郭金元,陈志霞,元帅

• 1:华中科技大学公共管理学院

摘要(Abstract)：

近年来,繁文缛节在学界和管理实践中受到关注和重视的同时也存在某些分歧,厘清其概念内涵对于深化相关研究十分必要。本文从繁文缛节的词源解析出发,基于"有益说—有害说""功能功效说—心理过程模型""客观说—主观说"三种不同视角对繁文缛节观点进行分析讨论,立足学术研究和现实场域对其概念进行科学界定,并对繁文缛节与行政负担、行政延迟、正式化等相关概念进行比较分析,进一步明确了繁文缛节的概念内涵和外延。同时,总结介绍了繁文缛节的概念操作化及其测量,提出繁文缛节三维控制理论模型。最后,结合当前研究进展,提出繁文缛节未来研究的关键领域,并对其在中国的应用前景进行了讨论。文章为繁文缛节研究的理论演进及实践管理者提供了重要的理论基础。

关键词(KeyWords)： 繁文缛节;概念辨析;操作化;三维控制模型

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家社会科学基金重点项目“行为公共管理视角下创新互联网时代群众工作机制”(项目批准号:20AAZD019);; 教育部社科基金后期资助项目“行为公共管理视角的城市幸福指数及其影响因素研究”(项目批准号:18JHQ080);; 国家财政专项华中科技大学人文社科发展基金项目“行为公共管理实验室平台项目”(项目批准号:HUST2019)资助

作者(Author): 郭金元,陈志霞,元帅

参考文献(References)：

• 蒋来用．2019．形式主义的治理机制研究[J]．中共中央党校(国家行政学院)学报，23(6):125-132.Jiang L Y.2019.Institutional deficiency and remedy of formalist governance[J].Journal of the CCPS(CAG),23(6):125-132.(in Chinese)
• 李利文．2019．软性公共行政任务的硬性操作:基层治理中痕迹主义兴起的一个解释框架[J]．中国行政管理，(11):38-45.Li L W.2019.Rigid operation of soft public administration task:An interpretation framework for the rise of tracerism in grass-roots governance[J].Chinese Public Administration,(11):38-45.(in Chinese)
• 林民望．2015．西方繁文缛节研究前沿挈领---基于SSCI代表性文献的研究[J]．公共行政评论，8(5):154-172.Lin M W.2015.The cutting-edge research on red tape:Review of SSCI representative literatures[J].Journal of Public Administration,8(5):154-172.(in Chinese)
• 马亮．2010．作为一种官僚病的繁文缛节:评《官僚制与繁文缛节》[J]．公共行政评论，3(1):183-194.Ma L.2010.Red tape as one type of bureaucratic pathologies:A review on bureaucracy and red tape[J].Journal of Public Administration,3(1):183-194.(in Chinese)
• 马亮，孙晓燕．2012．繁文缛节的起源、特征与影响[J]．吉首大学学报(社会科学版)，33(6):87-95,123.Ma L,Sun X Y.2012.On the sources,characteristics and consequences of red tape:Aliterature review[J].Journal of Jishou University (Social Science Edition),33(6):87-95,123.(in Chinese)
• 宋世明．2016．优化政府组织结构:中国行政体制改革不可回避的关口[J]．理论探讨，(4):9-15.Song S M.2016.Optimising the structure of government and organisations:An unavoidable threshold during reforming the administrative system in China[J].Theoretical Investigation,(4):9-15.(in Chinese)
• 孙德超，周媛媛．2020．从繁文缛节到有效规则:精准扶贫目标置换问题的治理路径[J]．学术研究，(6):58-62.Sun D C,Zhou Y Y.2020.From red tape to green tape:The research on the goal displacement in the process of targeted poverty alleviation[J].Academic Research,(6):58-62.(in Chinese)
• 吴肃然．2013．论操作化:当代社会科学哲学的启示[J]．社会，33(5):59-87.Wu S R.2013.On operationalization:Inspirations from the contemporary philosophy of social sciences[J].Society,33(5):59-87.(in Chinese)
• 张小天．1994．论操作化[J]．社会学研究，(1):54-60.Zhang X T.1994.On operationalization[J].Sociological Studies,(1):54-60.(in Chinese)
• 邹劲松．2018．形式主义、官僚主义的新表现及其治理[J]．理论视野，(7):51-56.Zou J S.2018.Features and Embodiment of Pharisaism and Bureaucratism in“New Epoch”[J].Theoretical Horizon,(7):51-56.(in Chinese)
• Argyris C.1957.Personality and organization[M].New York:Harper and Row．
• Bakker A B,Van Veldhoven M,Xanthopoulou D.2010.Beyond the demand-control model[J].Journal of Personnel Psychology,9(1):3-16．
• Baldwin J N.1990.Perceptions of public versus private sector personnel and informal red tape:Their impact on motivation[J].The American Review of Public Administration,20(1):7-28．
• Blom R.2020.Mixed feelings?Comparing the effects of perceived red tape and job goal clarity on hrm satisfaction and organizational commitment across central government,government agencies,and businesses[J].Public Personnel Management,49(3):421-443．
• Blom R,Borst R T,Voorn B.2020.Pathology or inconvenience?A meta-analysis of the impact of red tape on people and organizations[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration.doi:10.1177/0734371X20924117．
• Borry E L.2016.A new measure of red tape:Introducing the three-item red tape (TIRT) scale[J].International Public Management Journal,19(4):573-593．
• Borst R T.2018.Comparing work engagement in people-changing and people-processing service providers:A mediation model with red tape,autonomy,dimensions of PSM,and performance[J].Public Personnel Management,47(3):287-313．
