李子豪,顾海,顾淑燕

• 1:南京大学政府管理学院

摘要(Abstract)：

医患信任是构建和谐医患关系的核心议题。本文基于中国社会状况综合调查(CSS2017)数据,从医疗信息来源的不同渠道出发,分别探讨网络信息获取与线下就医经历对患者信任的影响、具体影响机制及影响效果差异性。研究发现:第一,中国患者信任内部的医生信任与医院信任具有互补性;第二,公众通过网络媒介获取医疗信息会降低患者信任,医疗风险感知在这一机制中发挥了正向中介效应;第三,公众线下就医经历对患者信任具有提升效应,机制分析表明制度感知存在部分中介效应;第四,公众网络医疗信息获取对患者信任的影响程度强于线下就医经历,相比医务工作者,公众更愿相信来自互联网中的医疗信息,这也表明患者信任具有不对称性。因此,提升患者信任要从政府提供医疗服务出发去提升医方与患方的接触效应,从互联网媒体角度出发去规范媒体树立和宣传正确医疗观念的行为,从多主体协同治理角度出发去构建医患共同体,以此提升患者信任,实现医患关系的有效治理。

关键词(KeyWords)： 医疗信息;网络媒介;就医经历;患者信任;医疗风险感知;制度感知

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 江苏省社会科学基金基地项目“江苏重大突发公共卫生事件多主体协同应急响应机制研究”(项目批准号:20JD001)资助

