陈静,黄萃,苏竣

• 1:清华大学公共管理学院
• 2:浙江大学公共管理学院

摘要(Abstract)：

在政策执行问题日益复杂、参与主体逐渐走向多元化的背景下,政策执行网络为理解和解释政策执行过程中的"黑箱"提供了新的研究路径。本文梳理了国际学界对政策执行网络概念和内涵的界定,系统分析了政策执行网络的研究起源、产生和发展历程。研究发现,目前国际学界基于"过程"和"工具"研究视角,就执行网络的形成与变化、网络与执行结果间的关系等研究议题开展了多领域实证研究,积累了丰富的研究成果。了解和把握国际学界政策执行网络研究动态,将为推进中国本土政策执行研究的突破提供有益的参考与启示。

关键词(KeyWords)： 政策执行;网络研究;发展脉络;研究视角

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金优秀青年科学基金项目“公共管理与公共政策”（项目批准号：71722002）;国家自然科学基金重点国际合作研究项目“决策模式差异化情景下的中美低碳创新政策工具比较研究”（项目批准号：71520107005）;; 教育部重大课题攻关项目“面向2035我国高校哲学社会科学整体发展战略研究”（项目批准号：18JZD056）资助

作者(Author): 陈静,黄萃,苏竣

参考文献(References)：

• 丁煌,杨代福.2008.政策网络、博弈与政策执行:以我国房价宏观调控政策为例[J].学海,(6):79-85.Ding H,Yang D F.2008.Policy network,game and policy implementation:Take the macro-control policy of house price in China as an example[J].Academia Bimestris,(6):79-85.(in Chinese)
• 丁煌,定明捷.2010.国外政策执行理论前沿评述[J].公共行政评论,3(1):119-148.Ding H,Ding M J.2010.Frontier and enlightenment of foreign theories on public policy implementation[J].Journal of Public Administration,3(1):119-148.(in Chinese)
• 丁煌,李晓飞.2013.中国政策执行力研究评估:2003—2012年[J].公共行政评论,6(4):130-157.Ding H,Li X F.2013.An evaluation on policy implementation ability research in China:2003—2012[J].Journal of Public Administration,6(4):130-157.(in Chinese)
• 丁煌,周丽婷.2013.地方政府公共政策执行力的提升——基于多中心治理视角的思考[J].江苏行政学院学报,(3):112-118.Ding H,Zhou L T.2013.Elevation of execution capability of local government in public policy—Considerations based on polycentric governance[J].Journal of Jiangsu Administration Institute,(3):112-118.(in Chinese)
• 定明捷.2008.西方政策执行研究的理论演进[J].上海行政学院学报,9(4):66-74.Ding M J.2008.An evolution of the major theories of western policy implementation[J].Journal of Shanghai Administration Institute,9(4):66-74.(in Chinese)
• 冯贵霞.2016.“共识互动式”环保政策执行网络的形成——以环保约谈制为例[J].东岳论丛,37(4):55-61.Feng G X.2016.The formation of"Consensus Interactive"environmental policy implementation network—Taking the environmental protection interview system as an example[J].Dong Yue Tribune,37(4):55-61.(in Chinese)
• 李元珍.2014.政策网络视角下的府际联动——基于重庆地票政策执行的案例分析[J].中国行政管理,(10):95-100.Li Y Z.2014.Intergovernmental linkage from the perspective of policy network-based on the case analysis of Chongqing land ticket policy implementation[J].Chinese Public Administration,(10):95-100.(in Chinese)
• 罗立.2013.政策执行力研究综述:现状、问题与发展——基于中国十年来政策执行力研究的文献分析[J].北京航空航天大学学报(社会科学版),26(2):1-5.Luo L.2013.Literature review on policy executive power:Present situation,problems and development based on the literature analysis about 10 years domestic policy executive power[J].Journal of Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics(Social Sciences Edition),26(2):1-5.(in Chinese)
• 宋雄伟.2014.政策执行网络:一种研究政策执行问题的理论探索[J].国家行政学院学报,(3):66-70,122.Song X W.2014.Policy implementation network:A theoretical study of policy implementation[J].Journal of Chinese Academy of Governance,(3):66-70,122.(in Chinese)
• 宋雄伟,张婧婧.2018.政策执行与科层结构中的“关键学习者”[J].经济社会体制比较,(3):71-81.Song X W,Zhang J J.2018.Policy implementation and"Critical Learners"in the bureaucratic structure[J].Comparative Economic&Social Systems,(3):71-81.(in Chinese)
• 谭英俊,黄山楠.2014.公共治理热点:地方政府政策执行力研究综述——基于CNKI文献的分析[J].广东行政学院学报,26(6):17-23.Tan Y J,Huang S N.2014.Hot spots of public governance'A review of the research on the implementation of local government policies based on CNKI literature[J].Journal of Guangdong Institute of Public Administration,26(6):17-23.(in Chinese)
