fontes:A synthesis of research on bounded rationality,cognitive biases,and nudging in public organizations[J].Public Administration Review,79(3):304-320.
• Battaglio R P Jr,BelléN,Cantarelli P.2021.Self-determination theory goes public:Experimental evidence on the causal relationship between psychological needs and job satisfaction[J].Public Management Review,doi:10.1080/14719037.2021.1900351.
• Bertelli A M,Riccucci N M.2020.What is behavioral public administration good for?[J].Public Administration Review,doi:10.1111/puar.13283.
• Boselie P,Van Harten J,Veld M.2021.A human resource management review on public management and public administration research:Stop right there...before we go any further...[J].Public Management Review,23(4):483-500.
• Bryson J M,Crosby B C,Bryson J K.2009.Understanding strategic planning and the formulation and implementation of strategic plans as a way of knowing:The contributions of actor-network theory[J].International Public Management Journal,12(2):172-207.
• Bryson J M.2010.The future of public and nonprofit strategic planning in the United States[J].Public Administration Review,70(S1):S255-S267.
• Cantarelli P,Belardinelli P,Belle N.2016.A meta-analysis of job satisfaction correlates in the public administration literature[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,36(2):115-144.
• Cantarelli P,Belle N,Longo F.2020.Exploring the motivational bases of public missiondriven professions using a sequential-explanatory design[J].Public Management Review,22(10):1535-1559.
• Carmeli A,Brammer S,Gomes E,et al.2017.An organizational ethic of care and employee involvement in sustainability-related behaviors:A social identity perspective[J].Journal of Organizational Behavior,38(9):1380-1395.
• Carrigan C,Pandey S K,Van Ryzin G G.2020.Pursuing consilience:Using behavioral public administration to connect research on bureaucratic red tape,administrative burden,and regulation[J].Public Administration Review,80(1):46-52.
• Christensen R K,Paarlberg L,Perry J L.2017.Public service motivation research:Lessons for practice[J].Public Administration Review,77(4):529-542.
• Crane A,Matten D,Glozer S,et al.2019.Business ethics:Managing corporate citizenship and sustainability in the age of globalization[M].5th ed.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
• Crucke S,Kluijtmans T,Meyfroodt K,et al.2021.How does organizational sustainability foster public service motivation and job satisfaction?The mediating role of organizational support and societal impact potential[J].Public Management Review,doi:10.1080/14719037.2021.1893801.
• Dawkins C E,Frass J W.2005.Decision of union workers to participate in employee involvement:An application of the theory of planned behaviour[J].Employee Relations,27(5):511-531.
• Deci E L,Ryan R M.2000.The“what”and“why”of goal pursuits:Human needs and the self-determination of behavior[J].Psychological Inquiry,11(4):227-268.
• Deci E L,Olafsen A H,Ryan R M.2017.Self-determination theory in work organizations:The state of a science[J].Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior,4(1):19-43.
• de Geus C J C,Ingrams A,Tummers L,et al.2020.Organizational citizenship behavior in the public sector:A systematic literature review and future research agenda[J].Public Administration Review,80(2):259-270.
• Demircioglu M A.2020.The effects of organizational and demographic context for innovation implementation in public organizations[J].Public Management Review,22 (12):1852-1875.
• Desmidt S,Meyfroodt K.2021.What motivates politicians to use strategic plans as a decisionmaking tool?Insights from the theory of planned behaviour[J].Public Management Review,23(3):447-474.
• Farooq M,Farooq O,Jasimuddin S M.2014.Employees response to corporate social responsibility:Exploring the role of employees.collectivist orientation[J].European Management Journal,32(6):916-927.
• Fattore G,Iacovone D,Steccolini I.2018.Managing successful change in the public sector:Aview from the consultants.world[J].Public Management Review,20(4):587-606.
• Gofen A,Moseley A,Thomann E,et al.2021.Behavioural governance in the policy process:Introduction to the special issue[J].Journal of European Public Policy,28 (5):633-657.
• Gond J P,El Akremi A,Swaen V,et al.2017.The psychological microfoundations of corporate social responsibility:A person-centric systematic review[J].Journal of Organizational Behavior,38(2):225-246.
• Grimmelikhuijsen S,Jilke S,Olsen A L,et al.2017.Behavioral public administration:Combining insights from public administration and psychology[J].Public Administration Review,77(1):45-56.
• Hainmueller J,Hopkins D J,Yamamoto T.2014.Causal inference in conjoint analysis:Understanding multidimensional choices via stated preference experiments[J].Political Analysis,22(1):1-30.
• Hainmueller J,Hangartner D,Yamamoto T.2015.Validating vignette and conjoint survey experiments against real-world behavior[J].Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,112(8):2395-2400.