作者(Author): 李子豪,顾海,顾淑燕

参考文献(References)：

• 柴民权.2017.就医形式、媒体传播与对医信任:基于群际接触理论的视角[J].中国社会心理学评论,13(2):167-178,203.Chai M Q.2017.Types of seeking medical treatment,media communication and trust to the doctor:On the perspective of intergroup contact theory[J].Chinese Social Psychological Review,13(2):167-178,203.(in Chinese)
• 陈诚,池上新.2019.削弱抑或促进:媒介使用与患者信任---兼论医疗环境中的媒介管理[J].东南大学学报(哲学社会科学版),21(2):104-112,148.Chen C,Chi S X.2019.Mass media and trust of patients[J].Journal of Southeast University (Philosophy and Social Science),21(2):104-112,148.(in Chinese)
• 池上新.2022.制度抑或文化:中国患者信任的影响因素及其演变趋势[J].社会学研究,37(2):137-160,229.Chi S X.2022.Institutional or cultural:Factors influencing patient trust in China and its evolution[J].Sociological Studies,37(2):137-160,229.(in Chinese)
• 龚钰涵,张锦华,陈博欧.2023.替代还是互补:公共教育财政与家庭教育储蓄---来自中国家庭追踪调查(CFPS)的经验证据[J].山西财经大学学报,45(2):45-58.Gong Y H,Zhang J H,Chen B O.2023.Substitution or complementation:Public education finance and household education savings-Empirical evidence from China family panel studies (CFPS)[J].Journal of Shanxi University of Finance and Economics,45(2):45-58.(in Chinese)
• 郝龙,王志章.2018.互联网负面新闻偏好对患方信任的影响---基于网络新闻大数据与CSS2013的实证研究[J].学术论坛,41(4):38-47.Hao L,Wang Z Z.2018.The impact of internet negative news preference on patient trust:An empirical study based on big data of internet news and CSS2013[J].Academic Forum,41(4):38-47.(in Chinese)
• 贾仓仓.2021.替代还是互补:非正式照护对正式照护的影响---基于CLHLS数据的经验证据[J].人口与发展,27(6):129-139.Jia C C.2021.Alternative or complementary:How does informal care affect formal care?-Empirical study based on the data of CLHLS[J].Population and Development,27(6):129-139.(in Chinese)
• 江艇.2022.因果推断经验研究中的中介效应与调节效应[J].中国工业经济,(5):100-120.Jiang T.2022.Mediating effects and moderating effects in causal inference[J].China Industrial Economics,(5):100-120.(in Chinese)
• 林雪玉,李雯.2015.1552例医疗纠纷调查分析[J].中国医院,19(2):61-62.Lin X Y,Li W.2015.Investigation on 1552 cases of medical dispute[J].Chinese Hospitals,19(2):61-62.(in Chinese)
• 刘宸,周向红.2017.互联网医疗信息溢出与中国居民就诊选择---基于CHNS混合截面数据的实证研究[J].公共管理学报,14(4):78-90,156-157.Liu C,Zhou X H.2017.Medical information spillovers and health care choice of Chinese residents in the internet era-An empirical research based on CHNS[J].Journal of Public Management,14(4):78-90,156-157.(in Chinese)
• 吕小康.2019.医患“获得感悖论”及其破局---兼论作为社会心理学议题的医患关系研究[J].南京师大学报(社会科学版),(1):76-86.LüX K.2019.Paradox of sense of gain between doctor and patient groups and its remedy:The study of doctor-patient relationship as a social psychological issue[J].Journal of Nanjing Normal University (Social Science Edition),(1):76-86.(in Chinese)
• 吕小康,汪新建,张慧娟,等.2019.中国医患社会心态问卷的初步编制与信效度检验[J].心理学探新,39(1):57-63.LüX K,Wang X J,Zhang H J,et al.2019.Preliminary establishment of Chinese doctor-patient social mentality questionnaire (DPSMQ) and its reliability and validity[J].Psychological Exploration,39(1):57-63.(in Chinese)
• 吕小康,王丛,汪新建,等.2021.多重不确定风险及其应对---儿童血液病病房中的医患信任研究[J].社会学研究,36(6):200-221,230.LüX K,Wang C,Wang X J,et al.2021.Coping with diverse uncertain risks:A study on the doctor-patient trust in a children'center for blood diseases in China[J].Sociological Studies,36(6):200-221,230.(in Chinese)
• 吕小康.2022.风险社会中的医患共同体建设[J].南京师大学报(社会科学版),(3):68-77.LüX K.2022.The construction of doctor-patient community in risk society[J].Journal of Nanjing Normal University (Social Science Edition),(3):68-77.(in Chinese)
• 牛冠朝,刘军强.2021.信与疑之间---民众对医生“反常”信任的实证分析[J].社会学研究,36(3):157-179,229.Niu G Z,Liu J Q.2021.Between trust and distrust:An empirical analysis of citizen'abnormal trust in doctors[J].Sociological Studies,36(3):157-179,229.(in Chinese)
• Rosenberg C E.2016.当代医学的困境[M].张大庆,译.北京:北京大学医学出版社.
• 唐钧,李军.2019.健康社会学视角下的整体健康观和健康管理[J].中国社会科学,(8):130-148,207.Tang J,Li J.2019.The concepts of overall health and health management from a health sociology perspective[J].Social Sciences in China,(8):130-148,207.(in Chinese)
• 汪新建,王丛,吕小康.2016.人际医患信任的概念内涵、正向演变与影响因素[J].心理科学,39(5):1093-1097.Wang X J,Wang C,LüX K.2016.The Conceptual Connotation,Positive Evolution,and Influencing Factors of Interpersonal doctor-patient Trust[J].Psychological Science,39(5):1093-1097.(in Chinese)
• 王俊豪,张宇力,单芬霞.2022.突发公共卫生事件下互联网医疗健康发展与监管制度创新研究[J].财经论丛,(10):102-112.Wang J H,Zhang Y L,Shan F X.2022.Research on the health development and regulation system innovation of internet medical under public health emergency[J].Collected Essays On Finance and Economics,(10):102-112.(in Chinese)
• 吴红雨,江美仪.2020.重塑中的医生与患者媒介形象对公众医疗认知的影响---以《人间世》等四部纪录片为例[J].新闻大学,(1):86-100,128.Wu H Y,Jiang M Y.2020.The influence of doctors and patients'media images on public medical cognition:Four documentaries such as life matters[J].Journalism Research,(1):86-100,128.(in Chinese)
• 徐彪,张士伟,郭宏骞,等.2020.公众疫情防控制度感知对遵从行为的影响机理研究---基于新冠肺炎疫情的理论和实证分析[J].公共管理评论,2(4):24-49.Xu B,Zhang S W,Guo H Q,et al.2020.Research on the mechanism behind the influence of the degree of public epidemic prevention and control perceptions on compliance behavior-Theoretical and empirical analyses based on COVID-19[J].China Public Administration Review,2(4):24-49.(in Chinese)