• 王春福.2008.政府执行力与政策网络的运行机制[J].政治学研究,(3):82-89.Wang C F.2008.The executive power of government and the operation mechanism of policy network[J].Political Studies,(3):82-89.(in Chinese)
• 吴宾,齐昕.2019.政策执行研究的中国图景及演化路径[J].公共管理与政策评论,(4):33-46.Wu B,Qi X.2019.Policy implementation research's China image and evaluation path[J].Public Administration and Policy Review,(4):33-46.(in Chinese)
• 于君博,宋宪策.2018.中外政策执行研究前沿比较——为“行动者中心视角”正名[J].公共管理评论,(2):101-114.Yu J B,Song X C.2018.Comparing the frontiers of research on policy implementation in China and abroad:The actor-centered perspective[J]. China Public Administration Review,(2):101-114.(in Chinese)
• 朱亚鹏.2008.政策网络分析:发展脉络与理论构建[J].中山大学学报(社会科学版),48(5):192-199.Zhu Y P.2008.An analysis of policy network:Development and theory building[J].Journal of Sun Yat-Sen University(Social Science Edition),48(5):192-199.(in Chinese)
• Agranoff R,McGuire M.2001.Big questions in public network management research[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,11(3):295-326.
• Agranoff R.2006.Inside collaborative networks:Ten lessons for public managers[J].Public Administration Review,66(S1):56-65.
• Alexander E R.1995.How organizations act together:Inter orgauizational coordination in theory and practice[M].London:Routledge.
• Bach T,de Francesco F,Maggetti M,et al.2016.Transnational bureaucratic politics:An institutional rivalry perspective on EU network governance[J].Public Administration,94(1):9-24.
• Bache I,Flinders M.2004.Multi-level governance[M].Oxford:Oxford University Press.
• Bauer A,Feichtinger J,Steurer R.2012.The governance of climate change adaptation in 10OECD countries:Challenges and approaches[J]. Journal of Environmental Policy&Planuing,14(3):279-304.
• Benson J K.1975.The interorganizational network as a political economy[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,20(2):229-249.
• Benson J K.1982.A framework for policy analysis[M]//Rogers D L,Whetten D A.Interorganizational Coordination:Theory,Research,and Implementation.Ames,IA:Iowa State University Press,137-176.
• Benz A,F(u|")rst D.2002.Policy learning in regional networks[J].European Urban and Regional Studies,9(1):21-35.
• Blair R.2002.Policy tools theory and implementation networks:Understanding state enterprise zone partnerships[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,12(2):161-190.
• Borzel T A.1998.Organizing Babylon-on the different conceptions of policy networks[J].Public Administration,76(2):253-273.
• Carlsson L.2000.Policy networks as collective action[J].Policy Studies Journal,28(3):502-520.
• Clarke N.2013.Model of complexity leadership development[J].Human Resource Development International,16(2):135-150.
• Cohen N,Reynolds K.2014.Urban agriculture policy making in New York's"New Political Spaces”:Strategizing for a participatory and representative system[J].Journal of Planning Education and Research,34(2):221-234.
• Crivello S.2015.Urban policy mobilities:The case of Turin as a smart city[J].European Planning Studies,23(5):909-921.
• Currie G,Grubnic S,Hodges R.2011.Leadership in public services networks:Antecedents,process and outcome[J].Public Administration,89(2):242-264.
