周磊,张千年,魏玖长

• 1:中国科学技术大学公共事务学院

摘要(Abstract)：

学术研究与政策实践的互动关系是当代学界和政界共同关注的重要议题。本文基于2003—2022年应急管理领域的学术文献和政策文本，采用LDA主题模型构建面板数据，并通过面板向量自回归模型、脉冲响应函数和方差分解分析了学术研究、法律法规和部门规章之间的动态关系。研究结果表明，学术研究与政策实践互为正向影响，但政策实践在二者的互动关系中居于引领地位。学术研究仅能对政策效力更高的法律法规产生正向影响，且随时间推移，正向影响逐渐增大，但其绝对程度仍然较小；政策效力较低的部门规章主要受到法律法规的正向影响，学术研究对其影响不显著；短期来看，部门规章对学术研究的正向影响较为强烈，但长期来看，法律法规对其正向作用更为明显。因此，应重视学术研究的政策价值，加强和完善循证理念，拓宽学者与政策制定者的联系渠道，从而实现学术研究与政策实践的良性互动。

关键词(KeyWords)： 学术研究;政策实践;LDA主题模型;面板向量自回归模型;应急管理

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金项目“多主体参与视角下应急管理政策的协同演化分析与效果评估”(项目批准号:72104226)、“战略研究类：宏观管理与政策学科的资助战略研究”(项目批准号:72440005)的资助

作者(Author): 周磊,张千年,魏玖长

参考文献(References)：

• 柏必成.2019.开门办智库：正确处理智库的外部关系——基于智库外部关系类型的分析[J].四川行政学院学报，(6):17-26.Bo B C.2019.Opening the door to think tanks:Managing external relationships effectively—An analysis based on types of think tank external relations[J].Journal of Sichuan Administration Institute,(6):17-26.(in Chinese)
• 曹玲静，张志强.2021.政策信息学的发展与前瞻[J].图书情报工作，65(21):38-50.Cao L J,Zhang Z Q.2021.Development and prospects of policy informatics[J].Library and Information Service,65(21):38-50.(in Chinese)
• 陈密容.2022-04-27(002).社科研究的政策价值不容忽视[N].中国社会科学报.Chen M R.2022-04-27(002).The policy value of social science research cannot be ignored[N].Chinese Social Sciences Today.(in Chinese)
• 方俊智，李忻蔚.2019.我国PPP政策与文献互动演化规律的计量分析[J].情报杂志，38(10):161-167.Fang J Z,Li X W.2019.A quantitative analysis of interactive evolution between the PPP policies and literature in China[J].Journal of Intelligence,38(10):161-167.(in Chinese)
• 甘甜，凌争，吴件，等.2023.连接理论与田野：公共管理研究的知识生产机制[J].岳麓公共治理，2(4):82-109.Gan T,Ling Z,Wu J,et al.2023.Connecting theory and field:Mechanisms of knowledge production in public management research[J].YueLu Public Governance,2(4):82-109.(in Chinese)
• 郭晟豪.2023.读公共管理研究论文对实践有用吗?——以街道干部为例[J].公共管理评论，5(3):152-177.Guo S H.2023.Is the reading of public administration papers useful for practice?An insight based on the experience of subdistrict officers[J].China Public Administration Review,5(3):152-177.(in Chinese)
• 贺东航，孔繁斌.2019.中国公共政策执行中的政治势能——基于近20年农村林改政策的分析[J].中国社会科学，(4):4-25,204.He D H,Kong F B.2019.Political potential energy in the implementation of Chinese public policy—An analysis based on the forestry reform policy of the last two decades[J].Social Sciences in China,(4):4-25,204.(in Chinese)
• 华生，傅捷，汲铮.2022.论文导向的科研评价激励体系改革探索[J].经济体制改革，(4):5-14.Hua S,Fu J,Ji Z.2022.On reform of the thesis-oriented evaluation and incentive system[J].Reform of Economic System,(4):5-14.(in Chinese)
• 李崇茂，陈泽长.2023.学术文献与政策文本是否相互影响?——特定术语下“能源-水”关联领域的面板VAR分析[J].科学学研究，41(7):1173-1185.Li C M,Chen Z C.2023.Does academic literature interact with policy texts?—A panel VAR analysis of energy-water nexus based on specific academic terms[J].Studies in Science of Science,41(7):1173-1185.(in Chinese)
• 李飞，张瑞，段婕.2023.高校科技成果转化的文献计量可视化研究[J].科学决策，(10):279-288.Li F,Zhang R,Duan J.2023.Visualization research on bibliometric of scientific and technological achievements transformation in universities[J].Scientific Decision Making,(10):279-288.(in Chinese)
• 李尧远，曹蓉.2015.我国应急管理研究十年(2004—2013):成绩、问题与未来取向[J].中国行政管理，(1):83-87.Li Y Y,Cao R.2015.Ten years of Chinese emergency management research (2004—2013):Achievements,problems and directions in future[J].Chinese Public Administration,(1):83-87.(in Chinese)
