金融发展理论的历史轨迹与未来发展:一个综述The History and Future of Financial Development Theories:a Review
夏金霞,韩廷春
摘要(Abstract):
本文通过研究金融发展理论的有关研究文献,总结了金融发展理论的理论渊源,及其产生、发展、兴起的过程;介绍了各个发展阶段的代表人物、著作和主要思想;剖析了随着经济发展水平的提高和经济理论不断创新而发展起来的金融发展理论的主要研究内容和方法;归纳了金融发展理论的发展特点;展望了未来金融发展理论可能的发展方向。
关键词(KeyWords): 金融发展;金融深化;经济增长
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 夏金霞,韩廷春
参考文献(References):
- ① Walter Bagehot,Lombard Street:A Description of the Money Market,Wiley,John and Sons,Incorporated Press,1999.
- ② (瑞典)魏克赛尔著、蔡受百,程伯译.利息与价格(Interest&Prices).北京:商务印书馆,1959(1982年5月重印)
- ③ (奥)约瑟夫·熊彼特著.何畏,易家详译.经济发展理论(The Theory of Economic Development,1911) .北京:商务印书馆,1990
- ④ (英)约翰·梅纳德·凯恩斯著.高鸿业译.就业、利息和货币通论(General Theory of Employment,Interest and Money,1936) .北京:商务印书馆,1999
- ⑤ (英)哈罗德著.黄范章译.动态经济学(Economic Dynamics).北京:商务印书馆,1981
- ⑥ Robert M.Solow,Growth Theory:An Exposition.London:Oxford University Press,2000.
- ⑦ Joan Robinson,“The Second Crisis of Economic Theory,” American Economic Review,Vol.62 (1/2) (May 1972) .
- ⑧ James Tobin,“Inflation and Unemployment,” American Economic Review,Vol.62,No.1 (1972) ;James Tobin,“A Dynamic Aggregative Model,” Journal of Political Economy,Vol.63 (April 1955) ,pp.103-115;James Tobin,“Money and Economic Growth,” Econometrica,Vol.33,No.4 (October 1965) ,pp.617-684;W.Brainard and J.Tobin,“Financial Intermediaries and the Effectiveness of Monetary Policy,” American Economic Review,Vol.53,No.2 (1963) ,pp.383-400.
- ① Robert M.Solow,“A Contribution to the Theory of Economic Growth,” Quarterly Journal of Economics,Vol.70,No.1 (1956) ,pp.65-94;Robert M.Solow,“Investment and Technical Progress,” in Kenneth J.Arrow,Samuel Karlin,and Patrick Suppes (eds),Mathematical Methods in the Social Sciences.Stanford:Stanford University Press,1960.
- ② R.F.Kahn,“Exercises in the Analysis of Growth,” Oxford Economic Papers,(1959) ,pp.143-156.
- ③ Ncholas Kaldor,“Alternative Theories of Distribution,” Review of Economic Studies,Vol.23,No.2(1956) ,pp.83-100;Nicholas Kaldor and James A.Mirrless,“A New Model of Economic Growth,” Review of Economic Studies,Vol.29 (1962) ,pp.174-192.
- ④ Joan Robinson,“The Model of an Expanding Economy.” Economic Journal,Vol.62 (1952) ;Joan Robinson,“Equilibrium Growth Models,” American Economic Review,LI (June 1961) .
- ① R.A.Mundell,“Capital Mobility and Stabilization Policy under Fixed and Flexible Exchange Rates,”Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science,Vol.29 (1963) ,pp.475-485;R.A.Mundell,“Growth,Stability and Inflationary Finance,” Journal of Political Economy,Vol.73,No.2 (1965) ,pp.97-109;R.A.Mundel,“A Fallacy in the Interpretation of Macroeconomic Equilibrium,” Journal of Political Economy,Vol.73,No.1 (1965) ,pp.61-66;R.A.Mundell,International Economics.New York:Macmillan,1968.
