孙昊辰,张铨,王翔

• 1:南开大学周恩来政府管理学院

摘要(Abstract)：

诉源治理是我国基于“枫桥经验”和多元解纷机制的制度性努力，是缓解人案矛盾与“诉讼爆炸”的有益尝试。然而在地方治理实践中，以“减负”为初衷的诉源治理反而时常陷入“增负”的困境。本研究从政法逻辑与司法逻辑的竞争性视角出发，选取C市W区人民法院为案例，深入挖掘基层诉源治理在实施过程中“欲减负却不能”背后的机制与逻辑。研究发现，政法逻辑与司法逻辑在诉源治理中相互影响，构建了横向和纵向的压力传导路径。在横向层面，“小权分散”与治理资源紧张引发了结构性压力；在纵向层面，上级的考核压力与基层“为民服务”的角色期望进一步加重了基层的负担。横纵交互的压力传导机制相互渗透、交织与碰撞，最终导致了诉源治理推行过程中的非预期效应。

关键词(KeyWords)： 诉源治理;减负;政法逻辑;司法逻辑;法政治学

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 司法部2024年度法治建设与法学理论研究部级科研项目青年课题"非诉讼纠纷解决机制的治理效能研究"(项目批准号:24SFB3006)的资助

作者(Author): 孙昊辰,张铨,王翔

参考文献(References)：

• 曹海军，鲍操.2020.系统集成与部门协同：基层社会矛盾纠纷化解的流程再造与治理效能——以浙江省A县“矛调中心”为例[J].天津行政学院学报，22(6):23-31.Cao H J,Bao C.2020.System integration and department collaboration:Reinventing the process of disputes mediation at grass-roots level and the governance effectiveness—A case study of “Conflicts and Disputes Mediation Center” of a county in Zhejiang Province[J].Journal of Tianjin Administration Institute,22(6):23-31.(in Chinese)
• 陈端洪.1998.司法与民主：中国司法民主化及其批判[J].中外法学，(4):34-44.Chen D H.1998.Justice and democracy:Democratization of justice in China and its criticism [J].Peiking University Law Journal,(4):34-44.(in Chinese)
• 陈正芹，吴涛.2022.城市风险治理中的人民调解问题研究[J].理论视野，(1):68-73.Chen Z Q,Wu T.2022.A study on people's mediation in urban risk governance[J].Theoretical Horizon,(1):68-73.(in Chinese)
• 董必武.2001.实事求是地总结经验，把政法工作做得更好[M]//董必武.董必武法学文集.北京：法律出版社，423-324.Dong B W.2001.Summing up experience in seeking truth from facts and doing better in political and legal work[M]//Dong B W.Dong Biwu Law Collection.Beijing:Law Press,423-324.(in Chinese)
• 董储超，舒瑶芝.2023.诉源治理导向下的纠纷解决：理念澄清与范式革新[J].交大法学，(4):80-94.Dong C C,Shu Y Z.2023.Dispute resolution under the guidance of litigation source governance:Concept clarification and paradigm innovation[J].SJTU Law Review,(4):80-94.(in Chinese)
• 顾培东.2020.人民法院改革取向的审视与思考[J].法学研究，42(1):3-26.Gu P D.2020.Review of and reflections on the orientation of the people's courts reform[J].Chinese Journal of Law,42(1):3-26.(in Chinese)
• 郭松.2016.审判管理进一步改革的制度资源与制度推进——基于既往实践与运行场域的分析[J].法制与社会发展，22(6):62-80.Guo S.2016.Institutional resources and institutional promotion for further reform of trial management:An analysis based on previous practice and operational field [J].Law and Social Development,22(6):62-80.(in Chinese)
• 侯猛.2009.中国的司法模式：传统与改革[J].法商研究，(6):58-64.Hou M.2009.China's judicial model:tradition and Reform [J].Studies in Law and Business,(6):58-64.(in Chinese)
• 黄宗智.1998.民事审判与民间调解：清代的表达与实践[M].北京：中国社会科学出版社.Huang Z Z.1998.Civil trial and civil mediation:Expression and practice in the Qing dynasty[M].Beijing:China Social Sciences Press.(in Chinese)
• 黄宗智.2021.再论调解及中西正义体系融合之路[J].中外法学，33(1):125-140.Huang Z Z.2021.Mediation reconsidered and the road to syncretizing the Chinese and Western justice systems[J].Peking University Law Journal,33(1):125-140.(in Chinese)
• 蒋铧毅，陈建财.2020-05-12(B03).行贿罪特殊从宽情节的理解与适用[N].广西法治日报.
• 李占国.2022.诉源治理的理论、实践及发展方向[J].法律适用，(10):3-16.Li Z G.2022.Theory,practice and orientation for the governance of sources of litigations[J].Journal of Law Application,(10):3-16.(in Chinese)