• Borst R T,Kruyen P M,Lako C J.2019.Exploring the job demands-resources model of work engagement in government:Bringing in a psychological perspective[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,39(3):372-397．
• Bozeman B,Reed P N,Scott P.1992.Red tape and task delays in public and private organizations[J].Administration&Society,24(3):290-322．
• Bozeman B.1993.A theory of government“red tape”[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,(3):273-303．
• Bozeman B,Scott P.1996.Bureaucratic red tape and formalization:Untangling conceptual knots[J].The American Review of Public Administration,26(1):1-17．
• Bozeman B.2000.Bureaucracy and red tape[M].Upper Saddle River,New Jersey:Prentice Hall．
• Bozeman B,Feeney M K.2011.Rules and red tape:A prism for public administration theory and research[M].New York:M.E.Sharpe．
• Bozeman B.2012.Multidimensional red tape:A theory coda[J].International Public Management Journal,15(3):245-265．
• Bozeman B,Anderson D M.2016.Public policy and the origins of bureaucratic red tape:Implications of the stanford yacht scandal[J].Administration&Society,48(6):736-759．
• Bretschneider S.1990.Management information systems in public and private organizations:An empirical test[J].Public Administration Review,50(5):536-545．
• Bretschneider S,Parker M.2016.Organization formalization,sector and social media:Does increased standardization of policy broaden and deepen social media use in organizations?[J].Government Information Quarterly,33(4):614-628．
• Brewer G A,Walker R M.2010.The impact of red tape on governmental performance:An empirical analysis[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,20 (1):233-257．
• Brewer G A,Walker R M,Bozeman B,et al.2012.External control and red tape:The mediating effects of client and organizational feedback[J].International Public Management Journal,15(3):288-314．
• Buchanan B.1975.Red-tape andthe service ethic:Some unexpected differences between public and private managers[J].Administration&Society,6(4):423-444．
• Burden B C,Canon D T,Mayer K R,et al.2012.The effect of administrative burden on bureaucratic perception of policies:Evidence from election administration[J].Public Administration Review,72(5):741-751．
• Campbell J W.2019.Obtrusive,obstinate and conspicuous:Red tape from a heideggerian perspective[J].International Journal of Organizational Analysis,27(5):1657-1672．
• Campbell J W.2020.Red tape,rule burden,and legitimate performance trade-offs:Results from a vignette experiment[J].Public Performance&Management Review,43 (4):741-765．
• Chen C A.2012.Sector imprinting:Exploring its impacts on managers’perceived formalized personnel rules,perceived red tape,and current job tenure[J].The American Review of Public Administration,42(3):320-340．
• Christensen J,Aare L,Baekgaard M,et al.2020.Human capital and administrative burden:The role of cognitive resources in citizen-state interactions[J].Public Administration Review,80(1):127-136．
• Cooke D K,Brant K K,Woods J M.2019.The role of public service motivation in employee work engagement:A test of the job demands-resources model[J].International Journal of Public Administration,42(9):765-775．
• Coursey D H,Pandey S K.2007.Content domain,measurement,and validity of the red tape concept:A second-order confirmatory factor analysis[J].The American Review of Public Administration,37(3):342-361．
• Crawford E R,Le Pine J A,Rich B L.2010.Linking job demands and resources to employee engagement and burnout:A theoretical extension and meta-analytic test[J].Journal of Applied Psychology,95(5):834-848．
• Davies R B.2013.The silver lining of red tape[J].Journal of Public Economics,101:68-76．
• Davis R S.2013.Union commitment and stakeholder red tape:How union values shape perceptions of organizational rules[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,33(4):365-383．
• Davis R S,Pink-Harper S A.2016.Connecting knowledge of rule-breaking and perceived red tape:How behavioral attribution influences red tape perceptions[J].Public Performance&Management Review,40(1):181-200．