• 姚君喜.2014.媒介使用、媒介依赖对信任评价的影响---基于不同媒介的比较研究[J].当代传播,(2):19-24.Yao J X.2014.The impact of media use and dependence on trust evaluation:Acomparative study based on different media[J].Contemporary Communications,(2):19-24.(in Chinese)
• 张璇,伍麟.2013.风险认知中的信任机制:对称或不对称?[J].心理科学,36(6):1333-1338.Zhang X,Wu L.2013.The mechanism of trust in risk research:Symmetry or asymmetry?[J].Journal of Psychological Science,36(6):1333-1338.(in Chinese)
• 张云亮,柳建坤.2021.互联网使用、社会公平感与医生信任---基于CSS2013数据的实证分析[J].新闻大学,(8):18-34,117-118.Zhang Y L,Liu J K.2021.Internet use,social justice and doctor credibility:An empirical analysis of the 2013 China social survey[J].Journalism Research,(8):18-34,117-118.(in Chinese)
• 张泽洪,熊晶晶,吴素雄.2017.医疗服务的接触效应---基于医患信任的中介机制分析[J].公共管理与政策评论,6(2):60-69.Zhang Z H,Xiong J J,Wu S X.2017.Analysis on the contact effect of medical service:Based on the intermediary mechanism of doctor-patient trust[J].Public Administration and Policy Review,6(2):60-69.(in Chinese)
• 郑大喜.2010.社会学语境下医患信任关系的异化及其重建[J].医学与社会,23(7):14-16.Zheng D X.2010.The lack and rebuiding of trust between doctors and patients under sociological context[J].Medicine and Society,23(7):14-16.(in Chinese)
• 朱博文,罗教讲.2017.互联网使用会影响公众对医生的信任吗?---基于数据CSS2013的实证分析[J].江苏社会科学,(3):70-78.Zhu B W,Luo J J.2017.Will internet use affect public trust in doctors-Empirical analysis based on data CSS2013[J].Jiangsu Social Sciences,(3):70-78.(in Chinese)
• 朱艳丽.2018.基于主题效价分析的医患关系影响因素探究[J].南京师大学报(社会科学版),(1):94-100.Zhu Y L.2018.Exploring the factors affecting doctor-patient relationship based on a theme valence analysis[J].Journal of Nanjing Normal University (Social Science Edition),(1):94-100.(in Chinese)
• Bakir V.2010.Media and risk:Old and new research directions[J].Journal of Risk Research,13(1):5-18.
• Bova C,Route P S,Fennie K,et al.2012.Measuring patient-provider trust in a primary care population:Refinement of the health care relationship trust scale[J].Research in Nursing&Health,35(4):397-408.
• Cappella J N,Jamieson K H.1997.Spiral of cynicism:The press and the public good[M].New York:Oxford University Press.
• Cutilli C C.2010.Seeking health information:What sources do your patients use?[J].Orthopaedic Nursing,29(3):214-219.
• de Boer M J,Versteegen G J,van Wijhe M.2007.Patients'use of the Internet for pain-related medical information[J].Patient Education and Counseling,68(1):86-97.
• Devi S.2020.COVID-19 exacerbates violence against health workers[J].The Lancet,396(10252):658.
• Dixon J L,Tillman M M,Wehbe-Janek H,et al.2015.Patients'perspectives of surgical safety:Do they feel safe?[J].The Ochsner Journal,15(2):143-148.
• Goold S D.2001.Trust and the ethics of health care institutions[J].The Hastings Center Report,31(6):26-33.
• Hall M A,Dugan E,Zheng B Y,et al.2001.Trust in physicians and medical institutions:What is it,can it be measured,and does it matter?[J].The Milbank Quarterly,79(4):613-639.
• Kleemans M,Hendriks Vettehen P G J,Beentjes J W J,et al.2012.The influence of age and gender on preferences for negative content and tabloid packaging in television news stories[J].Communication Research,39(5):679-697.
• Mechanic D.1996.Changing medical organization and the erosion of trust[J].The Milbank Quarterly,74(2):171-189.
• Morgan R M,Hunt S D.1994.The commitment-trust theory of relationship marketing[J].Journal of Marketing,58(3):20-38.
• Ozawa S,Sripad P.2013.How do you measure trust in the health system?A systematic review of the literature[J].Social Science&Medicine,91:10-14.
• Pettigrew T F,Tropp L R.2008.How does intergroup contact reduce prejudice?Meta‐analytic tests of three mediators[J].European Journal of Social Psychology,38(6):922-934.
• Quist N.2011.Social media and interpersonal relationships:For better or worse?[J].The Journal of Clinical Ethics,22(2):191-193.
• Radoi M,Lupu A.2014.Trust in the physician and in medical institutions.modalities of comprehension and analysis[J].Postmodern Openings,5(4):57-73.
• Shelby A,Ernst K.2013.Story and science:How providers and parents can utilize storytelling to combat anti-vaccine misinformation[J].Human Vaccines&Immunotherapeutics,9(8):1795-1801.
• Siegrist M,Gutscher H,Earle T C.2005.Perception of risk:The influence of general trust,and general confidence[J].Journal of Risk Research,8(2):145-156.
• Swoboda C M,van Hulle J M,McAlearney A S,et al.2018.Odds of talking to healthcare providers as the initial source of healthcare information:Updated cross-sectional results from the health information national trends survey (HINTS)[J].BMC Family Practice,19(1):146.
• Thom D H,Wong S T,Guzman D,et al.2011.Physician trust in the patient:Development and validation of a new measure[J].The Annals of Family Medicine,9(2):148-154.
• Trawalter S,Richeson J A,Shelton J N.2009.Predicting behavior during interracial interactions:A stress and coping approach[J].Personality and Social Psychology Review,13(4):243-268.
• Vosoughi S,Roy D,Aral S.2018.The spread of true and false news online[J].Science,359(6380):1146-1151.
• Zheng S J,Hui S F,Yang Z L.2017.Hospital trust or doctor trust?A fuzzy analysis of trust in the health care setting[J].Journal of Business Research,78:217-225.