中国公共管理研究的进展和热点:基于2021年英文期刊论文的分析Chinese Research on Public Administration in 2021: An Analysis Based on International Journals
史晓姣,余佳欣,马亮
摘要(Abstract):
本文选取中国大陆学者2021年在公共管理领域SSCI源期刊发表的中国主题论文,整理和评估中国公共管理研究国际化的现状、特征与趋势,包括论文出处、作者教育背景、合作情况、署名顺序、研究领域与主题、研究方法、具体分析方法和数据来源类型等方面。研究发现,官员行为、府际关系、公共管理创新、绩效管理和多层次治理这五个方面是2021年的热点议题。大陆学者扎实推进中国式概念和理论探究,并密切关注本土实践,从多个视角拓展中国公共管理研究。
关键词(KeyWords): 学科评估;研究综述;国际发表;公共管理;本土化
基金项目(Foundation): 北京市社会科学基金青年带头人项目(重点项目)“接诉即办、政府绩效管理与城市治理创新”(项目批准号:21DTR058);; 国家自然科学基金面上项目“数字政府如何降低行政负担:面向中国地方政府的实证研究”(项目批准号:72274203)资助
作者(Author): 史晓姣,余佳欣,马亮
参考文献(References):
- 刘润泽,巩宜萱.2020.回顾与反思:定量研究在公共管理学科的滥用[J].公共管理学报,17(1):152-158.Liu R Z,Gong Y X.2020.Review and reflection:The misuse of quantitative research in public administration[J].Journal of Public Management,17(1):152-158.(in Chinese)
- 马骏.2012.中国公共行政学:回顾与展望[J].中国行政管理,(4):7-11.Ma J.2012.The review and prospect of Chinese public administration[J].Chinese Public Administration,(4):7-11.(in Chinese)
- 史晓姣,马亮.2021.中国公共管理研究的国际化:基于2019年英文期刊论文的分析[J].公共管理评论,3(2):160-180.Shi X J,Ma L.2021.The internationalization of Chinese public administration research:An analysis of 2019 English-language journals[J].China Public Administration Review,3(2):160-180.(in Chinese)
- 史晓姣,马亮.2022.中国公共管理研究的进展和热点:基于2020年英文期刊论文的分析[J].公共管理评论,4(2):203-220.Shi X J,Ma L.2022.Progress and hotspots in the internationalization of Chinese public administration research—An analysis of English-language journals in 2020[J].China Public Administration Review,4(2):203-220.(in Chinese)
- 杨开峰,邢小宇,刘卿斐,等.2021.我国治理研究的反思(2007—2018):概念、理论与方法[J].行政论坛,28(1):119-128.Yang K F,Xing X Y,Liu Q F,et al.2021.Reflection on governance research in China (2007—2018):Concept,theory and method[J].Administrative Tribune,28(1):119-128.(in Chinese)
- 杨立华,常多粉.2019.中国行政学三十年的范式变迁:从行政管理到公共治理[J].中国行政管理,(6):94-102.Yang L H,Chang D F.2019.Paradigm shifts of Chinese public administration in past thirty years (1986—2016):From traditional public administration to public governance[J].Chinese Public Administration,(6):94-102.(in Chinese)
- 叶晓梅,梁文艳.2019.海归教师真的优于本土教师吗?——来自研究型大学教育学科的证据[J].教育与经济,(1):75-86.Ye X M,Liang W Y.2019.Are returnees really better than local teachers?—Evidence from education department of research university[J].Education & Economy,(1):75-86.(in Chinese)
- 张建民,江华.2009.国际学术界对中国公共管理的研究现状——论题、理论视角与方法[J].公共管理学报,6(2):1-13.Zhang J M,Jiang H.2009.The current state of international research on public administration in China—Topics,theoretical perspectives,and methods[J].Journal of Public Management,6(2):1-13.(in Chinese)
- Béland D,Rocco P,Shi S J,et al.2018.Paths to (de)centralization:Changing territorial dynamics of social policy in the People's Republic of China and the United States[J].Environment and Planning C:Politics and Space,36(5):897-915.
- Chan K N,Fan S W.2021.Friction and bureaucratic control in authoritarian regimes[J].Regulation & Governance,15(4):1406-1418.
- Cheng M Y,Qin F Y.2021.Innovation in construction of local eco-civilized cities in China:Cooperative construction mechanism with multi-element objects[J].Journal of Chinese Governance,6(3):375-395.
- Gong K L,Cheng Y.2022.Patterns and impact of collaboration in China's social sciences:Cross-database comparisons between CSSCI and SSCI[J].Scientometrics,127(10):5947-5964.
- Groeneveld S,Tummers L,Bronkhorst B,et al.2015.Quantitative methods in public administration:Their use and development through time[J].International Public Management Journal,18(1):61-86.
- Guo S H,Song Q J,Qi Y.2021.Innovation or implementation?Local response to low-carbon policy experimentation in China[J].Review of Policy Research,38(5):555-569.
- Huang B A,Wiebrecht F.2021.The dynamic role of governments in adopting policy innovations in China[J].Policy and Politics,49(4):633-651.
