徐换歌

• 1:上海财经大学公共经济与管理学院

摘要(Abstract)：

全国已有100多个城市陆续开通了电视问政节目,探究这种大规模的城市治理方式的创新和扩散具有重要意义。基于此,本文建立了35个大中城市的电视问政数据库,在创新扩散理论和TOE框架的基础上,结合中国的政务发展实践,基于清晰集定性比较分析(csQCA)方法,从组态效应的视角考察了电视问政兴起的原因。研究表明,电视问政节目的创新扩散并非单一因素作用的结果,而是多种因素共同作用,并基于清晰集的结果概念化出五种前因构型模式。本研究有助于理解中国情境下政务实践创新扩散发生的机理。

关键词(KeyWords)： 电视问政;创新扩散;TOE框架;组态效应

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 2018年国家社会科学基金专项项目“深化机构与行政体制改革研究:基于地方党政部门及内设机构权责优化配置的视角”(项目批准号:18VSJ027);; 上海财经大学研究生创新基金项目“政府治理绩效如何影响居民幸福感:基于‘放管服’改革的实证研究”(项目批准号:CXJJ-2019-376)资助

作者(Author): 徐换歌

参考文献(References)：

• 丁依霞，徐倪妮，郭俊华．2020．基于TOE框架的政府电子服务能力影响因素实证研究[J]．电子政务，(1):103-113.Ding Y X,Xu N N,Guo J H.2020.An empirical study on the influencing factors of government E-Service capability based on TOE framework[J].E-Government,(1):103-113.(in Chinese)
• 杜运周，贾良定．2017．组态视角与定性比较分析(QCA):管理学研究的一条新道路[J]．管理世界，(6):155-167.Du Y Z,Jia L D.2017.Configurational perspective and qualitative comparative analysis(QCA):A new approach to management research[J].Management World,(6):155-167.(in Chinese)
• 方晨，何志武．2015．场域视角下的电视问政:资本转化与权力生产[J]．当代传播，(5):36-38.Fang C,He Z W.2015.TV politics from the perspective of field:Capital transformation and power production[J].Contemporary Communication,(5):36-38.(in Chinese)
• 葛明驷，何志武．2015．电视问政十年:文化效应与反思[J]．中州学刊，(3):168-171.Ge M S,He Z W.2015.Ten years of TV politics:Cultural effect and reflection[J].Academic Journal of Zhongzhou,(3):168-171.(in Chinese)
• 韩娜娜．2019．中国省级政府网上政务服务能力的生成逻辑及模式---基于31省数据的模糊集定性比较分析[J]．公共行政评论，12(4):82-100.Han N N.2019.Realization logical and model of provincial government online services abilitily in China-A empirical study based on FSQCA method[J].Journal of Public Administration,12(4):82-100.(in Chinese)
• 韩万渠，沈亚平，原珂．2016．公民在场、政府效能评价与电视问政的运行机制---以武汉市电视问政实践为例[J]．理论导刊，(8):13-16.Han W Q,Shen Y P,Yuan K.2016.The presence of citizens,government effectiveness evaluation and the operation mechanism of television politics[J].Journal of Socialist Theory Guide,(8):13-16.(in Chinese)
• 何志武．2017．电视问政的协商理念及其实现保障[J]．中州学刊，(7):162-168.He Z W.2017.The negotiation idea and practice guarantee of governmental affairs enquiry on TV[J].Academic Journal of Zhongzhou,(7):162-168.(in Chinese)
• 胡春艳．2017．问责视角下电视问政的效果评价---以A市《电视问政》节目为个案[J]．探索，(3):60-69.Hu C Y.2017.Effect Evaluation of TV Ask Politicians with view of accountability:Taking a city TV program as an example[J].Probe,(3):60-69.(in Chinese)
• 黄建伟，陈玲玲．2018．公民问责与政务服务的同步创新---我国地方电视问政的过去、现在和未来[J]．新视野，(2):89-93,101.Huang J W,Chen L L.2018.Synchronous innovation of citizen accountability and government affairs service[J].Expanding Horizons,(2):89-93,101.(in Chinese)
• 黄晓春．2010．技术治理的运作机制研究:以上海市L街道一门式电子政务中心为案例[J]．社会，30(4):1-31.Huang X C.2010.A study on the performing mechanism of information technology:A case study of the One-Stop Administrative E-Service Center at Community L in Shanghai[J].Society,30(4):1-31.(in Chinese)