• Damgaard B.2006.Do policy networks lead to network governing?[J].Public Administration,84(3):673-691.
• DeLeon P,Varda D M.2009.Toward a theory of collaborative policy networks:Identifying structural tendencies[J].Policy Studies Journal,37(1):59-74.
• Egeberg M,Trondal J.2016.Why strong coordination at one level of government is incompatible with strong coordination across levels(and How to Live with It):The case of the European Union[J].Public Administration,94(3):579-592.
• Fischer M,Sciarini P.2013.Europeanization and the inclusive strategies of executive actors[J].Journal of European Public Policy,20(10):1482-1498.
• Fyall R.2016.The power of nonprofits Mechanisms for nonprofit policy influence[J].Public Administration Review,76(6):938-948.
• Goggin M L,Bowman A 0,Lester J P,et al.1990.Implementation theory and practice:Toward a third generation[M].Glenview,IL:Scott,Foresman/Little Brown Higher Education.
• Gouglas A.2015.Greek ministerial advisers:Policy managers,not experts?[J].International Journal of Public Administration,38(1):15-27.
• Grantham A.2001.How networks explain unintended policy implementation outcomes:The case of UK rail privatization[J].Public Administration,79(4):851-870.
• Greenaway J,Salter B,Hart S.2007.How policy networks can damage democratic health:A case study in the government of governance[J].Public Administration,85(3):717-738.
• Greers D G.1981.State-level coordination and policy implementation[J].Policy Studies Journal,10(1):32-47.
• Hajer M,Hendrik W.2003.Deliberative policy analysis:Understanding governance in the network society[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
• Hall T E,O'Toole L J Jr.2000.Structures for policy implementation:An analysis of national legislation,1965—1966 and 1993—1994[J].Administration&Society,31(6):667-686.
• Hall T E,O'Toole L J Jr.2004.Shaping Formal Networks Through the Regulatory Process[J].Administration&Society,36(2):186-207.
• Hanf K,O'Toole L J Jr.1992.Revisiting old friends:Networks,implementation Structures and the management of inter-organizational relations[J].European Journal of Political Research,21(1/2):163-180.
• Hay C,Richards D.2000.The tangled webs of Westminster and Whitehall:The discourse,strategy and practice of networking within the British core executive[J].Public Administration,78(1):1-28.
• Heeks R,Stanforth C.2014.Understanding development project implementation:An actornetwork perspective[J].Public Administration and Development,34(1):14-31.
• Heidbreder E G.2017.Strategies in multilevel policy implementation:Moving beyond the limited focus on compliance[J].Journal of European Public Policy,24(9):1367-1384.
• Hill H C.2003.Understanding implementation:Street-level bureaucrats'resources for reform[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,13(3):265-282.
• Hill M.1997.Implementation theory:Yesterday's issue?[J].Policy and Politics,25(4):375-385.
• Hill M,Hupe P.2009.Implementing public policy:Governance in theory and in practice[M].London:Sage.
• Hill M,Hupe P.2014.Implementing public policy:An introduction to the study of operational governance[M].3rd ed.London:Sage.
• Hjern B,Porter D 0.1981.Implementation structures:A new unit of administrative analysis[J].Organization.Studies,2(3):21 1-227.
• Howlett M.2019.Moving policy implementation theory forward:A multiple streams/critical juncture approach[J].Public Policy and Administration,34(4):405-430.
• Hupe P,Saetren H.2014.The sustainable future of implementation research:On the development of the field and its paradoxes[J].Public Policy and Administration,29(2):77-83.
• Hupe P,Saetren H.2015.Comparative implementation research:Directions and dualities[J].Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis:Research and Practice,17(2):93-102.
• Hupe P L,Hill M J.2016."And the rest is implementation.” Comparing approaches to what happens in policy processes beyond Great Expectations[J].Public Policy and Administration,31(2):103-121.
• Ingold K,Leifeld P.2016.Structural and institutional determinants of influence reputation:A comparison of collaborative and adversarial policy networks in decision making and implementation[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,26(1):1-18.
