中国地方政府创新研究:理论、议题与方法Research on Innovation in China's Local Governments:Theory,Issues,and Methods
王猛
摘要(Abstract):
地方政府创新是理解中国地方治理逻辑的重要切口。论文在从角色变迁、制度逻辑与行为选择三个视角对地方政府研究进行综述的基础上,对地方政府创新研究的核心议题、研究转向和理论路径进行了梳理。研究发现,随着央地关系的调整以及地方政府自主性的增强,地方政府越来越多地通过制度创新来保持竞争优势。现有研究主要围绕地方政府创新的动力机制、模式分类、延续扩散和影响因素等议题而展开,并在方法上向解释性研究转变、在内容上更加关注创新可持续性。未来的地方政府创新研究,需基于中国情境深入探讨地方政府创新的内在逻辑,通过构建地方政府创新的系统理论,推进中国公共管理理论本土化与地方治理现代化。
关键词(KeyWords): 地方政府创新;政策扩散;政策试验
基金项目(Foundation): 教育部人文社会科学研究青年基金项目(项目批准号:19YJC630171);; 中央高校基本科研业务费专项资金资助(项目批准号:SWU1909427);; 中央高校基本科研业务费创新团队项目(项目批准号:SWU1709123)资助
作者(Author): 王猛
参考文献(References):
- 艾赫克·D M.2006.美国地方政府创新的影响因素分析[J].冉冉,译.经济社会体制比较,(2):12-16.Ihrke D M.2006.An analysis of factors influencing local government innovation in America[J].Ran R,trans.Comparative Economic and Social Systems,(2):12-16.(in Chinese)
- 包国宪,潘旭.2004.中国西部地方政府制度创新问题初探---甘肃定西市县、乡政府调查启示及对策建议[J].中国行政管理,(12):84-89.Bao G X,Pan X.2004.On the innovation of the local governmental institutions in Western China[J].Chinese Public Administration,(5):84-89.(in Chinese)
- 包国宪,孙斐.2011.演化范式下中国地方政府创新可持续性研究[J].公共管理学报,8(1):104-113.Bao G X,Sun F.2011.Research on the sustainability of Chinese local government innovations based on evolutionary paradigm[J].Journal of Public Management,8(1):104-113.(in Chinese)
- 蔡芸,杨冠琼.2011.晋升锦标赛与中国的基础教育发展失衡[J].中央财经大学学报,(6):17-22.Cai Y,Yang G Q.2011.Promotion tournaments and disequilibrium of the basic education development in China[J].Journal of Central University of Finance&Economics,(6):17-22.(in Chinese)
- 曹龙虎,段然.2017.地方政府创新扩散过程中的利益契合度问题---基于H省X市2个综合行政执法改革案例的比较分析[J].江苏社会科学,(5):104-115.Cao L H,Duan R.2017.Interest agreement in the process of local governments'innovation diffusion-A comparative analysis based on two cases in administrative law enforcement in X city,H province[J].Jiangsu Social Sciences,(5):104-115.(in Chinese)
- 曹正汉,史晋川.2009.中国地方政府应对市场化改革的策略:抓住经济发展的主动权---理论假说与案例研究[J].社会学研究,(4):1-27.Cao Z H,Shi J C.2009.Seizing the initiative in economic growth:A theoretical hypothesis and case study of the Chinese local governments'strategies responding to the reformation of market economy[J].Sociological Studies,(4):1-27.(in Chinese)
- 陈国权,黄振威.2010.地方政府创新研究的热点主题与理论前瞻[J].浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版),40(4):14-26.Chen G Q,Huang Z W.2010.Local government innovation research:Hot topics and prospects[J].Journal of Zhejiang University(Humanities and Social Sciences),40(4):14-26.(in Chinese)
- 陈家喜,汪永成.2013.政绩驱动:地方政府创新的动力分析[J].政治学研究,(4):50-56.Chen J X,Wang Y C.2013.Performance-driven:An analysis of the motive force of local government innovation[J].Cass Journal of Political Science,(4):50-56.(in Chinese)
- 陈科霖,谷志军.2018.论中国地方政府创新的十大关系[J].深圳大学学报(人文社会科学版),35(6):74-82.Chen K L,Gu Z J.2018.Ten major relationships in China's local governance innovation[J].Journal of Shenzhen University(Humanities&Social Sciences),35(6):74-82.(in Chinese)