- Huang C,Chen W N,Yi H T.2021.Collaborative networks and environmental governance performance:A social influence model[J].Public Management Review,23(12):1878-1899.
- Jing Y J.2021.Marching through the deep-water zone:Chinese public sector reforms and the way forwards[J].Public Management Review,23(4):475-482.
- Kim M H,Li H F,Holzer M,et al.2019.Public administration research in Chinese mainland:A systematic review of Chinese public administration in English language journals (1996—2016)[J].International Journal of Public Administration,42(9):753-764.
- Li H,Zhang J S.2021.Chinese public administration research in mainstream PA journals:A systematic review (2002—2020)[M]//Bryer T A.Handbook of Theories of Public Administration and Management.Cheltenham,UK:Edward Elgar Publishing,286-298.
- Liu Y,Wu J N,Yi H T,et al.2021.Under what conditions do governments collaborate?A qualitative comparative analysis of air pollution control in China[J].Public Management Review,23(11):1664-1682.
- Liu Z L,Guo J,Zhong W,et al.2021a.Multi-level governance,policy coordination and subnational responses to COVID-19:Comparing China and the US[J].Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis :Research and Practice,23(2):204-218.
- Liu Z L,Yang Y Q,Wu J N.2021b.Participatory management,goal ambiguity,and gaming behaviors in performance management:Evidence from township government cadres in Chinese mainland[J].Public Performance & Management Review,44(1):58-80.
- Lu X L,Xu H,Wang W J.2021.Clients' help deservingness,crowd situational stress and discretionary decision-making:An experimental study of regulatory street-level bureaucrats in China[J].International Public Management Journal,24(2):287-312.
- Lyu P H,Zhang M Z,Liu C J,et al.2022.Global scientific production,international cooperation,and knowledge evolution of public administration[J].Public Administration,1-29.DOI:10.1111/padm.12853.
- Ongaro E,Gong T,Jing Y J.2021.Public administration,context and innovation:A framework of analysis[J].Public Administration and Development,41(1):4-11.
- Shi C Y,Frenkiel E.2021.Policy entrepreneurship under hierarchy:How state actors change policies in China[J].Journal of Chinese Governance,6(3):351-374.
- Tian C H,Teng Y,Guo H.2021.Resource flow or yardstick competition:Spatial dependence of educational expenditure among prefecture-level cities[J].International Public Management Journal,24(5):691-709.
- Wang Y R,Wu Q Z,Zhang X,et al.2021.Why does organizational performance fluctuate in agricultural industrialization consortia:A study based on dual paradox in development and institution[J].Lex Localis-Journal of Local Self-Government,19(4):921-941.
- Wei Y M,Guo Y,Su J.2021.Dancing on a tightrope:The reputation management of local governments in response to public protests in China[J].Public Administration,99(3):547-562.
- Xiang J Q,Ma F C.2021.Government agencies and their roles in the diffusion of intellectual property policy in China:Analysis based on a policy literature reference network[J].International Review of Administrative Sciences,87(4):888-907.
- Yang F,Li Z C,Huang X X.2021.Frontline information disclosure and street-level bureaucrats' willingness to follow the rules:Evidence from local regulatory agencies in China[J].International Public Management Journal,24(6):831-845.
- Ye L,Peng X G,Aniche L Q,et al.2021.Urban renewal as policy innovation in China:From growth stimulation to sustainable development[J].Public Administration and Development,41(1):23-33.
- Yee W H,Liu P.2021.Governance capacity and regulatory enforcement:Street-level organizations in Beijing's food safety reform[J].International Review of Administrative Sciences,87(2):256-274.
- Yi H T,Liu W X,Li F.2021.Network structure and low-carbon governance performance:A qualitative comparative analysis[J].International Public Management Journal,24(1):23-46.
- Zhang L,Shang Y Y,Huang Y,et al.2021.Toward internationalization:A bibliometric analysis of the social sciences in Chinese mainland from 1979 to 2018[J].Quantitative Science Studies,2(1):376-408.
- Zhang L W,Zhao J,Dong W W.2021.Street-level bureaucrats as policy entrepreneurs:Action strategies for flexible community governance in China[J].Public Administration,99(3):469-483.
- Zhang N D Y,Rosenbloom D H,Dong C G.2021.Deficits pro forma and substantive:Multilevel policy implementation in China's administrative approval intermediaries reform[J].The American Review of Public Administration,51(6):467-481.
- Zhang P.2021.Target interactions and target aspiration level adaptation:How do government leaders tackle the "Environment-Economy" nexus?[J].Public Administration Review,81(2):220-230.
- Zhang Y X,Wang S C.2021.How does policy innovation diffuse among Chinese local governments?A qualitative comparative analysis of River Chief Innovation[J].Public Administration and Development,41(1):34-47.
- Zhao C,Feng F,Chen Y E,et al.2021.Local government competition and regional innovation efficiency:From the perspective of China-style fiscal federalism[J].Science and Public Policy,48(4):488-489.
- Zhu X F,Zhao H.2021.Experimentalist governance with interactive central-local relations:Making new pension policies in China[J].Policy Studies Journal,49(1):13-36.