• 简·E．芳汀．2010．构建虚拟政府:信息技术与制度创新[M]．邵国松，译．北京:中国人民大学出版社．Fountain J E.2010.Building the virtual state:Information technology and institutional change[M].Shao G S,trans.Beijing:China Renmin University Press.(in Chinese)
• 郎玫，史晓姣．2020．创新持续到创新深化:地方政府治理创新能力构建的关键要素[J]．公共行政评论，(1):158-176,200.Lang M,Shi X J.2020.From sustaining innovation to deepening innovation:The key factors to building capacity for innovation in local government[J].Journal of Public Administration,(1):158-176,200.(in Chinese)
• 刘茂长，鞠晓峰．2012．基于TOE模型的电子商务技术扩散影响因素研究[J]．信息系统学报，(2):13-30.Liu M C,Ju X F.2012.Research of E-business technology diffusion’s influence factors based on TOE Model[J].China Journal of Information Systems,(2):13-30.(in Chinese)
• 马亮．2015．公共服务创新的扩散:中国城市公共自行车计划的实证分析[J]．公共行政评论，8(3):51-78.Ma L.2015.The diffusion of public service innovation:An empirical analysis of public bicycle programs in Chinese cities[J].Journal of Public Administration,8(3):51-78.(in Chinese)
• 马亮．2019．政务服务创新何以降低行政负担:西安行政效能革命的案例研究[J]．甘肃行政学院学报，(2):4-11.Ma L.2019.How do administrative service innovations alleviate administrative burden:Acase study of administrative reform in Xi’an[J].Journal of Gansu Administration Institute,(2):4-11.(in Chinese)
• 人民网．(2017-12-13)[2020-05-14]．武汉上半年电视问政问责113人次[EB/OL].http://hb.people.com.cn/n2/2017/1213/c192237-31026746.html．
• 沈永东，祝子航，杨鸣宇．2018．“因地制宜”与“殊途同归”:中国地方网约车政策多元化成因分析[J]．甘肃行政学院学报，(5):21-30.Shen Y D,Zhu Z H,Yang M Y.2018．“Adaptation to local condition”and“All roads lead to Rome”:Analysis on the causes of diversified online reserved Taxi policies at local China[J].Journal of Gansu Administration Institute,(5):21-30.(in Chinese)
• 谭海波，范梓腾，杜运周．2019．技术管理能力、注意力分配与地方政府网站建设---一项基于TOE框架的组态分析[J]．管理世界，35(9):81-94.Tan H B,Fan Z T,Du Y Z.2019.Technology management capability,attention distribution and local government website construction-A configurational analysis based on the TOE Framework[J].Management World,35(9):81-94.(in Chinese)
• 王猛．2020．中国地方政府创新研究:理论、议题与方法[J]．公共管理评论，2(1):116-154.Wang M.2020.Research on innovation in China’s Local Governments:Theory,issues,and methods[J].China Public Administration Review,2(1):116-154.(in Chinese)
• 王苗苗，谭康林．2019．高位推动下的政策执行过程分析---基于广东S市C社区网格化管理实践[J]．汕头大学学报(人文社会科学版)，35(3):69-75,96.Wang M M,Tan K L.2019.An analysis of policy implementation with the high-level promotion-Based on the grid management of a community in Guangdong[J].Shantou University Journal(Humanities&Social Sciences Monthly),35(3):69-75,96.(in Chinese)
• 王肖红，韩万渠．2019．党委问责、议题空间与地方政府行政效能提升---基于地方电视问政的比较案例分析[J]．地方治理研究，(3):2-14.Wang X H,Han W Q.2019.Party committee accountability,agenda space and the improvement of administrative efficiency of local governments:A comparative case analysis based on local TV politics[J].Local Governance Research,(3):2-14.(in Chinese)
• 熊烨，周建国．2017．政策转移中的政策再生产:影响因素与模式概化---基于江苏省“河长制”的QCA分析[J]．甘肃行政学院学报，(1):37-47.Xiong Y,Zhou J G.2017.Policy reproduction in“River-chief System”transfer:Influencing factors and model generalization-Based on the qualitative comparison and analysis(QCA)of multiple cases in Jiangsu province[J].Journal of Gansu Administration Institute,(1):37-47.(in Chinese)