- 陈玲,王晓丹,赵静,等.2010.发展型政府:地方政府转型的过渡态---基于沪、苏、锡的海归创业政策案例调研[J].公共管理学报,7(3):47-51.Chen L,Wang X D,Zhao J,et al.2010.The approach from developmental government to service-oriented government-based on case studies of returnee's entrepreneurship policy in Shanghai,Suzhou and Wuxi[J].Journal of Public Management,7(3):47-51.(in Chinese)
- 陈朋.2016.地方政府创新的影响因素分析---基于中国地方政府创新奖的数据研判[J].中共中央党校学报,20(4):44-50.Chen P.2016.Analysis on the influencing factors of local government innovation-based on the statistics of Chinese local government innovation award[J].Journal of the Party School of the Central Committee of the C.P.C.,20(4):44-50.(in Chinese)
- 陈世香,谢秋山.2014.先驱者利润与地方公共服务创新逻辑---选择性激励机制的构建[J].四川师范大学学报(社会科学版),41(2):39-44.Chen S X,Xie Q S.2014.Promoter's profit and the logic of local government's public service innovation[J].Journal of Sichuan Normal University(Social Sciences Edition),41(2):39-44.(in Chinese)
- 陈天祥.2000.中国地方政府制度创新的动因[J].管理世界,(6):202-203.Chen T X.2000.The Motives of China's local government bring forth new ideas in institution[J].Management World,(6):202-203.(in Chinese)
- 陈天祥.2002.中国地方政府制度创新的角色及方式[J].中山大学学报(社会科学版),42(3):111-118.Chen T X.2002.The roles and ways of institutional innovation of local government in China[J].Journal of Sun Yatsen University(Social Science Edition),42(3):111-118.(in Chinese)
- 陈天祥.2004.对中国地方政府制度创新作用的一种阐释[J].中山大学学报(社会科学版),44(4):19-23.Chen T X.2004.An analysis of the functions of institutional innovation by local government in China[J].Journal of Sun Yatsen University(Social Science Edition),44(4):19-23.(in Chinese)
- 陈雪莲,杨雪冬.2009.地方政府创新的驱动模式---地方政府干部视角的考察[J].公共管理学报,6(3):1-11.Chen X L,Yang X D.2009.Promoting local government innovations:Local cadres'view[J].Journal of Public Management,6(3):1-11.(in Chinese)
- 陈永杰,曹伟.2016.从政府创新到政府创新管理:一个分析框架[J].中国行政管理,(2):40-44.Chen Y J,Cao W.2016.From government innovation to government innovation management:An analytical framework[J].Chinese Public Administration,(2):40-44.(in Chinese)
- 陈钊,徐彤.2011.走向“为和谐而竞争”:晋升锦标赛下的中央和地方治理模式变迁[J].世界经济,(9):3-18.Chen Z,Xu T.2011.Towards“competition for harmony”:Changes in central and local governance models under promotion championships[J].The Journal of World Economy,(9):3-18.(in Chinese)
- 定明捷,张梁.2014.地方政府政策创新扩散生成机理的逻辑分析[J].社会主义研究,(3):75-82.Ding M J,Zhang L.2014.A logical analysis of generation mechanism about the local government policy innovation diffusion[J].Socialism Studies,(3):75-82.(in Chinese)
- 冯猛.2019.地方政府创新何以持续?---以浦东新区基层社会治理变迁为线索[J].中国行政管理,(7):101-106.Feng M.2019.How can local government innovation sustain?-Taking the grass-roots governance changes in Pudong district as a clue[J].Chinese Public Administration,(7):101-106.(in Chinese)
- 冯兴元.2001.论辖区政府间的制度竞争[J].国家行政学院学报,(6):27-32.Feng X Y.2001.On inter-governmental competition over systems[J].Journal of Chinese Academy of Governance,(6):27-32.(in Chinese)
- 傅大友,芮国强.2003.地方政府制度创新的动因分析[J].江海学刊,(4):92-98.Fu D Y,Rui G Q.2003.On motivation of system innovation in local government[J].Jianghai Academic Journal,(4):92-98.(in Chinese)
