李锋,马亮

• 1:中共中央党校(国家行政学院)
• 2:北京大学国家治理研究院
• 3:中国人民大学公共管理学院
• 4:中国人民大学国家发展与战略研究院

摘要(Abstract)：

公民网络问政日趋流行,但是政府回应情况却差别较大。本文提出地方官员对政民互动的重视程度会正向影响政府回应力,并利用某省2008—2019年人民网"领导留言板"的三万余条公民诉求数据进行实证分析。基于双重差分法和合成控制法,发现领导重视对政府回应力具有正向作用,而领导重视对政府回应力的影响存在逐层递减的现象,因而区域间具有明显的差异。这些研究发现为理解和推动数字政府建设提供了理论解释和经验依据,说明推动领导干部重视网络问政,加强政府回应制度建设,是推进数字政府建设和提升网络政府回应力的关键策略。

关键词(KeyWords)： 政府回应力;网络问政;领导重视;公众参与;数字政府

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家社科基金青年项目“大数据背景下地方政府回应性实证研究”(项目编号:20CZZ017);; 国家自然科学基金项目面上项目“第三方评估如何提升组织绩效?中国地方政府的实证研究”(批准号71774164)的阶段性成果

作者(Author): 李锋,马亮

参考文献(References)：

• 陈林，伍海军．2015．国内双重差分法的研究现状与潜在问题[J]．数量经济技术经济研究，32(7):133-148.Chen L,Wu H J.2015.Research status and potential problems of differences-indifferences method in China[J].The Journal of Quantitative&Technical Economics,32(7):133-148.(in Chinese)
• 陈朋．2016．地方政府创新的影响因素分析---基于中国地方政府创新奖的数据研判[J]．中共中央党校学报，20(4):44-50.Chen P.2016.Analysis on the influencing factors of local government innovation-Based on the statistics of Chinese local government innovation award[J].Journal of the Party School of the Central Committee of the C.T.C.,20(4):44-50.(in Chinese)
• 段哲哲．2019．基层公务员对群众回应性的来源:压力、价值观或观念形态?---基于我国东中部10市基层公务员调研证据[J]．公共行政评论，12(6):85-109.Duan Z Z.2019.The source of grassroots civil servants’responsiveness to the masses:Pressure,values or ideology-Based on the research evidence of grassroots civil servants in10 cities in the East and middle of China[J].Journal of Public Administration,12(6):85-109.(in Chinese)
• 段哲哲，刘江．2019．网络问政的政府回应逻辑:公开承诺压力与选择性回应---基于66个政府网站领导信箱的实验设计[J]．浙江工商大学学报，33(4):79-89.Duan Z Z,Liu J.2019.Government responsive logic in network politics:Public commitment pressure and selective response-Experimental design based on 66 government website leadership mailboxes[J].Journal of Zhejiang Gongshang University,33(4):79-89.(in Chinese)
• 韩志明．2019．问题解决的信息机制及其效率---以群众闹大与领导批示为中心的分析[J]．中国行政管理，(4):86-92.Han Z M.2019.The information mechanism of problem-solving and its efficiencyAnalysis of the Masses’Nao-Da and leadership approval[J].Chinese Public Administration,(4):86-92.(in Chinese)
• 李帆，马亮，李绍平．2018．公共政策评估的循证进路---实验设计与因果推论[J]．国家行政学院学报，(5):132-138.Li F,Ma L,Li S P.2018.An evidence-based approach to public policy evaluation:Experimental design and causal inference[J].Journal of Chinese Academy of Governance,(5):132-138.(in Chinese)
• 李锋，孟天广．2016．策略性政治互动:网民政治话语运用与政府回应模式[J]．武汉大学学报(人文科学版)，69(5):119-128，封3.Li F,Meng T G.2016.The strategic political interaction:Political discourses of Netizens and government responsiveness in cyber space[J].Wuhan University Journal (Humanities Sciences),69(5):119-128，封3.(in Chinese)
• 李锋．2018．运用大数据提升国家治理现代化水平---以新时代人民对于美好生活需要的大数据分析为案例[J]．电子政务，(5):64-73.Li F.2018.Using big data to improve the modernization level of national governanceTaking the big data analysis of people’s needs for a better life in the new era as a case[J].E-Government,(5):64-73.(in Chinese)
• 李锋．2019a．条块关系视野下的网络诉求与政府回应模式研究---基于中部某市网络问政平台的大数据分析[J]．电子政务，(5):27-37.Li F.2019a.Research on network appeal and government response mode from the perspective of the relationship between different sections-Big data analysis based on the network political platform of a city in Central China[J].E-Government,(5):27-37.(in Chinese)