• 徐自强，张静洁，马文倩，等．2019．电视问政:城市公共治理的创新长效机制研究---基于《问政日照》和《问政追踪》的内容分析[J]．福建行政学院学报，(5):26-40.Xu Z Q,Zhang J J,Ma W Q,et al.2019.Television politics:Exploration on long-term mechanism of urban public governance innovation-Content analysis based on Asking for Politics of Rizhao and Asking for Politics Tracking[J].Fujian Academy of Governance,(5):26-40.(in Chinese)
• 杨寅，刘勤，吴忠生．2018．科技资源开放共享平台创新扩散的关键因素研究---基于TOE理论框架[J]．现代情报，38(1):69-75,86.Yang Y,Liu Q,Wu Z S.2018.Research on key factors of the innovation diffusion of science and technology resource opening and sharing platform-Based on TOE theory framework[J].Journal of Modern Information,38(1):69-75,86.(in Chinese)
• 杨正喜．2019．波浪式层级吸纳扩散模式:一个政策扩散模式解释框架---以安吉美丽中国政策扩散为例[J]．中国行政管理，(11):97-103.Yang Z X.2019.The pattern of wave-like hierarchical absorption and diffusion:An interpretation framework of policy diffusion model-A case study of beautiful China policy diffusion in Anji[J].Chinese Public Administration,(11):97-103.(in Chinese)
• 曾婧婧，龚启慧，凌瑜．2016．政府即时回应的剧场试验:基于武汉电视问政(2011-2015年)的扎根分析[J]．甘肃行政学院学报，(2):15-23.Zeng J J,Gong Q H,Ling Y.2016.Explanation on characteristics of local government instance response:Based on analyzing the full-data of Television Politics of Wuhan(2011-2015)with grounded theory[J].Journal of Gansu Administration Institute,(2):15-23.(in Chinese)
• 张立荣，宋祎玮，张金庆．2016．电视问政与城市治理创新---以武汉市电视问政为例[J]．浙江社会科学，(7):70-76.Zhang L R,Song Y W,Zhang J Q.2016.On the government accountability on TV and the urban governance innovation[J].Zhejiang Social Sciences,(7):70-76.(in Chinese)
• 张亚泽．2018．当代中国政府民意回应性的治理绩效及其生成逻辑[J]．陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)，47(3):133-139.Zhang Y Z.2018.The Chinese government’s governance performance of responsiveness and its generation logic[J].Journal of Shaanxi Normal University(Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition),47(3):133-139.(in Chinese)
• 朱旭峰，赵慧．2016．政府间关系视角下的社会政策扩散---以城市低保制度为例(1993-1999)[J]．中国社会科学，(8):95-116.Zhu X F,Zhao H.2016.The diffusion of social policies from the perspective ofintergovernmental relations:A case study of the urban subsistence allowance(1993-1999)[J].Social Sciences in China,(8):95-116.(in Chinese)
• Berry F S,Berry W D.1999.Innovation and diffusion models in policy research[M]//Sabatier P A.Theories of the Policy Process.Boulder:Westview Press．
• Berry F S.1994.Innovation in public management:The adoption of strategic planning[J].Public Administration Review,54(4):322-330．
• Boudet H S,Jayasundera D C,Davis J.2011.Drivers of conflict in developing country infrastructure projects:Experience from the water and pipeline sectors[J].Journal of Construction Engineering and Management,137(7):498-511．
• Damanpour F,Walker R M,Avellaneda C N.2009.Combinative effects of innovation types and organizational performance:A longitudinal study of service organizations[J].Journal of Management Studies,46(4):650-675．
