QIN Chuanshen,ZAN Jincheng

• 1:the School of International and Public Affairs at Shanghai Jiao Tong University
• 2:School of Emergency Management at Shanghai Jiao Tong University

摘要(Abstract)：

This article introduces four noteworthy papers published in China's top journals in Summer 2021, all of which are phenomenon-driven and design-based case studies. The first paper employs a process tracing approach to analyze the failure of policy coordination based on an empirical case regarding the revision of the price catalog for basic medical services in Province F. The second paper develops a triple mechanism framework to account for the distortions in China's grassroots policies. With a most similar case design,the third paper proposes a typology framework for campaign-style environmental governance and compares the mobilization models for environmental governance. Based on a grounded theory approach, the final paper analyzes data from thirty-eight public crises cases to reveal the mechanism of political mobilization for emergency management. These studies explain clear theoretical puzzles brought about by practical problems, and they provide a sense of the research designs in the case studies. They show three types of case studies:(1) two single case studies, one with a process tracing approach and the other illustrating a developed theoretical framework,(2) a comparative case study, and (3) a multi-case study applying a grounded theory strategy. These studies provide enlightenment and lessons for future Chinese case studies.

关键词(KeyWords)：

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation):

作者(Author): QIN Chuanshen,ZAN Jincheng

参考文献(References)：

• 陈炳旭.(2021-3-25)[2021-8-23].中国案例研究期刊联盟成立大会在京召开[EB/OL].https://www.hubpd.com/c/2021-03-25/993367.shtml.Chen B X.(2021-3-25)[2021-8-23].The founding conference of the China Case Study Journal Alliance is held in Beijing[EB/OL].https://www.hubpd.com/c/2021-03-25/993367.shtml.(in Chinese)
• 丁煌,李晓飞.2010.逆向选择、利益博弈与政策执行阻滞[J].北京航空航天大学学报(社会科学版),23(1):15-21.Ding H,Li X F.2010.Adverse selection,interest game and retardance of policy implementation[J].Journal of Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics(Social Sciences Edition),23(1):15-21.(in Chinese)
• 侯志阳,张翔.2020.公共管理案例研究何以促进知识发展?基于《公共管理学报》创刊以来相关文献的分析[J].公共管理学报,17(1):143-151.Hou Z Y,Zhang X.2020.How can public management case studies promote knowledge development?Based on the analysis of related literatures from the publication of Journal of Public Management[J].Journal of Public Management,17(1):143-151.(in Chinese)
• 胡业飞,崔杨杨.2015.模糊政策的政策执行研究:以中国社会化养老政策为例[J].公共管理学报,12(2):93-105.Hu Y F,Cui Y Y.2015.Implementation of ambiguous policy:The case of socialized aged care service policy in China[J].Journal of Public Management,12(2):93-105.(in Chinese)
• 蒋积伟,唐明勇.2011.政治动员与公共危机管理:以自然灾害动员为例[J].党政论坛,(5):26-29.Jiang J W,Tang M Y.2011.Political mobilization and public crisis management:Taking natural disaster mobilization as an example[J].Party&Government Forum,(5):26-29.(in Chinese)
• 孔繁斌.2006.政治动员的行动逻辑:一个概念模型及其应用[J].江苏行政学院学报,(5):79-84.Kong F B.2006.Logic of action of political mobilization:A conceptual model and its application[J].Journal of Jiangsu Administration Institute,(5):79-84.(in Chinese)
• 李亮,刘洋,冯永春.2020.管理案例研究:方法与应用[M].北京:北京大学出版社.Li L,Liu Y,Feng Y C.2020.Case study research:Methods and practice[M].Beijing:Peking University Press.(in Chinese)
• 李妮.2018.模糊性政治任务的科层运作:A县政府是如何建构“创新”政绩的?[J].公共管理学报,15(1):1-11.Li N.2018.The bureaucratic operation of unspecified political tasks:How does the county government construct“innovation”political achievement?[J].Journal of Public Management,15(1):1-11.(in Chinese)
• 蒙克,李朔严.2019.公共管理研究中的案例方法:一个误区和两种传承[J].中国行政管理,(9):89-94.Meng K,Li S Y.2019.Case study in public management research:One misunderstanding and two tales of culture[J].Chinese Public Administration,(9):89-94.(in Chinese)
• 宋程成.2020.超越公共行政案例研究中的“定量范式”:与于文轩教授商榷[J].中国行政管理,(8):94-99.Song C C.2020.Beyond the“quantitative paradigm of case study in public administration:A dialogue with Prof.Yu Wenxuan[J].Chinese Public Administration,(8):9-99.(in Chinese)