• 李锋．2019b．网络空间公民利益诉求的对象选择与行为特征---以全国网络问政平台的大数据分析为例[J]．探索，(6):91-99.Li F.2019b.The object selection and behavior characteristics of citizen’s interest claim through internet:The big data analysis based on a national e-government platform[J].Probe,(6):91-99.(in Chinese)
• 廖为建，杨涵．2012．网络问政平台的现实困境和发展路径[J]．国际公关，(5):90-91.Liao W J,Yang H.2012.The practical dilemma and development path of network political platform[J].PR Magazine,(5):90-91.(in Chinese)
• 刘江．2020．城市电子政务回应能力的空间效应研究---基于地级市的实证分析[J]．电子政务，(4):102-113.Liu J.2020.Research on the spatial effect of urban e-government response capacity-An empirical analysis based on prefecture level cities[J].E-Government,(4):102-113.(in Chinese)
• 刘友金，曾小明．2018．房产税对产业转移的影响:来自重庆和上海的经验证据[J]．中国工业经济，(11):98-116.Liu Y J,Zeng X M.2018.Research on the influence of industrial transfer from the property taxes:Empirical research from Chongqing and Shanghai[J].China Industrial Economics,(11):98-116.(in Chinese)
• 马亮．2013．电子政务发展的影响因素:中国地级市的实证研究[J]．电子政务，(9):50-63.Ma L.2013.Factors influencing the development of E-government:An empirical study of prefecture level cities in China[J].E-Government,(9):50-63.(in Chinese)
• 孟天广，李锋．2015．网络空间的政治互动:公民诉求与政府回应性---基于全国性网络问政平台的大数据分析[J]．清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版)，30(3):17-29.Meng T G,Li F.2015.Political interactions between citizens’demands and government responsiveness in cyberspace:Based on the big data from online political forum[J].Journal of Tsinghua University (Philosophy and Social Sciences),30 (3):17-29.(in Chinese)
• 孟天广，赵娟．2018．网络驱动的回应性政府:网络问政的制度扩散及运行模式[J]．上海行政学院学报，19(3):36-44.Meng T G,Zhao J.2018.Internet driven government responsiveness:Institutional diffusion and operational models of online deliberation[J].The Journal of Shanghai Administration Institute,19(3):36-44.(in Chinese)
• 庞明礼．2019．领导高度重视:一种科层运作的注意力分配方式[J]．中国行政管理，(4):93-99.Pang M L.2019.Leaders attach great importance:An attention distribution approach of bureaucratic operation[J].Chinese Public Administration,(4):93-99.(in Chinese)
• 邵梓捷，杨良伟．2020．“钟摆式回应”:回应性不足的一种解释---基于S市地方领导留言板的实证研究[J]．经济社会体制比较，(1):114-122.Shao Z J,Yang L W.2020.Pendulum model response:An explanation of insufficient responsiveness based on the message board of local leaders in S city[J].Comparative Economic and Social Systems,(1):114-122.(in Chinese)
• 史亚东，阮世珂．2019．公众环境诉求影响因素及其作用机制---基于北京市网络问政平台数据[J]．调研世界，(5):11-17.Shi Y D,Ruan S K.2019.Influencing factors and mechanism of public environmental demands:Based on the data of Beijing online political platform[J].The World of Survey and Research,(5):11-17.(in Chinese)
• 陶鹏，初春．2020．府际结构下领导注意力的议题分配与优先:基于公开批示的分析[J]．公共行政评论，13(1):63-78.Tao P,Chu C.2020.Issue allocation and priority of leaders’attention under intergovernmental structure:An analysis based on public instructions[J].Journal of Public Administration,13(1):63-78.(in Chinese)
• 王军洋，胡洁人．2017．当代中国政府回应性的逻辑:基于历史与现实的分析[J]．社会科学，(12):30-39.Wang J Y,Hu J R.2017.Logics of the government responsiveness in contemporary China:An analysis based on history and reality[J].Journal of Social Sciences,(12):30-39.(in Chinese)
