杨雪冬

• 1: 中央编译局

摘要(Abstract)：

本文在梳理了治理改革与技术创新的一般理论的基础上,提出了分析地方治理改革中技术创新的基本框架。然后通过对三个案例:秘密划票间、"廉政账户"、"政府上网"工程的分析,检验了这个框架。案例分析表明,政府对技术使用的资源支持能力和上级权威的认同在三个案例中起到了关键作用。在中国的地方治理改革中,地方需要获得更大创新空间。更重要的是,技术创新始终是实现制度变革的一个手段,建立良好的制度才是地方治理改革的根本目的。

关键词(KeyWords)： 技术创新;制度创新;地方治理

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation):

作者(Author): 杨雪冬

参考文献(References)：

• ① Thomas G.Weiss,“Governance,Good Governance and Global Governance:Conceptual and Actual Challenges,”Third World Quarterly,Vol.21,No.5 (2000) ,pp.795-814．
• ② Thomas G.Weiss(2000) 在其文章中列举的世界银行、联合国发展署、经合发组织、智力研究所(渥太华)、全球治理委员会、国际行政管理科学研究所、东京技术研究所等的定义都反映了这种倾向。
• ③ J.Pierre,“Introduction:Understanding Governance”.in J.Pierre (ed.),Debating Governance.Oxford:Oxford University Press,2000．
• ④ G.Shabbir Cheema,Linda Maguire,“Governance for Human Development:The Role of External Partners,”Public Administration and Development,No.21 (2001) ,pp.201-209．
• ② Peter John,Local Governance in Western Europe.London:Sage Publications,2001．
• ③ Robert M.Solow,“A Contribution to the Theory of Economic Growth,”Quarterly Journal of Economics,Vol.70 (February 1956) ,pp.65-94．
• ④ UNDP,Human Development Report 2001:Making New Technologies Work for Human Development.New York:Oxford University Press,2001．
• ⑤ Jeffrey K.Liker,Carol J.Haddad and Jennifer Karlin,“Perspectives on Technology and Work Organization,”American Review of Sociology,No.25 (1999) ,pp.575-596．
• ① R.E.Walton,GI.Susman,“People Policies for the New Machines,”Harvard Business Review,No.2(March-April 1987) ,pp.98-106． S.Zuboff,In the Age of the Smart Machine:The Future of Work and Power.New York:Basic Books,1988．
• ② B.P.Bloomfiled,R.Coombs,“Information Technology,Control and Power,the Centralization and Decentralization Debate Revisited,”Journal of Management Studies,Vol.29 (1992) ,pp.459-484．
• ③ 道格拉斯·诺斯.经济史中的结构与变迁.陈郁等译.上海:三联书店,1994
• ⑤ John Street,“The Technological ‘Revolution’ in Government”,in Lynton Robins,Bill Jones.Eds,Half a Century of British Politics.Manchester:Manchester University Press,1998．
• ① Stanford F.Borins,“Public Sector Innovation:the Implications of New Forms of Organization andWork”,in Guy Peters,Donald J.Savoie (eds.),Governance in a Changing Environment.Montreal:MaGill-Queen's University Press,1995．
• ② Joseph A.Schumpeter:Business Cycles.New York:McGraw-Hill,1939．
• ③ Joel Mokyr:The Lever of Riches:Technological Creativity and Economic Progress.New York:Oxford University Press,1990．
• ⑤ Nelson W.Polsby,Political Innovation in Araerica:The Politics of Policy Initiation.New Haven:Yale University Press,1984．
• ① Alan A.Altshuler.“Public Innovation and Political Incentives,”Papers of American Government Program at John F.Kennedy School of Government,Harvard University,Fall 1997．