• De Jong G,Van Witteloostuijn A.2015.Regulatory red tape and private firm performance[J].Public Administration,93(1):34-51．
• De Hart-Davis L,Bozeman B.2001.Regulatory compliance and air quality permitting:Why do firms overcomply?[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,11 (4):471-508．
• De Hart-Davis L,Pandey S K.2005.Red tape and public employees:Does perceived rule dysfunction alienate managers?[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,15(1):133-148．
• De Hart-Davis L,Chen J,Little T D.2013.Written versus unwritten rules:The role of rule formalization in green tape[J].International Public Management Journal,16 (3):331-356．
• De Hart-Davis L.2014.Opening the black box of red tape research[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,24(4):1072-1076．
• Doty D H,Glick W H.1998.Common methods bias:Does common methods variance really bias results?[J].Organizational Research Methods,1(4):374-406．
• Feeney M K,Bozeman B.2009.Stakeholder red tape:Comparing perceptions of public managers and their private consultants[J].Public Administration Review,69 (4):710-726．
• Feeney M K,De Hart-Davis L.2009.Bureaucracy and public employee behavior:A case of local government[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,29(4):311-326．
• Feeney M K.2012.Organizational red tape:A measurement experiment[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,22(3):427-444．
• FontagnéL,Orefice G,Piermartini R.2020.Making small firms happy?The heterogeneous effect of trade facilitation measures[J].Review of International Economics,28 (3):565-598．
• Hattke F,Hensel D,Kalucza J.2020.Emotional responses to bureaucratic red tape[J].Public Administration Review,80(1):53-63．
• Heinrich C J.2016.The bite of administrative burden:A theoretical and empirical investigation[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,26(3):403-420．
• Herd P,Moynihan D P.2018.Administrative burden:Policymaking by other means[M].New York:Russell Sage Foundation．
• Hofstede G.2001.Culture’s consequences:Comparing values,behaviors,institutions,and organizations across nations[M].Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage Publications．
• Hong S.2020.Performance management meets red tape:Bounded rationality,negativity bias,and resource dependence[J].Public Administration Review,80(6):932-945．
• Jacobsen C B,Jakobsen M L.2018.Perceived organizational red tape and organizational performance in public services[J].Public Administration Review,78(1):24-36．
• James O.2011.Performance measures and democracy:Information effects on citizens in field and laboratory experiments[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,21(3):399-418．
• Jung J,Bozeman B,Gaughan M.2020.Fear in bureaucracy:Comparing public and private sector workers’expectations of punishment[J].Administration&Society,52 (2):233-264．
• Kaufman H.1977.Red tape:Its origins,uses,and abuses[M].Washington:Brookings Institution Press．
• Kaufmann W,Feeney M K.2012.Objective formalization,perceived formalization and perceived red tape:Sorting out concepts[J].Public Management Review,14 (8):1195-1214．
• Kaufmann W,Van Witteloostuijn A.2012.European and national rules as potential red tape drivers:An ecological analysis of the europeanization of dutch competition law,1962-2010[J].International Public Management Journal,15(3):266-287．
• Kaufmann W,Feeney M K.2014.Beyond the rules:The effect of outcome favourability on red tape perceptions[J].Public Administration,92(1):178-191．
• Kaufmann W,Hooghiemstra R,Feeney M K.2018.Formal institutions,informal institutions,and red tape:A comparative study[J].Public Administration,96(2):386-403．
• Kaufmann W,Van Witteloostuijn A.2018.Do rules breed rules?Vertical rule-making cascades at the supranational,national,and organizational level[J].International Public Management Journal,21(4):650-676．