• Hameed I,Riaz Z,Arain G A,et al.2016.How do internal and external CSR affect employees.organizational identification?A perspective from the group engagement model[J].Frontiers in Psychology,7:788.
• Hassan H A,Zhang X D,Ahmad A B,et al.2021.Public service motivation and employee change-supportive intention:Utilizing the theory of planned behavior[J].Public Personnel Management,50(2):283-304.
• Homberg F,Mc Carthy D,Tabvuma V.2015.A meta-analysis of the relationship between public service motivation and job satisfaction[J].Public Administration Review,75(5):711-722.
• Ingrams A.2020.Organizational citizenship behavior in the public and private sectors:Amultilevel test of public service motivation and traditional antecedents[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,40(2):222-244.
• Jacobsen D I.2006.The relationship between politics and administration:The importance of contingency factors,formal structure,demography,and time[J].Governance,19(2):303-323.
• Jimmieson N L,Peach M,White K M.2008.Utilizing the theory of planned behavior to inform change management:An investigation of employee intentions to support organizational change[J].The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science,44(2):237-262.
• Jones C,Hine D W,Marks A D G.2017.The future is now:Reducing psychological distance to increase public engagement with climate change[J].Risk Analysis,37(2):331-341.
• Jones D A,Newman A,Shao R D,et al.2019.Advances in employee-focused micro-level research on corporate social responsibility:Situating new contributions within the current state of the literature[J].Journal of Business Ethics,157(2):293-302.
• Kjeldsen A M,Jacobsen C B.2013.Public service motivation and employment sector:Attraction or socialization?[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,23(4):899-926.
• Kjeldsen A M,Hansen J R.2018.Sector differences in the public service motivation-job satisfaction relationship:Exploring the role of organizational characteristics[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,38(1):24-48.
• Kroll A.2015.Explaining the use of performance information by public managers:A plannedbehavior approach[J].The American Review of Public Administration,45(2):201-215.
• Kurtessis J N,Eisenberger R,Ford M T,et al.2017.Perceived organizational support:Ameta-analytic evaluation of organizational support theory[J].Journal of Management,43(6):1854-1884.
• Long E,Franklin A L.2004.The paradox of implementing the government performance and results act:Top-down direction for bottom-up implementation[J].Public Administration Review,64(3):309-319.
• Mergel I,BelléN,Nasi G.2021.Prosocial motivation of private sector IT professionals joining government[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,41(2):338-357.
• Moldavanova A,Goerdel H T.2018.Understanding the puzzle of organizational sustainability:Toward a conceptual framework of organizational social connectedness and sustainability[J].Public Management Review,20(1):55-81.
• Nazir O,Islam J U,Rahman Z.2021.Effect of CSR participation on employee sense of purpose and experienced meaningfulness:A self-determination theory perspective[J].Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management,46:123-133.
• Oliveira B,Jarzabkowski P,Lee N.2017.Adoption of management practices:Explaining individual motivations toward strategy tools adoption[J].Academy of Management Proceedings,2014(1):12254,doi:10.5465/ambpp.2014.12254abstract.
• Osborne S P,Radnor Z,Kinder T,et al.2015.The SERVICE framework:A public-servicedominant approach to sustainable public services[J].British Journal of Management,26(3):424-438.
• Perry J L,Wise L R.1990.The motivational bases of public service[J].Public Administration Review,50(3):367-373.
• Perry J L,Vandenabeele W.2015.Public service motivation research:Achievements,challenges,and future directions[J].Public Administration Review,75(5):692-699.
• Rainey H G.2009.Understanding and managing public organizations[M].4th ed.San Francisco,CA:John Wiley.
• Ritz A,Brewer G A,Neumann O.2016.Public service motivation:A systematic literature review and outlook[J].Public Administration Review,76(3):414-426.
• Rosenbloom D H.2017.Beyond efficiency:Value frameworks for public administration[J].Chinese Public Administration Review,8(1):37-46.
• Ryan M,Kolstad J R,Rockers P C,et al.2012.How to conduct a discrete choice experiment for health workforce recruitment and retention in remote and rural areas:A user guide with case studies[M].Geneva,Switzerland:World Health Organization.
• Ryan R M,Deci E L.2000a.Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations:Classic definitions and new directions[J].Contemporary Educational Psychology,25(1):54-67.
• Ryan R M,Deci E L.2000b.Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation,social development,and well-being[J].American Psychologist,55(1):68-78.
• Ryan R M,Deci E L.2017.Self-determination theory:Basic psychological needs in motivation,development,and wellness[M].New York,NY:The Guilford Press.