• ② Alan A.Altshuler,Marc D.Zegans,“Innovation and Public Management:Notes from the State House and City Hall”,In Alan A.Altshuler,Robert D.Behn (eds.),Innovation in American Government:Challenges,Opportunities,and Dilemmas.Washington,D.C.:Brookings Institution Press,1997,pp.68-82．
• ③ Lawrence B.Mohr,“Determinants of Innovation in Organization,”The American Political Science Review,Vol.63,No.1 (March 1969) ,pp.111-126．
• ① Lawrence B.Mohr,“Determinants of Innovation in Organization”,The American Political Science Review,Vol.63,No.1 (March 1969) ,pp.111-126．
• ② Nelson W.Polsby:Political Innovation in America:The Politics of Policy Initiation.New Haven:Yale University Press,1984．
• ③ Alan A.Altshuler,“Public Innovation and Political Incentives,”Papers of American Government Program at John F.Kennedy School of Government,Harvard University,Fall 1997．
• ④ Joel Mokyr,The Lever of Riches:Technological Creativity and Economic Progress.New York:Oxford University Press,1990．
• ① Alan A.Altshuler,“Bureaucratic Innovation,Democratic Accountability,and Political Incentive,”in Alan A.Altshuler,Robert D.Behn (eds.),Innovation in American Government:Challenges,Opportunities,and Dilemmas.Washington,D.C.:Brookings Institution Press,1997,pp.38-67．
• ② Castells M.,Internet Galaxy:Reflections on the lnternet,Business and Society.New York:Oxford University Press,2001．
• ③ Paul DiMaggio,Eszter Hargittail,W.Russell Neuman,and John P.Robinson,“Social Implications of the Internet,”Annual Review of Sociology,Vol.27 (2001) ,pp.307-336．
• ④ http://www.cnnic.net.cn/develst/2002-1/
• ① http://www.cnnic.net.cn/develst/2002-1/
• ② 蒋荣蓉.电子政府离我们有多远.http://www.people.com,2000-07-02
• ③ 统计显示全国有七成地市级政府上网.北京晚报,2002-03-07
• ④ 张旭东.数字接管城市--广东南海的信息化路径.http://www.sina.com.cn,2001-04-29
• ⑤ 有兴趣的朋友可以访问南海市政府网站 http://www.nanhai.gov.cn。
• ⑥ 2002年6月,南海市的利用网络减少腐败的经验还在中央纪律检查委员会进行了展示,受到了好评。“广东南海‘网络反腐’高手进中纪委传经,反响热烈”.羊城晚报,2002-06-24。
• ① 以南海为例,就有人对政府大力宣传网络建设提出了质疑:“现场会频频召开,参观团络绎不绝,南海正在做一场高科技秀”张旭东.数字接管城市--广东南海的信息化路径.http://www.sina.com.cn.2001-04-29
• ② 比如在新疆乌鲁木齐市就出现过市长和副市长与市民在网络上讨论市政建设的事例。市长市民“网议”市政.www.xinhua.org,2001-01-05
• ② 转引自何增科.中国转型期的腐败与反腐败问题研究:一种制度分析.马克思主义与现实,2001
• ③ 齐文信.扑克反腐败“前腐后继”.http://www.duoweiweek.com/96/ChinaAffairs/7702． html。
• ④ 电视片名为《痛悔--湖北省现身说纪说法警示教育》。
• ① “581”:引人关注的廉政新举,见 http://www.dflz.gov.cn.
• ③ 《检察日报》,2000年3月28日。
• ⑤ 《报刊文摘》,2000-04-24
• ① 朱荣成.警惕!“廉政账户”成了腐败的“挡箭牌”.人民日报,2001-09-26
• ② 浙江省纪委:廉政账户决非反腐主渠道.文汇报,2001-06-19
• ① 浙江省纪委:廉政账户决非反腐主渠道.文汇报,2001-06-19
• ① 孙中山.建国方略.见:孙中山全集,6:413
• ① Kevin J.O' Brien,Lianjiang Li,“Accommodating ‘Democracy’in a One-party State:Introducing Village Elections in China,”The China Quarterly,No.162 (June 2000) ,pp.465-489．
• ③ 村民自治与村级直选·张明亮与网友交流录.人民日报强国论坛,2000-04-20． http://www.peopledaily.com.cn。
• ① 同民政部官员王振耀的讨论,2000年。