徐建华,薛澜,寿明佳

• 1:北京大学环境科学与工程学院环境管理系
• 2:清华大学公共管理学院
• 3:杭州电子科技大学研究生院

摘要(Abstract)：

环境社会治理的本质是环境多元共治,是对公众参与的拓展。实现良好的环境社会治理需要政府创造合适的制度条件让多方参与进来。而创造合适的制度条件又需要从根本上理解人对环境风险的认知(即主观判断)及其影响因素。本文通过梳理国内外近半个世纪以来在环境风险认知领域的有关研究,分析和总结了影响人们环境风险认知的因素,并指出我国当下对风险认知相关问题探讨时存在的误区,提出我国学者未来在相关领域需要重点关注的方面。

关键词(KeyWords)： 社会治理;环境风险;风险认知

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金项目“新时期中国特色应急管理体系的顶层设计和模式重构”(编号:91224009)和“我国大气污染风险管理中的风险沟通研究”(编号:71303013)资助

作者(Author): 徐建华,薛澜,寿明佳

参考文献(References)：

• (1)陶格斯:《中国环境问题的历史变化》,《环境科学与管理》2009年第8期。
• (2)中华人民共和国环境保护部:《2012年中国环境状况公报》,www.mep.gov.cn/gzfw/xzzx/201403/P020140312404905083358.pdf。
• (3)董文福、傅德黔:《近年来我国环境污染事故综述》,《环境科学与技术》2009年第7期。
• (4)《中共中央关于全面深化改革若干重大问题的决定》于2013年11月12日中国共产党第十八届中央委员会第三次全体会议通过,http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/2013-11/12/c_118113455.htm。
• (5)Slovic P.,"Trust,Emotion,Sex,Politics,and Science;Surveying the Risk-assessment Battlefield,"Risk Analysis,1999(19),pp.689-701;Covello V.T.,"The Perception of Technological Risks:a Literature Review,"Technological Forecasting and Social Change,1983(23),pp.285-297.
• (1)《中华人民共和国环境保护法》于1989年12月26日第七届全国人民代表大会常务委员会第十一次会议通过,2014年4月24日第十二届全国人民代表大会常务委员会第八次会议修订。
• (2)Slovic P.,"Perception of Risk,"Science,1987(236),pp.280-285.
• (3)Wilson R.,"Analyzing the Daily Risks of Life,"Technology Review,1979,pp.41-46.
• (4)Ramsberg J.,Sj(o|¨)berg L.,"The Cost-effectiveness of Life Saving Interventions in Sweden,"Risk Analysis,1997(17),pp.467-478;Breyer S.,Breaking the Vicious Circle;Toward Effective Risk Regulation,Cambridge;Harvard University Press,1993;Zeckhauser R.J.,Viscusi W.K.,"The Risk Management Dilemma,"Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science,1996(545),pp.144-155.
• (1)Van der Plight J.,"Risk Perception and Self-protective Behavior,"European Psychologist,1996(1),pp.34-43.
• (2)National Research Council,Improving Risk Communication.Washington,D.C.:National Academy Press,1989.
• (3)Pidgeon N.F.,Hood C.,Jones D.etc.,Risk perception.Ch 5 of Risk-Analysis,Perception and Management:Report of a Royal Society Study Group,London;The Royal Society,1992,pp.89-134.
• (4)Kasperson R.E.,Renn 0.,Slovic P.,etc.,"The Social Amplification of Risk:a Conceptual Framework,"Risk Analysis,1988(8),pp.177-187.
• (5)Aven T.,"The Risk Concept-Historical and Recent Development Trends,"Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2012(99),pp.33-44.
• (6)Tversky A.,Kahneman D.,"Judgment under Uncertainty:Heuristics and Biases,"Science,1974(185),pp.1124-1131.