• 王贤彬，徐现祥，李郇．2009．地方官员更替与经济增长[J]．经济学(季刊)，8(4):1301-1328.Wang X B,Xu X X,Li Y.2009.Provincial governors’turnovers and economic growth:Evidence from China[J].China Economic Quarterly,8(4):1301-1328.(in Chinese)
• 王贤彬，聂海峰．2010．行政区划调整与经济增长[J]．管理世界，(4):42-53.Wang X B,Nie H F.2010.Administrative divisions adjustment and economic growth[J].Management World,(4):42-53.(in Chinese)
• 王贤彬，黄亮雄．2020．官员更替、政策不确定性及其经济效应---中国情景10年研究回顾与展望[J]．公共管理与政策评论，9(2):69-81.Wang X B,Huang L X.2020.Official turnover,policy uncertainty andits economic effects:Review and prospect of China’s scenario in 10 years[J].Public Administration and Policy Review,9(2):69-81.(in Chinese)
• 肖立辉．2009．关于党内“一把手体制”的思考[J]．湖湘论坛，22(6):56-59.Xiao L H.2009.Reflections on the“top leader system”within the party[J].Huxiang Forum,22(6):56-59.(in Chinese)
• 杨蓉蓉．2014．提高我国地方政府回应能力问题研究---基于人民网《地方领导留言板》的分析[J]．理论导刊，(6):30-33.Yang R R.2014.Research on improving the response ability of local governments in China-Based on the analysis of local leaders’message board[J].Journal of Socialist Theory Guide,(6):30-33.(in Chinese)
• 殷存毅，叶志鹏，杨勇．2016．政府创新扩散视角下的电子政务回应性实证研究---基于全国923家县级政府门户网站的在线测评数据[J]．上海行政学院学报，17(4):35-45.Yin C Y,Ye Z P,Yang Y.2016.An empirical study of the responsiveness of egovernment from the perspective of government innovation diffusion theory[J].The Journal of Shanghai Administration Institute,17(4):35-45.(in Chinese)
• 俞可平．2002．全球治理引论[J]．马克思主义与现实，20(1):20-32.Yu K P.2002.Introduction to global governance[J].Marxism&Reality,20(1):20-32.(in Chinese)
• 俞可平．2019．中国地方政府创新的可持续性(2000-2015)---以“中国地方政府创新奖”获奖项目为例[J]．公共管理学报，16(1):1-15.Yu K P.2019.Sustainability in Chinese Local Government Innovation (2000-2015)-Based on the award-winning projects from“Chinese Local Government Innovation Awards Program”[J].Journal of Public Management,16(1):1-15.(in Chinese)
• 中国互联网络信息中心．(2021-02-03)[2021-03-23]．第47次《中国互联网络发展状况统计报告》[EB/OL].http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2021-02/03/content_5584518.htm.China Internet Network Information Center.(2021-02-03)[2021-03-23].The 47th statistical report on Internet Development in China[EB/OL]http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2021-02/03/content_5584518.htm.(in Chinese)
• 周黎安．2014．行政发包制[J]．社会，34(6):1-38.Zhou L A.2014.Administrative subcontract[J].Chinese Journal of Sociology,34(6):1-38.(in Chinese)
• 周雪光．2017．中国国家治理的制度逻辑[M]．北京:生活·读书·新知三联书店，86-120.Zhou X G.2017.Institutional logic of governance in China[M].Beijing:SDX Joint Publishing Company,86-120.(in Chinese)
• 左才．2018．网络社会与国家治理研究[J]．南开学报(哲学社会科学版)，(3):28-36.Zuo C.2018.Review of the research on network society and governance[J].Nankai Journal (Philosophy Literature and Social Science Edition),(3):28-36.(in Chinese)
• Abadie A,Diamond A,Hainmueller J.2010.Synthetic control methods for comparative case studies:Estimating the effect of California’s tobacco control program[J].Journal of the American Statistical Association,105(490):493-505．
• Andersen K N,Medaglia R,Vatrapu R,et al.2011.The forgotten promise of e-government maturity:Assessing responsiveness in the digital public sector[J].Government Information Quarterly,28(4):439-445．