• 刘皛.2021.知识如何走出象牙塔——基于学术研究与政策实践关系的视角[J].高等教育研究，42(6):47-53.Liu X.2021.How is knowledge beyond the ivory tower—From the perspective of the relationship between academic research and policy practice[J].Journal of Higher Education,42(6):47-53.(in Chinese)
• 刘晓光，王贤文.2019.公共政策的学术影响计量——基于2004—2017年“中央一号文件”的引文分析[J].情报杂志，38(8):165-171.Liu X G,Wang X W.2019.Measurement of public policy influence on academia—Citation analysis on the Central Committee's Document No.1 2004—2017[J].Journal of Intelligence,38(8):165-171.(in Chinese)
• 卢凌宇，章远.2016.理论如何影响政策?——基于国际关系学的分析[J].国际观察，(1):34-51.Lu L Y,Zhang Y.2016.How does theory influence policy?An analysis based on international relations[J].International Review,(1):34-51.(in Chinese)
• 罗伯特·K·默顿.2001.社会研究与社会政策[M].林聚任，译.北京：生活·读书·新知三联书店，245-278.Robert K M.2001.Social research and social policy[M].Lin J R,trans.Beijing:SDX Joint Publishing Company,245-278.(translated into Chinese)
• 罗梁波.2020.公共管理研究的中国方式——基于社会工程的理解和行动框架[J].中国行政管理，(8):100-108.Luo L B.2020.The Chinese pattern of public administration research:Based on the understanding and action framework of social engineering[J].Chinese Public Administration,(8):100-108.(in Chinese)
• 马克斯·韦伯.2004.学术与政治[M].钱永祥，林振贤，罗久蓉，等，译.桂林：广西师范大学出版社，155-274.Max W.2004.Academic and politics[M].Qian Y X,Lin Z X,Luo J R,et al,trans.Guilin:Guangxi Normal University Press,155-274.(translated into Chinese)
• 马廷奇，郑政捷.2021.大学学科治理：逻辑意蕴、实践困境与破解路径[J].学位与研究生教育，(10):22-27.Ma T Q,Zheng Z J.2021.Aspects of university discipline governance[J].Academic Degrees & Graduate Education,(10):22-27.(in Chinese)
• 欧东.2019.学术研究的政策性价值[J].学理论，(9):39-41.Ou D.2019.The policy value of academic research[J].Theory Research,(9):39-41.(in Chinese)
• 任超，杨孟辉，赵群.2023.循证政策中的科学证据特征分析——以新冠疫情防控政策为例[J].情报理论与实践，46(7):98-106,124.Ren C,Yang M H,Zhao Q.2023.Analysis of scientific evidence features in evidence-based policy:Take the policies fighting on COVID-19 as an example[J].Information Studies:Theory & Application,46(7):98-106,124.(in Chinese)
• 山子.2015.中小学减负政策文本的梳理及分析[J].教育科学研究，(2):38-43.Shan Z.2015.A review and analysis of policies to reduce academic burden in primary and secondary education[J].Educational Science Research,(2):38-43.(in Chinese)
• 师博，常青，张良悦.2022.中国数字经济发展的政策演进与理论研究脉络[J].技术经济，41(8):1-10.Shi B,Chang Q,Zhang L Y.2022.Policy evolution and theoretical research on the development of China's digital economy[J].Journal of Technology Economics,41(8):1-10.(in Chinese)
• 施茜，裴雷，邱佳青.2016.政策扩散时间滞后效应及其实证评测——以江浙信息化政策实践为例[J].图书与情报，(6):56-62.Shi Q,Pei L,Qiu J Q.2016.The effect of time-lag in policy diffusion and its empirical evaluation—Taking informatization policies issued by provinces of Jiangsu and Zhejiang as examples[J].Library & Information,(6):56-62.(in Chinese)
• 苏长和.2009.从“政学相轻”到“政学相重”——国际关系研究中的理论与政策之弥合[J].国际政治研究，30(3):40-46.Su C H.2009.From “mutual disregard” to “mutual reliance”:Connecting theory and policy in international relations studies[J].The Journal of International Studies,30(3):40-46.(in Chinese)
• 王辉耀.2014.中国智库国际化的实践与思考[J].中国行政管理，(5):20-24.Wang H Y.2014.Thoughts and practice of Chinese think tank internationalization[J].Chinese Public Administration,(5):20-24.(in Chinese)