• Kaufmann W,Borry E L,De Hart-Davis L.2019a.More than pathological formalization:Understanding organizational structure and red tape[J].Public Administration Review,79(2):236-245．
• Kaufmann W,Taggart G,Bozeman B.2019b.Administrative delay,red tape,and organizational performance[J].Public Performance&Management Review,42 (3):529-553．
• Kaufmann W,Haans R F J.2021.Understanding the meaning of concepts across domains through collocation analysis:An application to the study of red tape[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,31(1):218-233．
• Kaufmann W,Ingrams A,Jacobs D.2021.Being consistent matters:Experimental evidence on the effect of rule consistency on citizen red tape[J].The American Review of Public Administration,51(1):28-39．
• Krogh Madsen J,Sass Mikkelsen K,Moynihan D.2020.Burdens,sludge,ordeals,red tape,oh my!A user’s guide to the study of frictions[J].Public Administration.doi:10.1111/padm.12717．
• Li M H,Feeney M K.2014.Adoption of electronic technologies in local U.S.Governments:Distinguishing between e-services and communication technologies[J].The American Review of Public Administration,44(1):75-91．
• Luton L S.2007.Deconstructing public administration empiricism[J].Administration&Society,39(4):527-544．
• Merton R K.1940.Bureaucratic structure and personality[J].Social Forces,18(4):560-568．
• Michaud K E H,Carlisle J E,Smith E R A N.2009.The relationship between cultural values and political ideology,and the role of political knowledge[J].Political Psychology,30(1):27-42．
• Moon M J,Kim J,Jung S,et al.2020.What makes administrative and hierarchical procedures more burdensome?Effects of degree of procedures,outcome favorability,and confucian values on red tape perception[J].Public Performance&Management Review,43 (6):1237-1259．
• Moynihan D P,Herd P,Harvey H.2014.Administrative burden:Learning,psychological,and compliance costs in citizen-state interactions[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,25(1):43-69．
• Moynihan D P,Pandey S K.2007.The role of organizations in fostering public service motivation[J].Public Administration Review,67(1):40-53．
• Moynihan D P,Vandenabeele W,Blom-Hansen J.2013.Debate:Advancing public service motivation research[J].Public Money&Management,33(4):288-289．
• Moynihan D P.2017.Commentary:Mapping a more specialized public administration[J].Public Administration Review,77(4):512-514．
• Oberfield Z.2019.Unionization and street-level bureaucracy:An examination of public school teachers in the united states[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration.doi:10.1177/0734371X19894376．
• Pandey S K,Bretschneider S I.1997.The impact of red tape’s administrative delay on public organizations’interest in new information technologies[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,7(1):113-130．
• Pandey S K,Kingsley G A.2000.Examining red tape in public and private organizations:Alternative explanations from a social psychological model[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,10(4):779-799．
• Pandey S K,Scott P G.2002.Red tape:A review and assessment of concepts and measures[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,12(4):553-580．
• Pandey S K,Moynihan D P.2005.Bureaucratic red tape and organizational performance:Testing the moderating role of culture and political support[M]//Boyne G A,Meier K J,O’Toole L J Jr,et al.Public Service Performance:Perspectives on Measurement and Management.Cambridge,England:Cambridge University Press,130-151．
• Pandey S K,Welch E W.2005.Beyond stereotypes:A multistage model of managerial perceptions of red tape[J].Administration&Society,37(5):542-575．
• Pandey S K,Coursey D H,Moynihan D P.2007.Organizational effectiveness and bureaucratic red tape:A multimethod study[J].Public Performance&Management Review,30(3):398-425．
• Pandey S K,Marlowe J.2015.Assessing survey-based measurement of personnel red tape with anchoring vignettes[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,35(3):215-237．
