试论比较政治经济学的非意识形态性及其在我国发展的现实意义The Non-ideological Nature of the Practical Significance of Comparative Political Economy in China's Development
张严冰
摘要(Abstract)：
英国甘布尔教授提出一个理解西方古典政治经济学的思路,即古典理论实际上大都隐含着三种自成体系但又相互联系的话语,包括政策话语或实践话语、理想话语、科学话语。本文尝试对西方新政治经济学,大体包括比较政治经济学、国际政治经济学、新古典政治经济学,根据此三种不同的话语进行解析,并讨论比较政治经济学在我国发展的现实意义。首先,笔者简单地评介甘布尔关于古典政治经济学具有三种话语的观点,引入意识形态的概念;其次,在第二部分尝试把新政治经济学解构成三种话语并分析它们的意识形态性;最后,从三个角度分析比较政治经济学在中国发展的现实意义。
关键词(KeyWords)： 比较政治经济学;新政治经济学;意识形态
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 张严冰
参考文献(References)：
- [1]Marx Kari.A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy,available at:http://www.marxists. org/archive/marx/works/1859/critique-pol-economy/preface.htm.
- [2]Gamble Andrew.The New Political Economy.Political Studies,1995,(3).
- [2]Hey wood Andrew.Political Ideologies:an Introduction.Basingstoke:Palgrave Macmillan,2003.
- [3]关于古典自由主义和马克思主义,见Caporaso和Levine的Theories of Politial economy第2、3章。Caporaso James A,Levine David P.Theories of political economy.New York:Cambridge,Cambridge University Press:1992.
- [4]Marx Karl,Engels Frederick.The German Ideology,available at http://www.marxists.org/archive/ marx/works/1845/german-ideology/ch01b.htm.
- [5]Lenin V 1.(1902),What Is To Be Done?,available at http://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/ works/1901/witbd/ii.htm# v05fl61h-373-GUESS.
- [6]Foucault Michel.Power:Essential Works of Michel Foucault 1954—1984 v.3.London,Penguin Books,2002.
- [1]Kuhn Thomas S.The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.Chicago,London:University of Chicago Press,1970.
- [2]Hayek Friedrich A.von.The Constitution of Liberty.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul,1960.
- [3]关于意识形态的简单介绍,见Freeden,Michael.Ideology:A Very Short Introduction.Oxford:Oxford University Press,2003.
- [4]Skinner Quentin.The Foundations of Modern Political Thought.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,pxiii,1928.
- [1]杨龙.从政治经济学到新政治经济学——西方政治经济理论的演变.哈尔滨工业大学学报:社会科学版, 2000,(1).汪丁丁.试述新政治经济学的三个维度.北京大学学报:哲学社会科学版,2005,(6).汪丁丁.中国的新政治经济学的可能依据——行为和意义的综合视角.社会科学战线,2004,(3).
- [2]陈振明,黄新华.政治经济学的复兴——西方“新政治经济学”的兴起、主题与意义.厦门大学学报:哲学社会科学版,2004,(1).黄新华.当代西方“新政治经济学”的兴起——论西方政治经济学的演进与新发展.天津社会科学,2005,(1).黄新华.当代西方新政治经济学.上海:人民出版社,2008.方福前.西方新政治经济学述评.教学与研究,1999,(3).
- [3]关于国内对于新自由主义的批评.见何秉孟.新自由主义评析.北京:社会科学文献出版社,2004.
- [4]Polanyi Karl.The Great Transformation.New York:Octagon Books,1975.
- [5]North Douglass C,Thomas Robert Paul The Rise of the Western World:A New Economic History, Cambridge:Cambridge UP,1976.North Douglass C.Structure and Change in Economic History.New York: Norton,1981.
- [6]Gilpin Robert.Global Political Economy:Understanding the International Economic Order.Princeton: Princeton University Press,2001.
- [7]Caporaso James A.Levine David P.Theories of political economy.New York:Cambridge,Cambridge University Press,1992:pp.79-81.
- [1]Arrow Kenneth.Social Choice and Individual Values.New Haven,Conn.:Yale UP,1951.
- [2]Buchanan James,Gordon Tullock.The Calculus"of Consent.Ann Arbor:University of Michigan Press, 1962.
- [3]Gilpin Robert,Gilpin Jean M.The Political Economy of International Relations.Princeton,N.J,: Princeton University Press,1987.Gill Stephen,Law,David.The Global Political Economy:Perspectives, Problems,and Policies.Baltimore:Johns Hopkins University Press,1988.Strange Susan.States and Markets. London:Pinter Balaam David N,Veseth Michael.Introduction to International Political Economy.Upper Saddle River,N.J.:London:Prentice Hall,2001.
- [1]Skinner Quentin.Visions of Politics.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2002:6.
- [2]比如,Peter Katzenstein,ed.(1978),Between Power and Plenty:Foreign Economic Policies of Advanced Industrial States,Madison:University of Wisconsin Press.David Coates(2000),Models of Capitalism,London:Polity.Hall,Peter A.Soskice,David,ed.(2001),Varieties of Capitalism:The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage,Oxford:Oxford UP.Lane,Jan-Erik and Ersson,Svante (1997),Comparative Political Economy:a Developmental Approach,London:Washington:Pinter.