• Johansson R,Borell K.1999.Central steering and local networks:Old-age care in Sweden[J].Public Administration,77(3):585-598.
• Jones S.2013.Climate change policies of city governments in federal systems:An analysis of Vancouver,Melbourne and New York City[J].Regional Studies,47(6):974-992.
• Kenbeek S D,Bone C,Moseley C.2016.A network modeling approach to policy implementation in natural resource management agencies[J].Computers,Environment and Urban Systems,57:155-177.
• Kickert W J M,Klijn E H,Koppenjan J F M.1997.Managing complex networks-:Strategies for the public sector[M].London:Sage Publications.
• Klaster E,Wilderom C P M,Muntslag D R.2017.Balancing relations and results in regional networks of public-policy implementation[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,27(4):676-691.
• Klijn E H.2005.Designing and managing networks:Possibilities and limitations for network management[J].European Political.Science,4(3):328-339.
• Koppenjan J,Kars M,van der Voort H.2009.Vertical politics in horizontal policy networks:Framework setting as coupling arrangement[J].Policy Studies Journal,37(4):769-792.
• La Porte T R.1996.Shifting vantage and conceptual puzzles in understanding public organization networks[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,6(1):49-74.
• Lecy J D,Mergel I A,Schmitz H P.2014.Networks in public administration:Current scholarship in review[J].Public Management Review,16(5):643-665.
• Lee T,Koski C.2014.Mitigating global warming in global cities:Comparing participation and climate change policies of C40 cities[J].Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis:Research and Practice,16(5):475-492.
• Leifeld P.2013.Reconceptualizing major policy change in the advocacy coalition framework:A discourse network analysis of German pension politics[J].Policy Studies Journal,41(1):169-198.
• Lester J P,Goggin M L.1998.Back to the future:The rediscovery of implementation studies[J].Policy Currents,8(3):1-9.
• Li L C.2010.Central-local relations in the people's republic of China:Trends,processes and impacts for policy implementation[J].Public Administration and Development,30(3):177-190.
• Lotta G S,Marques E C.2020.How social networks affect policy implementation:An analysis of street-level bureaucrats'performance regarding a health policy[J].Social Policy&Administration,54(3):345-360.
• Loyens K.2019.Networks as unit of analysis in street-level bureaucracy research[M]//Hupe P.Research Handbook on Street-Level Bureaucracy.Cheltenham,UK:Edward Elgar,351-369.
• Lundin M.2007.Explaining cooperation:How resource interdependence,goal congruence,andtrust affect joint actions in policy implementation[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,17(4):651-672.
• Mandell M.1984.Application of network analysis to the implementation of a complex project[J].Human Relations,37(8):659-679.
• Marsh D,Smith M.2000.Understanding policy networks:Towards a dialectical approach[J].Political.Studies,48(1):4-21.
• Mathieu E.2016.When Europeanization feeds back into EU governance:EU legislation,national regulatory agencies,and EU regulatory networks[J].Public Administration,94(1):25-39.
• Matland R E.1995.Synthesizing the implementation literature:The Ambiguity-conflict model of policy implementation[J].Journal of Public Administration Research&Theory,5(2):145-174.
• Meier K J,O'Toole L J Jr.2003.Public management and educational performance:The impact of managerial networking[J].Public Administration Review,63(6):689-699.
• Newig J,Challies E,Jager N W,et al.2018.The environmental performance of participatory and collaborative governance:A framework of causal mechanisms[J]. Policy Studies Journal,46(2):269-297.
• O'Toole L J Jr.1986.Policy recommendations for multi-actor implementation:An assessment of the field[J].Journal of Public Policy,6(2):181-210.
• O'Toole L J Jr.1993.Interorganizational policy studies:Lessons drawn from implementation research[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,3(2):232-251.
• O'Toole L J Jr.1997.Treating networks seriously:Practical and research-based agendas in public administration[J].Public Administration Review,57(1):45-53.
• O'Toole L J Jr,Hanf K I,Hupe P L.1997.Managing implementation processes in networks[M]//Kickert W J M,Klijn E H,Koppenjan J F M.Managing Complex Networks:Strategies for the Public.Sector.London:Sage,137-151.