- 付光伟.2013.地方政府行为演进的机理---珠三角L镇政府的个案[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社.Fu G W.2013.The mechanism of local government behavior evolution:A case study of the Ltown government in the Pearl River Delta[M].Beijing:China Social Sciences Press.(in Chinese)
- 傅金鹏,杨继君.2010.我国地方政府创新的可持续性:影响因素与对策[J].理论导刊,(12):14-16.Fu J P,Yang J J.2010.Sustainability of local government innovation in China:Influencing factors and countermeasures[J].Journal of Socialist Theory Guide,(12):14-16.(in Chinese)
- 傅金鹏.2012.我国地方政府创新动力研究---生态、利益和组织的视角[J].理论月刊,(3):106-109.Fu J P.2012.Research on the innovation motivation of local governments in China-From the perspective of ecology,benefits and organization[J].Theory Monthly,(3):106-109.(in Chinese)
- 高卫星.2005.地方政府制度创新的几个问题[J].郑州大学学报(哲学社会科学版),38(4):40-43.Gao W X.2005.Some questions aboutinstitutional innovation of local government[J].Journal of Zhengzhou University,38(4):40-43.(in Chinese)
- 谷志军,黄卫平.2018.“上下联动”:地方政府创新可持续性的影响因素分析[J].学术研究,(10):59-64.Gu Z J,Huang W P.2018.“Up and down linked”:Analysis of influencing factors of local government innovation sustainability[J].Academic Research,(10):59-64.(in Chinese)
- 郭栋,胡业飞.2019.地方政府竞争:一个文献综述[J].公共行政评论,12(3):156-173.Guo D,Hu Y F.2019.Local government competition:A literature review[J].Journal of Public Administration,12(3):156-173.(in Chinese)
- 郭杰,李涛.2009.中国地方政府间税收竞争研究---基于中国省级面板数据的经验证据[J].管理世界,(11):54-64,73.Guo J,Li T.2009.A study on the competition in taxation between China's local governments[J].Management World,(11):54-64,73.(in Chinese)
- 郭庆旺,贾俊雪.2006.政府公共资本投资的长期经济增长效应[J].经济研究,(7):29-40.Guo Q W,Jia J X.2006.The effects of government public capital investment on long-run economic growth[J].Economic Research Journal,(7):29-40.(in Chinese)
- 郭小聪.2000.中国地方政府制度创新的理论:作用与地位[J].政治学研究,(1):67-73.Guo X C.2000.The theory of Chinese local government institutional innovation:Role and status[J].Cass Journal of Political Science,(1):67-73.(in Chinese)
- 韩福国.2012.地方政府创新与区域经济增长的关联性---基于中国区域间地方政府创新差异的跨案例分析[J].浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版),42(2):161-177.Han F G.2012.The correlation between regional economic growth and local government innovations:An inter-case analysis of the differences between Chinese local governments[J].Journal of Zhejiang University(Humanities and Social Sciences),42(2):161-177.(in Chinese)
- 贺东航.2006.地方政治精英与制度创新---以东南沿海X市S区塑造“公共部门绩效评估”活动为例[J].内蒙古大学学报(人文社会科学版),38(4):53-57.He D H.2006.Local political elites and the system reform-Take X Citys area's“public sector performance assessment”as example[J].Journal of Inner Mongolia University(Humanities and Social Sciences),38(4):53-57.(in Chinese)
- 何绍辉.2010.目标管理责任制:运作及其特征---对红村扶贫开发的个案研究[J].中国农业大学学报(社会科学版),27(4):173-182.He S H.2010.Target management responsibility system:Operation and characteristics-Acase study on the development for poverty relief of Village Hong[J].China Agricultural University Journal of Social Sciences Edition,27(4):173-182.(in Chinese)