• El-Haddadeh R.2020.Digital innovation dynamics influence on organisational adoption:The case of cloud computing services[J].Information Systems Frontiers,22(4):985-999．
• Fan Z T,Meng Q G,Wei N.2020.Fiscal slack or environmental pressures:Which matters more for technological innovation assimilation?A configurational approach[J].International Public Management Journal,23(3):380-404．
• Grimmelikhuijsen S G,Feeney M K.2017.Developing and testing an integrative framework for open government adoption in local governments[J].Public Administration Review,77(4):579-590．
• Hansen M B.2011.Antecedents of organizational innovation:The diffusion of new public management into Danish local government[J].Public Administration,89(2):285-306．
• Lee S Y,Whitford A B.2013.Assessing the effects of organizational resources on public agency performance:Evidence from the US federal government[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,23(3):687-712．
• Li M H,Feeney M K.2014.Adoption of electronic technologies in local U.S.governments:Distinguishing between e-services and communication technologies[J].The American Review of Public Administration,44(1):75-91．
• Ma L.2014.Diffusion and assimilation of government microblogging:Evidence from Chinese cities[J].Public Management Review,16(2):274-295．
• Ragin C C.2014.The comparative method:Moving beyond qualitative and quantitative strategies[M].Oakland,CA:University of California Press．
• Rihoux B,Ragin C C.2008.Configurational comparative methods:Qualitative comparative analysis(QCA)and related techniques(Vol.51)[M].Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage Publications．
• Rogers E M.2003.Diffusion of innovations[M].5th ed.New York:Free Press．
• Shipan C R,Volden C.2008.The mechanisms of policy diffusion[J].American Journal of Political Science,52(4):840-857．
• Tornatzky L G,Fleischer M.1990.The processes of technological innovation[M].Lexington,MA:D.C.Heath&Company．
• Walker R M,Avellaneda C N,Berry F S.2011.Exploring the diffusion of innovation among high and low innovative localities:A test of the Berry and Berry model[J].Public Management Review,13(1):95-125．
• Walker R M.2014.Internal and external antecedents of process innovation:A review and extension[J].Public Management Review,16(1):21-44．
• Zhu X F.2014.Mandate versus championship:Vertical government intervention and diffusion of innovation in public services in authoritarian China[J].Public Management Review,16(1):117-139．
• Zhu X F,Zhang Y L.2019.Diffusion of marketization innovation with administrative centralization in a multilevel system:Evidence from China[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,29(1):133-150.
• (1)35个大中城市包括北京市、天津市、石家庄市、太原市、呼和浩特市、沈阳市、大连市、长春市、哈尔滨市、上海市、南京市、杭州市、宁波市、合肥市、福州市、厦门市、南昌市、济南市、青岛市、郑州市、武汉市、长沙市、广州市、深圳市、南宁市、海口市、重庆市、成都市、贵阳市、昆明市、西安市、兰州市、西宁市、银川市和乌鲁木齐市。
• (2)需要说明的是，本文统计的是城市所在地的地级市政府主管的媒体开通第一期即首播电视问政节目的时间，且时间截至2017年。有的城市虽然现在已经开通了电视问政节目，但并不在本文的统计时期内，如北京市开通的首档电视问政节目是北京卫视2018年6月开播的《向前一步》，因此算作未开通城市。