• (1)天花,维生素中毒,肉毒杆菌中毒,麻疹,燃放烟花爆竹,注射天花疫苗,百日咳,骨髓灰质炎,蚊虫蛇蝎叮咬,龙卷风,闪电,无毒动物,洪水,极寒,梅毒,怀孕、分娩和堕胎,传染性肝炎,阑尾炎,触电,机动车-火车撞车,哮喘,擦枪走火,固体或液体中毒,肺结核,火灾,溺水,白血病,意外摔倒,他杀,肺气肿,自杀,乳腺癌,糖尿病,机动车事故,肺癌,消化系统癌变,所有事故,中风,所有癌症,心脏病,所有疾病。
• (2)Lichtenstein S.,Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,etc.,"Judged Frequency of Lethal Events,"Journal of Experimental Psychology:Human Learning and Memory,1978(4),pp.551-578.
• (3)核电,消防,滑雪,机动车,大型工程,X光照射,枪械,狩猎,高中和大学足球运动,吸烟,喷雾剂产品,铁路,摩托车,爬山,食品防腐剂,含酒精饮料,骑自行车,食用色素,私家飞机,商业飞机,电动割草机,警察,火力发电,处方抗生素,杀虫剂,游泳,家用电器,手术,避孕药,疫苗注射。
• (4)Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S."Rating the Risks,"Environment:Science and Policy for Sustainable Development,1979(21),pp.14-39.
• (5)Zhang J.,"Environmental Hazards in the Chinese Public's Eyes,"Risk Analysis,1994(14),pp.163-167.
• (6)Sj(o|¨)berg L.,"Risk Perception by the Public and by Experts;a Dilemma in Risk Management,"Human Ecology Review,1999(6),pp.1-9.
• (7)Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S.,"Rating the Risks,"Environment;Science and Policy for Sustainable Development,1979(21),pp.14-39;Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S.,"Characterizing Perceived Risk,"In R.W.Kates,C.Hohenemser,J.X.Kasperson(Eds.),Perilous Progress;Managing the Hazards of Technology,Boulder,CO:Westview,1985,pp.91-125.
• (8)Lichtenstein S.,Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,etc.,"Judged Frequency of Lethal Events,"Journal of Experimental Psychology:Human Learning and Memory,1978(4),pp.551-578;Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S.,"Characterizing Perceived Risk,"In R.W.Kates,C.Hohenemser,J.X.Kasperson(Eds.),Perilous Progress;Managing the Hazards of Technology,Boulder,CO;Westview,1985,pp.91-125.
• (9)Covello V.T.,"The Perception of Technological Risks:a Literature Review,"Technological Forecasting and Social Change,1983(23),pp.285-297.
• (1)Fischhoff B.,Watson S.R.,Hope C.,"Defining Risk,"Policy Sciences,1984(17),pp.123-139.
• (2)Slovic P.,Perceptions of Risk:Reflections on the Psychometric Paradigm.In S.Krimsky&D.Golding(Eds.),Social Theories of Risk.Westport,CT:Praeger.1992,117-152.
• (3)Boholm A.,"Comparative Studies of Risk Perception:a Review of Twenty Years of Research,"Journal of Risk Research,1998(1),pp.135—163;奥尔特温·雷恩,伯内德·罗尔曼编著《跨文化的风险感知:经验研究的总结》,赵延东、张虎彪译,北京出版社,2007。
• (4)地震,洪水,水污染,大气污染,水土流失,沙漠化,火灾,台风,泥石流,龙卷风,干旱,杀虫剂使用,生物病虫害,噪声,火山,冰雹,寒流,化肥,雪灾,海浪。
• (5)Zhang J.,"Environmental Hazards in the Chinese Public's Eyes,"Risk Analysis,1994(14),pp.163-167.
• (6)核武器,战争,枪械,滴滴涕使用,犯罪,核电,杀虫剂使用,吸烟,吸食海洛因,饮酒,机动车事故,化肥使用,放疗,口服避孕药,体检X光照射,食品防腐剂,DNA研究,微波炉使用,商业航空,烟花爆竹,咖啡因,怀孕、生产,食品染色剂,铁路,核电外的其他发电形式,外太空探索,骑自行车,休闲船艇,化妆品,日光浴。
• (1)Keown C.F.,"Risk Perceptions of Hong Kongese vs.Americans,"Risk Analysis,1989(9),pp.401-405.