• 王缉思.2009.学术研究与政策研究相脱节的症结与出路[J].国际政治研究，30(3):1-11.Wang J S.2009.How to narrow the gap between scholarly research and policy-oriented Studies in IR[J].The Journal of International Studies,30(3):1-11.(in Chinese)
• 王敬尧，宋哲.2011.中国农村政策与中国农村研究：影响力考察[J].吉林大学社会科学学报，51(5):138-146.Wang J Y,Song Z.2011.Chinese rural policies and rural studies:An examination of influence[J].Jilin University Journal Social Sciences Edition,51(5):138-146.(in Chinese)
• 王效岳，白如江，王晓笛，等.2013.海量网络学术文献自动分类系统[J].图书情报工作，57(16):117-122.Wang X Y,Bai R J,Wang X D,et al.An automatic classification system of mass online academic literatures[J].Library and Information Service,57(16):117-122.(in Chinese)
• 王燕青，陈红.2022.应急管理理论与实践演进：困局与展望[J].管理评论，34(5):290-303.Wang Y Q,Chen H.2022.Evolution of emergency management theory and practice:Dilemma and prospect[J].Management Review,34(5):290-303.(in Chinese)
• 吴宾，滕蕾.2021.社会科学研究如何间接影响政策变迁?——基于政策文献量化与知识图谱的分析[J].吉首大学学报(社会科学版),42(2):35-46.Wu B,Teng L.2021.Social sciences research indirectly affects policy changes:An analysis based on policy literature and genealogy[J].Journal of Jishou University (Social Sciences),42(2):35-46.(in Chinese)
• 许源源，王琎.2022.典型治理的运行机制研究——基于2003—2022年的乡村典型示范政策的扎根探索[J].湖南师范大学社会科学学报，51(6):96-109.Xu Y Y,Wang J.2022.Research on the operation mechanism of typical governance:A grounded exploration based on the typical rural demonstration policies[J].Journal of Social Science of Hunan Normal University,51(6):96-109.(in Chinese)
• 姚清晨，张颖.2018.基于循证理念的公共政策制定研究[J].四川行政学院学报，(4):27-32.Yao Q C,Zhang Y.2018.Research on public policy making based on evidence-based concept[J].Journal of Sichuan Administration College,(4):27-32.(in Chinese)
• 燕继荣，林永兴，刘舒杨.2023.制度创新的条件及实现路径——基于政府、市场、社会的协商共治经验[J].政治学研究，(3):35-45,168-169.Yan J R,Lin Y X,Liu S Y.2023.Conditions and realization paths of institutional innovation—Based on the experience of consultation and co-governance among government,market and society[J].CASS Journal of Political Science,(3):35-45,168-169.(in Chinese)
• 杨代福，穆冬梅.2022.危机决策中科学研究的使用：现状、障碍与应对策略[J].智库理论与实践，7(3):25-32.Yang D F,Mu D M.2022.The use of scientific research in crisis decision-making:Status,barriers,and coping strategies[J].Think Tank:Theory & Practice,7(3):25-32.(in Chinese)
• 杨开峰，储梦然，刘杨.2023.公共管理学科与国家治理现代化：延续、变革与展望[J].中国行政管理，39(10):21-31.Yang K F,Chu M R,Liu Y.2023.The discipline of public administration and governance modernization:Continuity,change and prospects[J].Chinese Public Administration,39(10):21-31.(in Chinese)
• 易承志.2023.从刚性应对到弹性治理：韧性视角下城市应急管理的转型分析[J].南京社会科学，(5):63-71.Yi C Z.2023.From rigid response to flexible governance:Transformation analysis of urban emergency management from the perspective of resilience[J].Nanjing Journal of Social Sciences,(5):63-71.(in Chinese)
• 殷杰，胡敏.2010.社会科学与公共政策的关联性[J].科学技术哲学研究，27(3):14-19,91.Yin J,Hu M.2010.The correlation between social science and public policy[J].Studies in Philosophy of Science and Technology,27(3):14-19,91.(in Chinese)
• 翟羽佳，许佳，梁艺潇.2023.学术引用视角下我国政府信息公开政策及其研究的互动关联分析[J].情报学报，42(6):690-701.Zhai Y J,Xu J,Liang Y X.2023.The interaction and relevance between Chinese government information disclosure policy and related research from the perspective of academic citation[J].Journal of the China Society for Scientific and Technical Information,42(6):690-701.(in Chinese)