- 何显明.2007.市场化进程中的地方政府角色行为模式及其变迁---浙江现象的行政学解读[J].浙江社会科学,(4):43-48.He X M.2007.The role of local government and its action logic in the process of marketoriented-Analyse on Zhejiang phenomena under the science of administration[J].Zhejiang Social Sciences,(4):43-48.(in Chinese)
- 何显明.2009.地方政府创新实践的生成机制与运行机理---基于浙江现象的考察[J].中国行政管理,(8):124-128.He X M.2009.Emergence and operation mechanism of local government's innovation practice-In the view of Zhejiang phenomena[J].Chinese Public Administration,(8):124-128.(in Chinese)
- 何艳玲,李妮.2017.为创新而竞争:一种新的地方政府竞争机制[J].武汉大学学报(哲学社会科学版),70(1):87-96.He Y L,Li N.2017.Competition for innovation:A new competitive mechanism of local governments[J].Wuhan University Journal(Social Science),70(1):87-96.(in Chinese)
- 何增科.2011.中国政府创新的趋势分析---基于五届“中国地方政府创新奖”获奖项目的量化研究[J].北京行政学院学报,(1):1-8.He Z K.2011.A trend analysis of the trend of China's government innovations[J].Journal of Beijing Administrative College,(1):1-8.(in Chinese)
- 何增科.2015.地方政府创新与政治正当性:中美之间的比较研究[J].湖北社会科学,(4):23-32.He Z K.2015.Local government innovation and political legitimacy:A comparative study between China and the United States[J].Hubei Social Sciences,(4):23-32.(in Chinese)
- 洪银兴,曹勇.1996.经济体制转轨时期的地方政府功能[J].经济研究,(5):22-28.Hong Y X,Cao Y.1996.Functions of local government in the transition of economic system[J].Economic Research Journal,(5):22-28.(in Chinese)
- 胡宁生.2010.社会转型时期公共政策创新模式研究[J].江海学刊,(1):116-122.Hu N S.2010.On innovation mode of public policy during social transformation[J].Jianghai Academic Journal,(1):116-122.(in Chinese)
- 胡宁生,杨志.2015.中国地方政府社会治理创新的持续性:影响因素与政策优化[J].江苏社会科学,(3):114-120.Hu N S,Yang Z.2015.Sustainability of social governance innovation in Chinese local governments:Influencing factors and policy optimization[J].Jiangsu Social Sciences,(3):114-120.(in Chinese)
- 胡宁生,戴祥玉.2016.地方政府治理创新自我推进机制:动力、挑战与重塑[J].中国行政管理,(2):27-32.Hu N S,Dai X Y.2016.Local governance innovation self propulsion mechanism:Motivation,challenges and remodeling[J].Chinese Public Administration,(2):27-32.(in Chinese)
- 黄巡晋.2017.地方政府“创新悖论”的机制及警示[J].领导科学,(11):54-56.Huang X J.2017.The mechanism and warning of local government's“innovation paradox”[J].Leadership Science,(11):54-56.(in Chinese)
- 黄永炎,陈成才.2001.地方政府制度创新的行为探析[J].探索,(4):54-57.Huang Y Y,Chen C C.2001.Exploration into action of local government's systematic innovation[J].Probe,(4):54-57.(in Chinese)
- 黄玮强,庄新田.2007.网络结构与创新扩散研究[J].科学学研究,25(5):1018-1024.Huang W Q,Zhuang X T.2007.The study of network structure and innovation diffusion[J].Studies in Science of Science,25(5):1018-1024.(in Chinese)
- 计宁,魏淑艳.2014.地方政府创新可持续性内涵及其影响因素---基于行政生态学的视角[J].行政论坛,(2):46-50.Ji N,Wei S Y.2014.Connotation and influencing factors of local government innovation sustainability-Based on the perspective of administrative ecology[J].Administrative Tribune,(2):46-50.(in Chinese)
- 孔凡义.2014.社会流动、制度变迁与政府管理创新:以C市实证研究为例[J].经济社会体制比较,(1):161-167.Kong F Y.2014.Social mobility,institutional change and innovation in government management:Empirical research on the Basis of C City in Sichuan Province[J].Comparative Economic&Social Systems,(1):161-167.(in Chinese)