• (2)Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S.,"Rating the Risks,"Environment:Science and Policy for Sustainable Development,1979(21):14-39;Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S.,"Characterizing Perceived Risk,"In R.W.Kates,C.Hohenemser,J.X.Kasperson(Eds.),Perilous Progress;Managing the Hazards of Technology,Boulder,CO:Westview,1985,pp.91-125.
• (3)机动车污染,来自核电站的放射性物质,化学品废物,二手烟,交通噪声,疏浚和倾倒,细菌和微生物,过度捕鱼,建筑材料的放射性,酸雨,自然栖息地的丧失,室内空气质量,湿地的消失,生物多样性的丧失,视觉污染问题,水资源短缺,海豚的减少,人类基因改造,农药和除草剂,煤的减少.转基因食品,洪水和海啸,暴风雨,地震,风水的破坏。
• (4)Lai J.C.,Tao J.,"Perception of Environmental Hazards in Hong Kong Chinese,"Risk Analysis,2003(23):669-684.
• (5)Gregory R.,Mendelsohn R.,"Perceived Risk,Dread,and Benefits,"Risk Analysis,1993(13),pp.259-264.
• (6)Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S.,Characterizing Perceived Risk.In R.W.Kates,C.Hohenemser,J.X.Kasperson(Eds.),Perilous Progress:Managing the Hazards of Technology,Boulder,CO;Westview,1985,pp.91-125.
• (7)Zhang J.,"Environmental Hazards in the Chinese Public's Eyes,"Risk Analysis,1994(14),pp.163-167.
• (1)Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S.,Characterizing Perceived Risk.In R.W.Kates,C.Hohenemser,J.X.Kasperson(Eds.),Perilous Progress;Managing the Hazards of Technology,Boulder,CO:Westview,1985,pp.91-125.
• (2)Gregory R.,Mendelsohn R."Perceived Risk,Dread,and Benefits,"Risk Analysis,1993(13),pp.259-264.
• (3)Slovic P.,Finucane M.L.,Peters E.,etc.,"Risk as Analysis and Risk as Feelings;Some Thoughts about Affect,Reason,Risk and Rationality,"Risk Analysis,2004(24),pp.311-322;Kahneman D.,Think Fast and Slow.New York;Farrar,Straus and Giroux,New York,2011.
• (1)Sj(o|¨)berg L.,"Factors in Risk Perception,"Risk Analysis,2000(20),pp.1-11.
• (2)Fischhoff B.,Slovic P.,Lichtenstein S.,"How Safe is Safe Enough?A Psychometric Study of Attitudes Towards Technological Risks,"Policy Sciences,1978(9),pp.127-152.
• (3)Tilt B.,"Perceptions of Risk from Industrial Pollution in China;A Comparison of Occupational Groups,"Human Organization,2006(65),pp.115-127.
• (4)Jasanoff S.,"The Political Science of Risk Perception,"Reliability Engineering and System Safety,1998(59),pp.91-99.
• (5)Savage I.,"Demographic Influences on Risk Perceptions,"Risk Analysis,1993(13),pp.413-420.
• (1)Lai J.C.,Tao J.,"Perception of Environmental Hazards in Hong Kong Chinese,"Risk Analysis,2003(23),pp.669-684.
• (2)吸烟,街头吸毒,艾滋病,压力,化学品污染,核废料,机动车事故,饮酒,日光浴,臭氧层耗损,食品残留农药,室外大气污染,输血,燃煤、燃油或热电厂,气候变化,食品里的细菌,核电站,食品辐照,暴雨和洪水,遗传学工程师细菌,室内氡污染,高压输电线,视频显示终端(VDTs),医用X光照射,商业航空旅行。
• (3)Flynn J.,Slovic P.,Mertzl C.K.,"Gender,Race,and Perception of Environmental Health Risks,"Risk Analysis,1994(14),pp.1101-1108.