• 张海波.2020.应急管理的全过程均衡：一个新议题[J].中国行政管理，(3):123-130.Zhang H B.2020.The full process balance of emergency management[J].Chinese Public Administration,(3):123-130.(in Chinese)
• 张简.2016.在理论与实践之间：夏书章“应用型公共管理”思想及其启示[J].中国行政管理，(9):65-69.Zhang J.2016.Between theory and practice:Professor Xia Shuzhang's applied public administration and its implication[J].Chinese Public Administration,(9):65-69.(in Chinese)
• 张玲，恽诚涛，尹思力，等.2023.我国科研诚信政策与文献主题演化对比分析[J].现代情报，43(6):108-120.Zhang L,Yun C T,Yin S L,et al.2023.Hot topics evolution and contrastive analysis of Chinese academic integrity policy and research literature[J].Journal of Modern Information,43(6):108-120.(in Chinese)
• 张铭凯，黄瑞昕.2023.我国义务教育阶段学生“减负”政策的新世纪图景[J].教育科学研究，(9):35-42.Zhang M K,Huang R X.2023.The new century landscape of the “burden reduction” policy for Chinese students of compulsory education[J].Educational Science Research,(9):35-42.(in Chinese)
• 张雪帆，何艳玲.2016.建构公共共同体：公共行政学合法性争论及其未来[J].中国行政管理，(4):86-94.Zhang X F,He Y L.2016.For the public:The outlook of the legitimacy of public administration[J].Chinese Public Administration,(4):86-94.(in Chinese)
• 张义川，赵聪聪，伍军红，等.2022.期刊政策影响力评价方法研究[J].图书情报工作，66(22):95-105.Zhang Y C,Zhao C C,Wu J H,et al.2022.Research on evaluation method of journal policy influence[J].Library and Information Service,66(22):95-105.(in Chinese)
• 张云昊.2010.中国学术研究向政策转化的主要模式[J].北京行政学院学报，(6):25-31.Zhang Y H.2010.On the main paradigms of the transformation of Chinese academic research into policy[J].Journal of Beijing Administration Institute,(6):25-31.(in Chinese)
• 张云昊.2011.中国社会科学研究影响政策的主要模式及其创新路径[J].中国科技论坛，(10):11-16.Zhang Y H.2011.The impact of Chinese social sciences research on policy and its innovation path[J].Forum on Science and Technology in China,(10):11-16.(in Chinese)
• 张云昊.2012a.社会科学研究向政策转化的国际经验——演进历程、主要模式及其创新路径分析[J].科学学研究，30(6):801-806.Zhang Y H.2012a.The international experience of translation from research to policy in social science—The practice course,maid mode and innovation path[J].Studies in Science of Science,30(6):801-806.(in Chinese)
• 张云昊.2012b.我国社会科学研究向政策转化的组织结构体系创新[J].大连理工大学学报(社会科学版),33(2):81-86.Zhang Y H.2012b.The organizational structure innovation of social science research to policy transformation[J].Journal of Dalian University of Technology (Social Sciences),33(2):81-86.(in Chinese)
• 张云昊.2013.政策社会科学：何以可能与何以所为[J].国外社会科学，(4):109-117.Zhang Y H.2013.Policy social science:Potential and practice[J].Social Sciences International,(4):109-117.(in Chinese)
• 张云昊.2017.循证政策的发展历程、内在逻辑及其建构路径[J].中国行政管理，(11):73-78.Zhang Y H.2017.The development process,internal logic and construction path of evidence-based policy[J].Chinese Public Administration,(11):73-78.(in Chinese)
• 张正军.2020.公共管理学“大问题”研究的特点、意蕴和价值[J].天津社会科学，(5):52-60,92.Zhang Z J.2020.Characteristics,implications and value of major research issues in public administration[J].Tianjin Social Sciences,(5):52-60,92.(in Chinese)
• 赵琦，陈醉.2021.中国应急管理政策工具类型及其发展沿革——基于中央层面政策文本的分析[J].兰州学刊，(3):46-62.Zhao Q,Chen Z.2021.The development of policy instruments for risk management in China's government emergency—Analysis based on the policy text at the central level[J].Lanzhou Academic Journal,(3):46-62.(in Chinese)