• 梁治平.2013.寻求自然秩序中的和谐：中国传统法律文化研究[M].北京：商务印书馆.Liang Z P.2013.Searching for harmony in the natural order[M].Beijing:The Commercial Press.(in Chinese)
• 刘磊.2021.维稳压力对基层法院组织形态的形塑[J].交大法学，(1):60-75.Liu L.2021.The shaping of stability maintenance logic on the organization form of basic court[J].SJTU Law Review,(1):60-75.(in Chinese)
• 刘练军.2019.“红”与“专”:法官职业认知的理念与规范叙事[J].法治研究，(5):95-110.Liu L J.2019.“Red” and “Specialized”:The idea and normative narration of judges' professional cognition[J].Research on Rule of Law,(5):95-110.(in Chinese)
• 刘忠.2020.员额制之后：法院人员分类构成评析[J].华东政法大学学报，23(6):88-105.Liu Z.2020.After the “Yuan'e” System:Comment on classification of personnel in people's court[J].ECUPL Journal,23(6):88-105.(in Chinese)
• 欧阳桃花.2004.试论工商管理学科的案例研究方法[J].南开管理评论，7(2):100-105.Ouyang T H.2004.Case study method in the field of business administration[J].Nankai Business Review,7(2):100-105.(in Chinese)
• 强世功.2000.权力的组织网络与法律的治理化——马锡五审判方式与中国法律的新传统[J].北大法律评论，3(2):1-61.Qiang S G.2000.The network of power organization and the governmentalization of law:Ma Xiwu's form of trial and new Chinese legal traditions[J].Peking University Law Review,3(2):1-61.(in Chinese)
• 瞿郑龙.2016.我国司法模式的历史变迁与当代重构——政治视野的考察[J].法学评论，34(4):113-124.Qu Z L.2016.Historical changes and contemporary reconstruction of China's justice mode[J].Law Review,34(4):113-124.(in Chinese)
• 任建新.2005.政法工作五十年[M].北京：人民法院出版社，358.Ren J X.2005.Fifty years of political and legal work[M].Beijing:People's Court Press,358.(in Chinese)
• 宋远升.2017.精英化与专业化的迷失——法官员额制的困境与出路[J].政法论坛，35(2):101-117.Song Y S.2017.The loss of elitism and specialization—Dilemma and outlet of the judge's post system[J].Tribune of Political Science and Law,35(2):101-117.(in Chinese)
• 王斌通.2021.新时代“枫桥经验”与矛盾纠纷源头治理的法治化[J].行政管理改革，12(12):67-75.Wang B T.2021.“Fengqiao Experience” in the new era and the iegalization of the source management of conflicts and disputes[J].Administration Reform,12(12):67-75.(in Chinese)
• 王翔.2022.“去精英化”抑或“再精英化”——“压力分摊”下人民陪审员选任的实践逻辑[J].社会学研究，37(6):201-221.Wang X.2022.“De-elitism” or “Re-elitism”?The practical logic of people's assessor selection under “Pressure Sharing”[J].Sociological Studies,37(6):201-221.(in Chinese)
• 王翔.2023.诉源治理的全球视野：比较经验与中国反思[J].经济社会体制比较，(4):135-146.Wang X.2023.Comparative experiences and lessons for China in litigation source governance from a global perspective[J].Comparative Economic & Social Systems,(4):135-146.(in Chinese)
• 魏治勋.2010.司法现代化视野中的“马锡五审判方式”[J].新视野，(2):57-60.Wei Z X.2010.“Ma Xiwu Judging Form” in perspective of judicial modernization[J].Expanding Horizons,(2):57-60.(in Chinese)
• 肖滨，戴少斌.2022.判决抑或调解——基层法官行为选择的政治学分析[J].吉林大学社会科学学报，62(5):45-58.Xiao B,Dai S B.2022.Choice of basic judge's behavior:Judgment or mediation a political explanation based on the empirical investigation[J].Jilin University Journal Social Sciences Edition,62(5):45-58.(in Chinese)