• (4)Finucane M.L.,Slovic P.,Mertz C.K.,etc.,"Gender,Race,and Perceived Risk;the'White Male'Effect,"Health,Risk&Society,2000(2),pp.159-172.
• (5)Kahan D.M.,Braman D.,Gastil J.,etc.,"Culture and Identity-protective Cognition:Explaining the White-male Effect in Risk Perception,"Journal of Empirical Legal Studies,2007(4),pp.465-505.
• (6)王甫勤:《风险社会与当前中国民众的风险认知研究》,《上海行政学院学报》2010年第2期。
• (7)龚识懿、杨洁、孟庆艳等:《无锡公众太湖蓝藻风险感知分析》,《苏州科技学院学报》(工程技术版)2010年第1期。
• (8)Slovic P.,"Trust,Emotion,Sex,Politics,and Science:Surveying the Risk-assessment Battlefield,"Risk Analysis,1999(19),pp.689-701;Flynn J.,Slovic P.,Mertzl C.K.,"Gender,Race,and Perception of Environmental Health Risks,"Risk Analysis,1994(14),pp.1101-1108;Gustafson P.E.,"Gender Differences in Risk Perception;Theoretical and Methodological Perspectives,"Risk Analysis,1998(18),pp.805-811.
• (1)Kung Y.,Chen S.,"Perception of Earthquake Risk in Taiwan;Effects of Gender and Past Earthquake Experience,"Risk Analysis,2012(32),pp.1535-1546;Johnson B.B.,"Gender and Race in Beliefs about Outdoor Air Pollution,"Risk Analysis,2002(22),pp.725-738.
• (2)朱可瑁、徐建华:《城市大气污染的风险认知研究评述与展望》,《北京大学学报》(自然科学版)2014年第5期。
• (3)Olofsson A.,Rashid S.,"The White(male)Effect and Risk Perception:Can Equality Make a Difference?"Risk Analysis,2011(31),pp.1016-1032.
• (4)寿明佳:《北京公众环境风险认知研究——以北京高校学生为例》,硕士学位论文,北京大学,2013。
• (1)Sj(o|¨))berg L.,"The Allegedly Simple Structure of Experts'Risk Perception;an Urban Legend in Risk Research,"Science,Technology&Human Values,2002(27),pp.443-459.
• (2)Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S.,"Rating the Risks,"Environment;Science andPolicy for Sustainable Development,1979(21),pp.14-39;Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S.,"Characterizing Perceived Risk,"In R.W.Kates,C.Hohenemser,J.X.Kasperson(Eds.),Perilous progress;Managing the hazards of technology,Boulder,CO;Westview,1985,pp.91—125.
• (3)Sj(o|¨)berg L.,Drottz-SjSberg B.,"Risk Perception by Politicians and the Public,"Energy&Environment,2008(19),pp.455-483.
• (1)吸烟,饮酒,工业污染,境外核电站,机动车尾气,臭氧层破坏,失业,经济严重恶化,生病时没有足够的医疗保障,室内氡污染,严重的交通事故,辐照食品,阳光照射,入室盗窃,温室效应,电磁场,不良饮食习惯,放射性废物储存库的核辐射,运输核废料过程中带来的风险,大量核废弃物,袭击,瑞典境内的核电站,食品短缺,自然本地辐射,X光检查,被闪电击中。
• (2)Flynn J.,Burns W.,Mertz C.K.,etc.,"Trust as a Determinant of Opposition to a High-level Radioactive Waste Repository:Analysis of a Structural Model,"Risk Analysis,1992(12),pp.417-429.
• (3)Viklund M.J.,"Trust and Risk Perception in Western Europe:A Cross-national Study,"Risk Analysis,2003(23),pp.727-738.