• 赵蓉英，魏绪秋.2017.引证视角下的国内学术论文影响力评价——以CNKI中国引文数据库为例[J].情报理论与实践，40(8):55-60.Zhao R Y,Wei X Q.2017.Evaluation of domestic academic papers' influence from the perspective of citation:Based on CNKI Chinese citation database[J].Information Studies:Theory & Application,40(8):55-60.(in Chinese)
• 赵一方，王铮，裴雷.2020.政策计量视角下公共文化服务政策内容主题分析[J].图书情报工作，64(10):66-74.Zhao Y F,Wang Z,Pei L.2020.A thematic analysis of public cultural service policy based on policy measurement[J].Library and Information Service,64(10):66-74.(in Chinese)
• 郑敏睿，陈美景，郝晓丹，等.2022.政策与学术互动发展：从《中国土地科学》载文分析中国土地科学发展[J].中国土地科学，36(10):119-128.Zheng M R,Chen M J,Hao X D,et al.2022.Interaction between public policies and academia:Analysis of land science development in China from articles of China Land Science[J].China Land Science,36(10):119-128.(in Chinese)
• 郅庭瑾，吴晶.2014.美国智库教育政策研究及其启示[J].教育发展研究，34(23):6-11.Zhi T J,Wu J.2014.American think tank and its enlightenment:Based on the example of education policy research[J].Research in Educational Development,34(23):6-11.(in Chinese)
• 朱富成，刘永.2023.利用政策关联度指标进行学术影响力研究——以疫情防控档案政策关联度为例[J].图书情报工作，67(14):62-72.Zhu F C,Liu Y.2023.Discussion on academic influence of analysis of policy related degree index of our country:A case study of the correlation degree of epidemic prevention and control archives policies[J].Library and Information Service,67(14):62-72.(in Chinese)
• Bakhtin P,Saritas O,Chulok A,et al.2017.Trend monitoring for linking science and strategy[J].Scientometrics,111(3):2059-2075.
• Banks G.2016.Commentary:Could academic research be more policy influential?[J].Public Administration Review,76(1):33-34.
• Bulmer M.1987.Social science research and government:Comparative essays on Britain and the United States[M].Cambridge,New York:Cambridge University Press.
• Byman D,Kroenig M.2016.Reaching beyond the ivory tower:A how to manual[J].Security Studies,25(2):289-319.
• Caplan N.1979.The two-communities theory and knowledge utilization[J].American Behavioral Scientist,22(3):459-470.
• Gunderson M.2007.How academic research shapes labor and social policy[J].Journal of Labor Research,28(4):573-590.
• Güneri B,Yasemin Yalta A.2021.Does economic complexity reduce output volatility in developing countries?[J].Bulletin of Economic Research,73(3):411-431.
• Ion G,St?ngu M,Marin E.2019.How can researchers facilitate the utilisation of research by policy-makers and practitioners in education?[J].Research Papers in Education,34(4):483-498.
• Landry R,Amara N,Lamari M.2001.Utilization of social science research knowledge in Canada[J].Research Policy,30(2):333-349.
• Newman J,Cherney A,Head B W.2016.Do policy makers use academic research?Reexamining the “two communities” theory of research utilization[J].Public Administration Review,76(1):24-32.
• Perry J L.2016.Is public administration vanishing?[J].Public Administration Review,76(2):211-212.
• Talbot C,Talbot C.2015.Bridging the academic-policy-making gap:Practice and policy issues[J].Public Money & Management,35(3):187-194.
• Weiss C H.1979.The many meanings of research utilization[J].Public Administration Review,39(5):426-431.
• Williams G A,Ulla Díez S M,Figueras J,et al.2020.Translating evidence into policy during the COVID-19 pandemic:Bridging science and policy (and politics)[J].Eurohealth,26(2):29-33.
• Yin Y A,Gao J,Jones B F,et al.2021.Coevolution of policy and science during the pandemic[J].Science,371(6525):128-130.