• Ryan R M,Deci E L.2020.Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation from a self-determination theory perspective:Definitions,theory,practices,and future directions[J].Contemporary Educational Psychology,61:101860,doi:10.1016/j.cedpsych.2020.101860.
• Simon H A,Smithburg D W,Thompson V A.1950.Public administration[M].New York,NY:Alfred A.Knopf.
• Stevens J M,Steensma H K,Harrison D A,et al.2005.Symbolic or substantive document?The influence of ethics codes on financial executives.decisions[J].Strategic Management Journal,26(2):181-195.
• Straatmann T,Nolte J K,Seggewiss B J.2018.Psychological processes linking organizational commitment and change-supportive intentions[J].Personnel Review,47(2):403-424.
• Street D J,Burgess L,Louviere J J.2005.Quick and easy choice sets:Constructing optimal and nearly optimal stated choice experiments[J].International Journal of Research in Marketing,22(4):459-470.
• Stritch J M,Christensen R K.2014.Looking at a job.s social impact through PSM-tinted lenses:Probing the motivation-perception relationship[J].Public Administration,92(4):826-842.
• Torugsa N,Arundel A.2016.Complexity of innovation in the public sector:A workgroup-level analysis of related factors and outcomes[J].Public Management Review,18 (3):392-416.
• Tummers L,Steijn B,Bekkers V.2012.Explaining the willingness of public professionals to implement public policies:Content,context,and personality characteristics[J].Public Administration,90(3):716-736.
• Vaara E,Sorsa V,P?lli P.2010.On the force potential of strategy texts:A critical discourse analysis of a strategic plan and its power effects in a city organization[J].Organization,17(6):685-702.
• Vandenabeele W.2007.Toward a public administration theory of public service motivation:An institutional approach[J].Public Management Review,9(4):545-556.
• Vandenabeele W.2011.Who wants to deliver public service?Do institutional antecedents of public service motivation provide an answer?[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,31(1):87-107.
• Vandenabeele W.2014.Explaining public service motivation:The role of leadership and basic needs satisfaction[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,34(2):153-173.
• Van den Broeck A,Ferris D L,Chang C H,et al.2016.A review of self-determination theory.s basic psychological needs at work[J].Journal of Management,42 (5):1195-1229.
• Van Loon N,Kjeldsen A M,Andersen L B,et al.2018.Only when the societal impact potential is high?A panel study of the relationship between public service motivation and perceived performance[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,38(2):139-166.
• Walker R M,Jung C S,Boyne G A.2013.Marching to different drummers?The performance effects of alignment between political and managerial perceptions of performance management[J].Public Administration Review,73(6):833-844.
• Walker R M.2014.Internal and external antecedents of process innovation:A review and extension[J].Public Management Review,16(1):21-44.
• Wanberg C R,Banas J T.2000.Predictors and outcomes of openness to changes in a reorganizing workplace[J].Journal of Applied Psychology,85(1):132-142.
• Wang T K,Brower R.2019.Job satisfaction among federal employees:The role of employee interaction with work environment[J].Public Personnel Management,48(1):3-26.
• Wright B E,Hassan S,Christensen R K.2017.Job choice and performance:Revisiting core assumptions about public service motivation[J].International Public Management Journal,20(1):108-131.
• Zarychta A,Grillos T,Andersson K P.2020.Public sector governance reform and the motivation of street-level bureaucrats in developing countries[J].Public Administration Review,80(1):75-91.
• (1)截至2021年7月,JBPA已在线发行四卷六期。网址:https://journal-bpa. org/index. php/jbpa。
• (2)此会于2019年10月12-13日由华中科技大学公共管理学院主办。见http://cpa. hust. edu. cn/info/1602/9478. htm。
• (3)此会拟于2021年2021年11月26-28日,由北京师范大学政府管理学院承办。见https://mp. weixin.qq. com/s/v TNo GC4m Sl C5i TU5a Kb89Q。
• (1)该专栏包含了1篇专栏导语、8篇研究论文和4篇观点文章。
• (2)公共部门组织行为与公共组织行为在本文中不加区分,替换使用。
• (3)搜索来源:CSSCI中文论文来自CNKI数据库;SSCI英文论文来自Web of Science数据库。搜索目标:篇名、关键词、摘要、正文和参考文献5个板块中至少有一个板块中出现“行为公共管理(学)”或“Behavioral Public Administration”的文章及其专栏。共搜索到CSSCI论文66篇、SSCI论文125篇;再加上JBPA上发表的论文76篇,合计267篇。感谢刘星同学对文献的梳理。
• (4)数学概念,将一个函数的定义域扩大的过程称为延拓。最早为复变函数术语,后来也被用到泛函分析。