• O'Toole L J Jr,Meier K J.1999.Modeling the impact of public management:Implications of structural context[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,9(4):505-526.
• O'Toole L J Jr.2000.Research on policy implementation:Assessment and prospects[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,10(2):263-288.
• Olvera-Garcia J,Neil S.2019.Examining how collaborative governance facilitates the implementation of natural resource planning policies:A water planning policy case from the Great Barrier Reef[J].Environmental Policy and Governance,doi:10.1002/eet.1875.
• Peters B G,Pierre J.2001.Developments in intergovernmental relations:Towards multilevel governance[J].Policy and Politics,29(2):131-135.
• Pitt D.2010.The impact of internal and external characteristics on the adoption of climatemitigation policies by US municipalities[J].Environment and Planning C:Government and Policy,28(5):851-871.
• Pressman J L,Wildavsky A.1984.Implementation[M].Berkeley:University of California Press.
• Pro van K G,Milward H B.2001.Do networks really work? A framework for evaluating publicsector organizational networks[J].Public Administration Review,61(4):414-423.
• Provan K G,Huang K.2012.Resource tangibility and the evolution of a publicly funded health and human services network[J].Public Administration Review,72(3):366-375.
• Rhodes R A W.1997.Understanding governance:Policy networks,governance,reflexivity and accountability[M].Buckingham;Philadelphia:Open University Press.
• Saetren H.2005.Facts and myths about research on public policy implementation:Out-offashion,allegedly dead,but still very much alive and relevant[J].The Policy Studies Journal,33(4):559-578.
• Saetren H.2014.Implementing the third generation research paradigm in policy implementation research:An empirical assessment[J].Public Policy and Administration,29(2):84-105.
• Saz-Carranza A,Iborra S S,Albareda A.2016.The power dynamics of mandated network administrative organizations[J].Public Administration Review,76(3):449-462.
• Scholten M.2017.Mind the trendi Enforcement of EU law has been moving to"Brussels”[J]_Journal of European Public Policy,24(9):1348-1366.
• Schrama R.2019.Swift,brokered and broad-based information exchange:How network structure facilitates stakeholders monitoring EU policy Implementation[J].Journal of Public Policy,39(4):565-585.
• Schroeder A D.2001.Building implementation networks:Building multi-organizational,multisectorial structures for policy implementation[D].Blacksburg:Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University.
• Siciliano M D,Moolenaar N M,Daly A J,et al.2017.A cognitive perspective on policy implementation:Reform beliefs,sensemaking,and social networks[J].Public Administration Review,77(6):889-901.
• Smith A.2000.Policy networks and advocacy coalitions:Explaining policy change and stability in UK industrial pollution policy?[J].Environment&Planning C:Government&Policy,18(1):95-114.
• Smith J M,Halgin D S,Kidwell-Lopez V,et al.2014.Power in politically charged networks[J].Social Networks,36:162-176.
• Stillman R J.1992.Public administration:Concepts and cases[M].Boston,MA:Houghton Mifflin.
• Stone D.2008.Global public policy,transnational policy communities,and their networks[J].Policy Studies Journal,36(1):19-38.
• Swann W L.2017.Examining the impact of local collaborative tools on urban sustainability efforts:Does the managerial environment matter?[J].The American Review of Public Administration,47(4):455-468.
• Thomann E,Lieberherr E,Ingold K.2016.Torn between state and market:Private policy implementation and conflicting institutional logics[J].Policy and Society,35(1):57-69.
• Van Meerkerk I,Edelenbos J.2014.The effects of boundary spanners on trust and performance of urban governance networks:Findings from survey research on urban development projects in the Netherlands[J].Policy Sciences,47(1):3-24.
• Villadsen A R.2011.Structural embeddedness of political top executives as explanation of policy isomorphism[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,21(4):573-599.
• Wang X H,Chen K,Berman E M.2016.Building network implementation capacity:Evidence from China[J].International Public Management Journal,19(2):264-291.
• Zhelyazkova A,Kaya C,Schrama R.2016.Decoupling practical and legal compliance:Analysis of member states'implementation of EU policy[J].European Journal of Political Research,55(4):827-846.