• Athey S,Imbens G W.2006.Identification and inference in nonlinear difference-in-differences models[J].Econometrica,74(2):431-497．
• Besley T J,Burgess R.2002.The political economy of government responsiveness:Theory and evidence from India[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,117(4):1415-1451．
• Chen J D,Pan J,Xu Y Q.2016.Sources of authoritarian responsiveness:A field experiment in China[J].American Journal of Political Science,60(2):383-400．
• Faguet J P.2009.Governance from below in Bolivia:A theory of local government with two empirical tests[J].Latin American Politics and Society,51(4):29-68．
• Gauld R,Gray A,McComb S.2009.How responsive is e-government?Evidence from Australia and New Zealand[J].Government Information Quarterly,26(1):69-74．
• Gilens M.2005.Inequality and democratic responsiveness[J].Public Opinion Quarterly,69(5):778-796．
• Hassid J,Brass J N.2015.Scandals,media and good governance in China and Kenya[J].Journal of Asian and African Studies,50(3):325-342．
• Jiang J Y,Meng T G,Zhang Q.2019.From internet to social safety net:The policy consequences of online participation in China[J].Governance,32(3):531-546．
• Li F,Liu Y,Meng T G.2019.Discursive strategy of opinion expression and government response in China:Text analysis based on online petitions[J].Telematics and Informatics,42:101238．
• Liao Y G.2018.Toward a pragmatic model of public responsiveness:Implications for enhancing public administrators’responsiveness to citizen demands[J].International Journal of Public Administration,41(2):159-169．
• Maksimovska A,Stojkov A.2016.Social responsiveness and service performance of local government:The case of Macedonia[J].Croatian&Comparative Public Administration,16(2):219-236．
• Malesky E,Schuler P.2010.Nodding or needling:Analyzing delegate responsiveness in an authoritarian parliament[J].American Political Science Review,104(3):482-502．
• Meng T G,Pan J,Yang P.2017.Conditional receptivity to citizen participation:Evidence from a survey experiment in China[J].Comparative Political Studies,50(4):399-433．
• Moon M J,Norris D F.2005.Does managerial orientation matter?The adoption of reinventing government and e-government at the municipal level[J].Information Systems Journal,15(1):43-60．
• Su Z,Meng T G.2016.Selective responsiveness:Online public demands and government responsiveness in authoritarian China[J].Social Science Research,59:52-67．
• Tolbert C J,Mossberger K,McNeal R.2008.Institutions,policy innovation,and e-government in the American States[J].Public Administration Review,68(3):549-563．
• Wu Y H,Bauer J M.2010.E-government in China:Deployment and driving forces of provincial government portals[J].Chinese Journal of Communication,3(3):290-310．
• Yang K F,Pandey S K.2007.Public responsiveness of government organizations:Testing a preliminary model[J].Public Performance&Management Review,31(2):215-240．
• Zhou X.2004.E-government in China:A content analysis of national and provincial web sites[J].Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,9(4):JCMC948.