• 谢伊云.2022.系统不响应：对基层矛盾治理中“小事拖大”现象的考察与分析[J].湖北社会科学，(7):38-47.Xie Y Y.2022.No respond from the system:An investigation and analysis of the phenomenon of “Small Issues Delaying Big” in the grass-roots contradiction management[J].Hubei Social Sciences,(7):38-47.(in Chinese)
• 于晓虹，杨惠.2019.党政体制重构视阈下政法工作推进逻辑的再审视——基于《中国共产党政法工作条例》的解读[J].学术月刊，51(11):105-116.Yu X H,Yang H.2019.Promoting the political-legal work against the backdrop of political reform—Interpreting the 2019 “Regulation on the Political-legal Work”[J].Academic Monthly,51(11):105-116.(in Chinese)
• 于晓虹，王翔.2021.政法传统中的人民陪审：制度变迁与发展逻辑[J].学术月刊，53(7):105-120.Yu X H,Wang X.2021.People's assessors in China's political-legal tradition:Institutional changes and developmental logic[J].Academic Monthly,53(7):105-120.(in Chinese)
• 张保川，熊晓彪.2017.基层诉源治理的探索与出路——以四川省蒲江县人民法院为中心的分析[J].人民法治，(7):22-24.Zhang B C,Xiong X B.2017.Exploration and way out of grassroots litigation source governance—An analysis centered on the People's Court of Pujiang County,Sichuan Province[J].People-Rule of Law,(7):22-24.(in Chinese)
• 章荣君.2017.“微治理”:基层社会矛盾源头预防的有效机制——基于常熟市H社区“微治理”的案例分析[J].理论与改革，(4):51-58.Zhang R J.2017.Micro-governance:The mechanism of preventing the grass-root social contradictory—A case study of H Community in Changshu City[J].Theory and Reform,(4):51-58.(in Chinese)
• 章武生.2007.论我国大调解机制的构建——兼析大调解与ADR的关系[J].法商研究，24(6):111-115.Zhang W S.2007.On the construction of great mediation mechanism in China—Analyzing the relationship between great mediation and ADR[J].Studies in Law and Business,24(6):111-115.(in Chinese)
• 章志远.2021.新时代行政审判因应诉源治理之道[J].法学研究，43(3):192-208.Zhang Z Y.2021.Measures for the management of litigation source in administrative trial[J].Chinese Journal of Law,43(3):192-208.(in Chinese)
• 周光辉，赵德昊.2021.教化：大一统国家韧性的形成路径[J].探索与争鸣，(4):53-64.Zhou G H,Zhao D H.2021.Enlightenment:The formation path of the national resilience of a unified country[J].Exploration and Free Views,(4):53-64.(in Chinese)
• 朱光磊.2017.全面深化改革进程中的中国新治理观[J].中国社会科学，(4):27-39.Zhu G L.2017.China's new view of governance in the process of comprehensively deepening reform[J].Social Sciences in China,(4):27-39.(in Chinese)
• 左卫民.2020.通过诉前调解控制“诉讼爆炸”——区域经验的实证研究[J].清华法学，14(4):89-106.Zuo W M.2020.Controlling “Litigation Explosion” by pre-litigation mediation:An empirical research[J].Tsinghua University Law Journal,14(4):89-106.(in Chinese)
• (1)最高人民法院.(2024-07-25)[2024-10-12].最高法:上半年636万件诉讼纠纷成功化解在诉前[EB/OL].https://news.gmw.cn/2024-07/25/content_37458043.htm.
• (2)最高人民法院.(2023-03-08)[2024-10-19.2022年全国法院受理案件超3300万件[EB/OL].https://www.chinacourt.org/article/detail/2023/03/id/7178935.shtml.人民网.(2019-03-12)[2024-10-19].周强:2018年地方各级人民法院受理案件2800万件[EB/OL].http://lianghui.people.com.cn/2019npc/n1/2019/0312/c425476-30971677.html.
• (3)新华社.(2014-10-28)[2024-10-12].中共中央关于全面推进依法治国若干重大问题的决定[EB/OL].https://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2014-10/28/content_2771714.htm.
• (4)最高人民法院.(2021-09-15)[2024-10-12].最高人民法院关于推动新时代人民法庭工作高质量发展的意见[EB/OL].https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu-xiangqing-322461.html.