• Peeters R,Widlak A.2018.The digital cage:Administrative exclusion through information architecture-The case of the Dutch civil registry’s master data management system[J].Government Information Quarterly,35(2):175-183．
• Peeters R.2020.The political economy of administrative burdens:A theoretical framework for analyzing the organizational origins of administrative burdens[J].Administration&Society,52(4):566-592．
• Pollitt C.2017.Public administration research since 1980:Slipping away from the real world?[J].International Journal of Public Sector Management,30(6/7):555-565．
• Pugh D S,Hickson D J,Hinings C R,et al.1968.Dimensions of organization structure[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,13(1):65-105．
• Quratulain S,Khan A K.2015.Red tape,resigned satisfaction,public service motivation,and negative employee attitudes and behaviors:Testing a model of moderated mediation[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,35(4):307-332．
• Rainey H G,Backoff R W,Levine C H.1976.Comparing public and private organizations[J].Public Administration Review,36(2):233-244．
• Rainey H G,Pandey S,Bozeman B.1995.Research note:Public and private managers’perceptions of red tape[J].Public Administration Review,55(6):567-574．
• Rosenfeld R A.1984.An expansion and application of kaufman’s model of red tape:The case of community development block grants[J].Western Political Quarterly,37(4):603-620．
• Schlager E.2013.Rules and red tape:A prism for public administration theory and research by Barry Bozeman and Mary K.Feeney[J].International Public Management Journal,16(2):328-330．
• Scott P G,Pandey S K.2000.The influence of red tape on bureaucratic behavior:An experimental simulation[J].Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,19 (4):615-633．
• Scott P G,Pandey S K.2005.Red tape and public service motivation:Findings from a national survey of managers in state health and human services agencies[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,25(2):155-180．
• Steijn B,Van Der Voet J.2019.Relational job characteristics and job satisfaction of public sector employees:When prosocial motivation and red tape collide[J].Public Administration,97(1):64-80．
• Triandis H C.2001.Individualism-collectivism and personality[J].Journal of Personality,69(6):907-924．
• Tummers L,Weske U,Bouwman R,et al.2016.The impact of red tape on citizen satisfaction:An experimental study[J].International Public Management Journal,19(3):320-341．
• Van Eijk C,Steen T,Torenvlied R.2019.Public professionals’engagement in coproduction:The impact of the work environment on elderly care managers’perceptions on collaboration with client councils[J].The American Review of Public Administration,49(6):733-748．
• Van Loon N M,Leisink P L M,Knies E,et al.2016.Red tape:Developing and validating a new job-centered measure[J].Public Administration Review,76(4):662-673．
• Van Loon N M.2017.From red tape to which performance results?Exploring the relationship between red tape and various dimensions of performance in healthcare work units[J].Public Administration,95(1):60-77．
• Vento I,Kuokkanen K.2020.Mapping the post-bureaucratic landscape:Project managers’perception of bureaucracy in european union cohesion policy projects[J].International Review of Administrative Sciences.doi:10.1177/0020852320969801．
• Waldo D.1946.Government by procedure[M]//Marx F M.Elements of Public Administration.New York:Prentice Hall,381-399．
• Walker R M,Brewer G A.2008.An organizational echelon analysis of the determinants of red tape in public organizations[J].Public Administration Review,68(6):1112-1127．
• Wandschneider P R.1979.Red tape:Its origins,uses and abuses[J].Journal of Economic Issues,13(1):250-253．
• Wright B E.2015.The science of public administration:Problems,presumptions,progress,and possibilities[J].Public Administration Review,75(6):795-805．
• Zhu L,Witko C,Meier K J.2019.The public administration manifestoⅡ:Matching methods to theory and substance[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,29(2):287-298.