• 孙婧婧,和经纬.2020.作为溯因推理研究方法的因果过程追踪及其在公共政策研究中的应用[J].公共管理评论,2(4):214-229.Sun J J,He J W.2020.Causal process tracing as an abductive reasoning method and its application to public policy research:Noteworthy English publications of the season[J].China Public Administration Review,2(4):214-229.(in Chinese)
• 孙雨.2019.中国地方政府“注意力强”现象的解释框架:基于S省N市环保任务的分析[J].北京社会科学,(11):41-50.Sun Y.2019.An explanatory framework of“attention increase in Chinese local governments:A case study for environmental protection task[J].Social Sciences of Beijing,(11):41-50.(in Chinese)
• 王刘飞,王毅杰.2017.转型社会中运动式治理的价值探讨:以元镇环境治理为例[J].南京农业大学学报(社会科学版),17(5):48-58.Wang L F,Wang Y J.2017.Study of campaign-style governance value in transitional society:A case study based on‘environmental governance’in Yuan Town[J].Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University(Social Sciences Edition),17(5):48-58.(in Chinese)
• 王智睿,赵聚军.2021.运动式环境治理的类型学研究:基于多案例的比较分析[J].公共管理与政策评论,10(2):62-78.Wang Z R,Zhao J J.2021.Typological research on campaign-style environmental governance:Comparative analysis based on multiple cases[J].Public Administration and Policy Review,10(2):62-78.(in Chinese)
• 吴文强.2021.政策协调机制何以失效?对F省新版医疗服务价格目录“难产”的过程追踪[J].公共管理学报,18(4):22-33.Wu W Q.2021.How do policy coordination mechanisms fail?A process tracing of the revision of basic medical service price catalog in China'F Province[J].Journal of Public Management,18(4):22-33.(in Chinese)
• 杨志军,肖贵秀.2018.环保专项行动:基于运动式治理的机制与效应分析[J].甘肃行政学院学报,(1):59-70.Yang Z J,Xiao G X.2018.Special action on environmental protection:Mechanism and effect analysis based on campaign-style governance[J].Journal of Gansu Administration Institute,(1):59-70.(in Chinese)
• 于文轩.2020.中国公共行政学案例研究:问题与挑战[J].中国行政管理,(6):105-112.Yu W X.2020.Chinese public administration research methods:Problems and challenges[J].Chinese Public Administration,(6):105-112.(in Chinese)
• 张长东.2018.社会科学中的因果机制:微观基础和过程追踪[J].公共管理评论,(1):10-21.Zhang C D.2018.Causal mechanisms in the social sciences:The micro-foundation and process tracking[J].China Public Administration Review,(1):10-21.(in Chinese)
• 张翔.2021.压力与容纳:基层政策变通的制度韧性与机制演化:以A市食品安全“全覆盖监管”政策的执行情况为例[J].中国行政管理,(6):90-97.Zhang X.2021.Pressure and accommodation:The institutional resilience and mechanism evolution of policy deformation in grassroots governance:A case study of“full supervision”policy of food safety regulation in A city[J].Chinese Public Administration,(6):90-9.(in Chinese)
• 钟爽,朱侃,王清.2021.公共危机中政治动员运行机制研究:基于2015年以来38个重大公共危机案例的分析[J].政治学研究,(2):79-96.Zhong S,Zhu K,Wang Q.2021.Research on the operation mechanism of political mobilization in public crisis:Based on the analysis of 38 major public crisis cases in recent years[J].CASS Journal of Political Science,(2):79-96.(in Chinese)
• 周雪光,练宏.2011.政府内部上下级部门间谈判的一个分析模型:以环境政策实施为例[J].中国社会科学,(5):80-96.Zhou X G,Lian H.2011.Bureaucratic bargaining in the Chinese government:The case of environmental policy implementation[J].Social Sciences in China,(5):80-96.(in Chinese)
• 周雪光.2012.运动型治理机制:中国国家治理的制度逻辑再思考[J].开放时代,(9):105-125.Zhou X G.2012.Campaign-style governance:Rethinking the institutional logic of Chinese governance[J].Open Times,(9):105-125.(in Chinese)
• Beach D,Pedersen R B.2019.Process-tracing methods:Foundations and guidelines[M].Ann Arbor:University of Michigan Press.
• Brady H E,Collier D.(Eds.).2010.Rethinking social inquiry:Diverse tools,shared standards[M].Lanham,MD:Rowman&Littlefield.
• Cameron D R.1974.Toward a theory of political mobilization[J].Journal of Politics,36(1):138-171.
• Collier D.2011.Understanding process tracing[J].PS:Political Science&Politics,44(4):823-830.
• de Vaus D.2001.Research design in social research[M].London:SAGE.
• Falleti T G,Lynch J F.2009.Context and causal mechanisms in political analysis[J].Comparative Political Studies,42(9):1143-1166.
• Gerring J.2006.Case study research:Principles and practices[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
• Hansen J M.2016.Mobilization,participation,and political change[J].Party Politics,22(2):149-157.
• King G,Keohane R O,Verba S.1994.Designing social inquiry[M].Princeton,NJ:Princeton University Press.
• Li X,Yang X,Wei Q,et al.2019.Authoritarian environmentalism and environmental policy implementation in China[J].Resources,Conservation and Recycling,145:86-93.
• Yin R K.(2011).Applications of case study research[M].London:SAGE.