• (4)黄蕾、毕军、杨洁等:《连云港公众对核电和火电风险感知的比较分析》,《安全与环境学报》2009年第4期。
• (5)沈鸿、孙雪萍、苏筠:《科技信任、管理信任及其对公众水灾风险认知的影响——基于长江中下游的社会调查》,《灾害学》2012年第1期。
• (1)Barnett J.,Breakwell G.M.,"Risk Perception and Experience;Hazard Personality Profiles and Individual Differences,"Risk Analysis,2002(21),pp.171-178.
• (2)Peacock W.G.,Brody S.D.,Highfield W.,"Hurricane Risk Perceptions among Florida's Single Family Homeowners,"Landscape and Urban Planning,2005(73),pp.120-135.
• (3)Kung Y.,Chen S.,"Perception of Earthquake Risk in Taiwan;Effects of Gender and Past Earthquake Experience,"Risk Analysis,2012(32),pp.1535-1546.
• (4)Bouyer M.,Bagdassarian S.,Chaabanne S.,etc.,"Personality Correlates of Risk Perception,"Risk Anal"ysis,2001(21),pp.457-466.
• (5)谢晓非、徐联仓:《一般社会情境中风险认知的实验研究》,《心理科学》1998年第4期。
• (6)Sandman P.M.,"Mass Media and Environmental Risks;Seven Principles,"Risk;Health,Safety&Environment,1994,pp.251-260.
• (1)Wahlberg A.A.F.,Sjaberg L.,"Risk Perception and the Media,"Journal of Risk Research,2000,3(1),pp.31-50.
• (2)Combs B.,Slovic P.,"Newspaper Coverage of Causes of Death,"Journalism Quarterly,1979(56),pp.837-843.
• (3)王甫勤:《风险社会与当前中国民众的风险认知研究》,《上海行政学院学报》2010年第2期。
• (4)Sj(o|¨)berg L.,Risk Perception in Western Europe 10 Years after the Chernobyl Accident In K.Andersson(Ed.),Values in Decisions on Risk,1999,pp.343-351.
• (5)Binder A.R.,Scheufele D.A.,Brossard D.,etc.,"Interpersonal Amplification of Risk?Citizen Discussions and their Impact on Perceptions of Risks and Benefits of a Biological Research Facility,"Risk Analysis,2010(31),pp.324-334.
• (6)Brenkert-Smith H.,Dickinson K.L.,Champ P.A.,etc.,"Social Amplification of Wildfire Risk;the Role of Social Interactions and Information Sources,"Risk Analysis,2013(33),pp.800-817.
• (7)Douglas M.,Wildavsky A.,Risk and Culture:An Essay on the Selection of Technological and Environmental Dangers,University of California Press,1983.
• (1)周志家:《环境保护、群体压力还是利益波及——厦门居民Px环境运动参与行为的动机分析》,《社会》2011年第1期。
• (2)Mileti D.,"Human Adjustment to the Risk of Environmental Extremes,"Sociology and Social Research,1980(64),pp.328-347.
• (3)Arrow K.J.,"Risk Perception in Psychology and Economics,"Economic Inquiry,1982,20(1);Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S.,"Behavioral Decision Theory,"Annual Review of Psychology,1977(28),pp.1-39.
• (4)Bier V.M.,"On the State of the Art;Risk Communication to the Public,"Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2001(71),pp.139-150.
• (5)Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S.,"Why Study Risk Perception?"Risk Analysis,1982(2),pp.83-93.
• (1)Lai J.C.,Tao J.,"Perception of Environmental Hazards in Hong Kong Chinese,"Risk Analysis,2003(23),pp.669-684;Willis H.H.,DeKay M.L,Fischhoff B.,etc.,"Aggregate,Disaggregate,and Hybrid analyses of Ecological Risk Perceptions,"Risk Analysis,2005(25),pp.405-428;McDaniels T.,Axelrod L.J.,Slovic P.,"Perceived Ecological Risks of Global Change-A Psychometric Comparison of Causes and Consequences,"Global Environmental Change:Human and Policy Dimensions,1996(6),pp.159-171.
• (1)Jasanoff S.,"The Political Science of Risk Perception,"Reliability Engineering and System Safety,1998(59),pp.91-99.