- ② D.Patinkin,Money,Interest and Prices:An integration of monetary and value theory.New York:Harper and Rowe,1965;D.Patinkin,“The Chicago Tradition,the Quantity Theory and Friedman,” Journal of Money,Credit and Banking,Vol.1 (1969) ,pp.46-70;D.Patinkin,“Friedman on the Quantity Theory and Keynesian Economics,” Journal of Political Economy,Vol.80 (1972) ,pp.883-905;D.Patinkin,Essays On and In the Chicago Tradition.Durham,NC:Duke University Press,1981.
- ③ M.Friedman,A Program for Monetary Stability.New York:Fordham University Press,1959;M.Friedman,“The Demand for Money:Some theoretical and empirical results,” Journal of Political Economy,Vol.67,No.4 (1959) ,pp.327-351;M.Friedman,“The Lag in the Effect of Monetary Policy,” Journal of Political Economy,Vol.69 (1961) ,pp.447-466.
- ① Ronald I.McKinnon,Money and Capital in Economic Development.Washington D.C.:Brookings Institution,1973.
- ② Edward S.Shaw,Financial Deepening in Economic Development.New York:Oxford University Press,1973.
- ③ Basant K Kapur (ed.),“Alternative Stabilization Policies for Less Developed Economies,” Journal of Political Economy,Vol.84,No.4 (August 1976) .
- ④ Basant K.Kapur (ed.),“On the Role of the Money Supply in a Flexible Exchange Rate Economy,”Malayan Economic Review,Vol.22,No.4 (April 1977) .
- ⑤ Vicente Galbis,“Monetary and Exchange Rate Policiesin a Small Open Economy,” IMF Staff Papers,Vol.22 (July 1975) ,pp.313-343.
- ⑥ Vicente Galbis,“Financial Intermediation and Economic Growth in Less-Developed Countries:A Theoretical Approach,” Journal of Development.Studies,Vol.13,No.2 (January 1977) ,pp.58-72.
- ⑦ Donald J.Mathieson,“Financial Reform and Stabilization Policy in a Developing Economy,” Journal of Development Economics,(September 1980) ,pp.359-395.
- ⑧ Maxwell J.Fry,“Money and Capital or Financial Deepening in Economic Development,” Journal of Money,Credit and Banking,Vol.10,No.4 (1978) ,pp.464-475.
- ⑨ Maxwell J.Fry,“Models of Financially Repressed Developing Economies,” World Development,Vol.10,No.9 (September 1982) ,pp.731-750.
- ⑩ Maxwell J.Fry,Money,Interest,and Banking in Economic Development.Maryland:The John Hopkins University Press,1988.
- (11) Vicente Galbis,“Money,Investment and Growth in Latin America,1961-1973,” Economic Development and Cultural Change,Vol.27,No.3 (April 1979) .
- (12) Maxwell J.Fry,“Alternative Stabilisation Strategies from a Model of Short Run Price and Output Fluctuations in Turkey,” METU Studies in Development,Vol.18 (1978) ,pp.21-36.
- (13) Maxwell J.Fry,“Saving,Investment,Growth and the Cost of Financial Repression,” World Development,Vol.8,No.4 (April 1980) ,pp.317-327.
- (14) Maxwell J.Fry,“Interest Rates in Asia:An Examination of Interest Rate Policies in Burma,India,Indonesia,Korea,Malaysia,Nepal,Pakistan,Philippines,Singapore,Sri Lanka,Taiwan and Thailand,” Study prepared for the Asian Department of the International Monetary Fund,(June 1981) .
- (15) Ronald I.McKinnon,“Financial Liberalization and Economic Development:A Reassessment of Interest-Rate Policies in Asia and Latin America,” Oxford Review of Economic Policy,Vol.5,No.4 (1989) .
- ① 韩廷春.金融发展与经济增长:基于中国的实证分析.经济科学,2001,3:31;韩廷春.金融发展与经济增长:经验模型与政策分析.世界经济,2001,6:1;谈儒勇.金融抑制和金融约束.金融研究,1998,2:26;谈儒勇.金融自由化的条件研究.中国人民大学学报.1999,3:1;谈儒勇.我国金融改革方向的理性思考.南京大学学报,2001,1:102
- ① Ernst-Ludwig von Thadden,“Long-Term Contracts,Short-Term Investment and Monitoring,” Review of Economic Studies,Vol.62,No.4 (October 1995) ,pp.557-575;Ben Bernanke and Mark Gertler,“Ageney Costs,Net Worth and Business Fluctuations,” The American Economic Review,Vol.79,No.1 (March 1989) ,pp.14-31;R.Merton and Z.Bodie,“A Conceptual Framework for Analyzing the Financial System,” in The Global Financial System:A Functional Perspective.Massachusetts:Harvard Business School Press,1995.