- 莱特·P C.2004.持续创新:打造自发创新的政府和非营利组织[M].张秀琴,译.北京:中国人民大学出版社.Light P C.2004.Sustaining innovation:Creating nonprofit and government organizations that innovate naturally[M].Zhang X Q,trans.Beijing:China Renmin University Press.(in Chinese)
- 郎玫.2018.地方政府创新可持续的影响因素及其交叠效应研究---基于西北案例的定性比较分析[J].经济社会体制比较,(6):109-120.Lang M.2018.The factors influencing local government innovation sustainability and their overlap effect:Based on QCA of Northwest cases[J].Comparative Economic&Social Systems,(6):109-120.(in Chinese)
- 雷平,张宁亭.2015.“政治集权,经济分权”与政府差别化税收策略研究[J].中南财经政法大学学报,(1):28-35.Lei P,Zhang N T.2015.“Political centralization,economic decentralization”and differentiated tax policy[J].Journal of Zhongnan University of Economics and Law,(1):28-35.(in Chinese)
- 李佳佳.2015.从地方政府创新理解现代国家---基于“非协调约束权力结构”的框架[M].上海:学林出版社.Li J J.2013.Understanding the modern state from the local government innovation-Based on the framework of“non-coordinate constraint power structure”[M].Shanghai:Xuelin press.(in Chinese)
- 刘景江.2009.地方政府创新:概念框架和两个向度[J].浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版),39(4):35-42.Liu J J.2009.Local government innovation:Conceptual framework and two dimensions[J].Journal of Zhejiang University(Humanities and Social Sciences),39(4):35-42.(in Chinese)
- 刘鹏,刘志鹏.2014.街头官僚政策变通执行的类型及其解释---基于对H县食品安全监管执法的案例研究[J].中国行政管理,(5):101-105.Liu P,Liu Z P.2014.The type and explanation of policy misimplementation by streetlevel bureaucrats in Chinese context-Based on the study of food safety regulation in county H[J].Chinese Public Administration,(5):101-105.(in Chinese)
- 刘强,覃成林.2009.地方政府竞争与地区制度创新:一个制度分析的视角[J].中州学刊,(6):46-49.Liu Q,Qin C L.2009.The competitions among local governments and the regional system innovation:A view of system analysis[J].Academic Journal of Zhongzhou,(6):46-49.(in Chinese)
- 刘伟.2014a.学习借鉴与跟风模仿---基于政策扩散理论的地方政府行为辨析[J].国家行政学院学报,(1):34-38.Liu W.2014a.Lesson drawing and general imitation-Local government behavior analysis based on policy diffusion theory[J].Journal of Chinese Academy of Governance,(1):34-38.(in Chinese)
- 刘伟.2014b.社会嵌入与地方政府创新之可持续性---公共服务创新的比较案例分析[J].南京社会科学,(1):87-93.Liu W.2014b.Social embeddedness and the sustainability of local government innovation[J].Nanjing Journal of Social Sciences,(1):87-93.(in Chinese)
- 刘锡田.2003.地方政府制度创新:动力和意义[J].当代财经,(8):17-19.Liu X T.2003.Local government institution innovation:Motivation and significance[J].Contemporary Finance&Economics,(8):17-19.(in Chinese)
- 刘亚平,颜昌武.2006.转型期中国地方政府间竞争:策略选择与制度规范[J].浙江社会科学,(6):25-30.Liu Y P,Yan C W.2006.Competition among Chinese local governments in transition:Strategic choices and institutional regulations[J].Zhejiang Social Sciences,(6):25-30.(in Chinese)
- 娄成武,董鹏.2016.中国地方政府改革的三重逻辑:效率、合法性与适当[J].理论月刊,(8):100-104.Lou C W,Dong P.2016.The triple logic of China's local government reform:Efficiency,legitimacy,and appropriateness[J].Theory Monthly,(8):100-104.(in Chinese)