- ② D.Diamond,“Financial intermediation and delegated monitoring,” Review of Economic Studies,Vol.51 (1984) ,pp.393-414.
- ③ Dwight B.Crane,Kenneth A.Froot,Scott P.Mason,Robert C.Merton,Erik R.Sirri and Peter Tufano,The Global Financial System,A Functional Perspective,Massachusetts:Harvard Business School Press,1995;Naomi Lamoreaux,Insider Lending:Banks,Personal Connections,and Economic Development in Industrial New England,New York:Cambridge University Press,1994,reissued in paperback,1996.
- ④ 散见于已提及的文章中.
- ⑤ 散见于已提及的文章中.
- ① Ross Levine,Norman Loayza and Thorsten Beck,“Finance and the Sources of Growth,” Journal of Financial Economics,Vol.58 (October 2000) ,pp.261-300;Thorsten Beck and Ross Levine,“New Firm Formation and Industry Growth:Does Having a Market-Based or Bank-Based System Matter?” World Bank Policy Research Working Paper,(2000) ;Thorsten Beck and Ross Levine,“External Dependence and Industry Growth:Does Financial Structure Matter?” World Bank mimeo,(February 2000) ;Thorsten Beck and Ross Levine,“Stock Markets,Banks and Growth:Correlation or Causality?” World Bank mimeo,(2000) .
- ② Rafael La Porta (ed.),“Law and Finance,” National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper,No.5661 (July 1996) ;Rafael La Porta (ed.),“Legal Determinants of External Finance,” Journal of Finance,Vol.52. No.3 (July 1997) ,pp.1131-1150;Ross Levine,“The legal environment,banks and long-run economic growth,” Journal of Money,Credit and Banking,Vol.30,No.3 (1998) ,pp.596-613.
- ③ Ross Levine,“Bank-Based or Market-Based Financial Systems:Which Is Better?” University of Minnesota mimeo,(2000) .
- ④ John C.Jr Coffee,“The Rise of Dispersed Ownerships The Roles of Law and State in the Seperation of Ownership and Control,” The Yale Law Journal,Vol.111,No.1 (October 2001) .
- ⑤ Thorsten Beck,Demirguc-Kunt and Levine,“Law,Endowment and Finance,” National Bureau of Economic Research,Inc,Working Paper,No.9089 (2002) .
- ① R.I.McKinnon,“Financial Control in the Transition from Classical Socialism to a Market Economy,” Journal of Economic Perspectives,Vol.5 (1991) ,pp.107-122.
- ② Bruce C.Greenwald and Joseph E.Stiglitz,“Asymmetric Information and the New Theory of the Firm:Financial Constraints and Risk Behavior,” American Economic Review,Vol.80,No.2 (1990) ,pp.160-165.
- ③ Paul Burkett and A.K.Dutt,“Interest rate policy,effective demand and growth in LDCs,”International Review of Applied Economics,Vol.5,No.2 (1991) ,pp.127-153.
- ④ Joseph E.Stiglitz,“Government,Financial Markets and Economic DeveLopment,” National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper,(1991) .
- ⑤ John B.Taylor,“Policy Choice and Economic Structure,” Occasional Papers,No.9. New York:Group of Thirty,1982.
- ① Vicente Galbis,“Sequencing of Financial Sector Reforms:A Review,” IMF Working Paper,No.94/101,(September 1994) .
- ② Philip Arestis and Panicos Demetriades,“Finance and Growth:Is Schumpeter ‘Right’?” Discussion Papers,No.95/11. Department of Economics,Keele University.
- ① Levine,Ross,“Financial Development and Economic Growth:Views and Agenda,” Journal of Economic Literature,Vol.3,5,No.2 (June 1997) ,pp.688-726.