- 卢福营.2014.论农村基层社会治理创新的扩散[J].学习与探索,(1):46-52.Lu F Y.2014.On the diffusion of rural grassroots social governance innovation[J].Study&Exploration,(1):46-52.(in Chinese)
- 罗晓光,孙艳凤.2015.创新扩散网络结构与创新扩散绩效关系研究[J].科技进步与对策,32(8):1-6.Luo X G,Sun Y F.2015.On the relationship between the structure of innovation diffusion network and the innovation diffusion performance[J].Science&Technology Progress and Policy,32(8):1-6.(in Chinese)
- 平新乔,白洁.2006.中国财政分权与地方公共品的供给[J].财贸经济,(2):49-55.Ping X Q,Bai J.2006.Fiscal decentralization and local public good provision in China[J].Finance&Trade Economics,(2):49-55.(in Chinese)
- 丘海雄,崔强.2004.剖析集群创新---西樵纺织产业集群的案例研究[J].学术研究,(7):25-31.Qiu H X,Cui Q.2004.An analysis of the innovation in Chinese grouped manufacture[J].Academic Research,(7):25-31.(in Chinese)
- 丘海雄,徐建牛.2004a.市场转型过程中地方政府角色研究述评[J].社会学研究,(4):24-30.Qiu H X,Xu J N.2004a.A review of studies on the role of local government in market transformation[J].Sociological Research,(4):24-30.(in Chinese)
- 丘海雄,徐建牛.2004b.产业集群技术创新中的地方政府行为[J].管理世界,(10):36-46.Qiu H X,Xu J N.2004b.The behavior of local governments in technical innovation in industrial groups[J].Management World,(10):36-46.(in Chinese)
- 单鑫.2009.政府创新与地方治理:一个分析框架[J].武汉理工大学学报(社会科学版),22(1):38-44.Shan X.2009.An analytical framework of government innovation and local governance[J].Journal of Wuhan University of Technology(Social Sciences Edition),22(1):38-44.(in Chinese)
- 沈立人,戴园晨.1990.我国“诸侯经济”的形成及其弊端和根源[J].经济研究,(3):12-19,67.Shen L R,Dai Y C.1990.The formation of China's“prince economy”and its disadvantages and causes[J].Economic Research Journal,(3):12-19,67.(in Chinese)
- 斯托鲁莫夫·C S.2006.政府分权促进了政策创新吗?[J].刘承礼,译.经济社会体制比较,(2):3-11.Storumov C S.2006.Does government decentralization increase policy innovation?[J].Liu C L,trans.Comparative Economic and Social Systems,(2):3-11.(in Chinese)
- 孙荣,辛方坤.2010.地方政府竞争、制度创新与知识溢出[J].江苏行政学院学报,(5):96-100.Sun R,Xin F K.2010.Local government competition,institutional innovation and knowledge spillover[J].Journal of Jiangsu Administration Institute,(5):96-100.(in Chinese)
- 唐丽萍.2011.地方政府竞争中的制度创新及异化分析[J].上海行政学院学报,12(1):40-47.Tang L P.2011.Analysis of institutional innovation and alienation in local government competition[J].The Journal of Shanghai Administration Institute,12(1):40-47.(in Chinese)
- 唐志军.2011.地方政府竞争与中国经济增长[M].北京:中国经济出版社.Tang Z J.2011.Local government competition and China's economic growth[M].Beijing:China Economic Publishing House.(in Chinese)
- 王法硕.2019.地方政府创新执行主体如何提升“互联网+政务服务”创新效果?---一项基于扎根理论的质性研究[J].电子政务,(2):72-81.Wang F S.2019.How do local government innovation executives enhance the“internet+government service”innovation effect?-A qualitative study based on grounded theory[J].E-Government,(2):72-81.(in Chinese)
- 王汉生,王一鸽.2009.目标管理责任制:农村基层政权的实践逻辑[J].社会学研究,(2):61-92.Wang H S,Wang Y G.2009.Target management responsibility system:The practical logic of local party-state in rural China[J].Sociological Studies,(2):61-92.(in Chinese)
- 王焕祥,黄美花.2007.中国地方政府创新的可持续性问题研究[J].上海行政学院学报,8(6):20-27.Wang H X,Huang M H.2007.The research on the sustainability in Chinese local government innovations[J].The Journal of Shanghai Administration Institute,8(6):20-27.(in Chinese)
- 王焕祥,黄美花.2008.东西部地方政府创新制度化能力及其可持续性的实证比较[J].社会科学辑刊,(1):78-82.Wang H X,Huang M H.2008.An empirical and comparative study on institutional ability and sustainability in innovations between eastern and western local government[J].Social Science Journal,(1):78-82.(in Chinese)
- 王洛忠,刘金发.2007.招商引资过程中地方政府行为失范及其治理[J].中国行政管理,(2):72-75.Wang L Z,Liu J F.2007.Misconduct of local governments and its governance in the process of investment attraction[J].Chinese Public Administration,(2):72-75.(in Chinese)
- 王浦劬,赖先进.2013.中国公共政策扩散的模式与机制分析[J].北京大学学报(哲学社会科学版),50(6):14-23.Wang P Q,Lai X J.2013.A study on the model and mechanism of public policy diffusion in China[J].Journal of Peking University(Philosophy and Social Sciences),50(6):14-23.(in Chinese)
- 翁列恩.2017.地方政府创新的动因考察与测度研究[J].探索,(1):85-93.Weng L E.2017.Study on the motivation and measurement of local government innovation[J].Probe,(1):85-93.(in Chinese)
- 吴建南,马亮,杨宇谦.2007.中国地方政府创新的动因、特征与绩效---基于“中国地方政府创新奖”的多案例文本分析[J].管理世界,(8):43-51.Wu J N,Ma L,Yang Y Q.2007.The local governments'impetus for innovations,their characteristics and the related performance:An analysis of the test of cases adopted from“the awards for innovation to China's local governments”[J].Management World,(8):43-51.(in Chinese)
- 吴建南,马亮,苏婷,等.2011.政府创新的类型与特征---基于“中国地方政府创新奖”获奖项目的多案例研究[J].公共管理学报,8(1):94-103.Wu J N,Ma L,Su T,et al.2011.Typology and characteristics of government innovations:A multi-case study of winning programs of the innovations and excellence in Chinese local governance'[J].Journal of Public Management,8(1):94-103.(in Chinese)
- 吴理财,吴侗.2018.论地方政府创新韧性[J].江苏社会科学,(1):127-132.Wu L C,Wu D.2018.On the innovation tenacity of local government[J].Jiangsu Social Sciences,(1):127-132.(in Chinese)
- 吴理财,刘建.2019.地方政府创新的可持续性分析---基于“中国地方政府创新奖”中部地区获奖项目的跟踪调查[J].江汉论坛,(8):11-16.Wu L C,Liu J.2019.Sustainability analysis on local government innovation[J].Jianghan Tribune,(8):11-16.(in Chinese)
- 吴昀潇.2018.能动者视角下的地方政府创新差异---基于五届“中国地方政府创新奖”获奖项目的实证研究[J].中共福建省委党校学报,(7):82-87.Wu Y X.2018.The difference of innovation of local government from the perspective of activism[J].Journal of Fujian Party School,(7):82-87.(in Chinese)
- 徐东涛,郎友兴.2012.地方治理精英与制度创新的关联性分析:以杭州为例[J].浙江社会科学,(12):40-45,60.Xu D T,Lang Y X.2012.The relationship between local governing-elites and institutional innovations:A case study of Hangzhou[J].Zhejiang Social Sciences,(12):40-45,60.(in Chinese)
- 杨代福.2016.西方政策创新扩散研究的最新进展[J].国家行政学院学报,(1):122-126.Yang D F.2016.The latest development of Western policy innovation diffusion research[J].Journal of Chinese Academy of Governance,(1):122-126.(in Chinese)
- 杨宏山.2014.政策执行的路径-激励分析框架:以住房保障政策为例[J].政治学研究,(1):78-92.Yang H S.2014.The“path-incentive”framework of policy implementation[J].CASSJournal of Political Science,(1):