纪锋

• 1:清华大学公共管理学院

摘要(Abstract)：

在分析凯恩斯计划的背景、原则与内容的基础上,本文探讨了凯恩斯计划与解决当前国际货币体系缺陷的相关性。凯恩斯计划下的国际货币体系是一个以规则为基础的体系,是建立在国内和国际公共机构对国际清算体系的垄断和对投机性资本流动进行限制的基础上的,因此与当前以美元为关键货币、以金融全球化为主要特征的国际货币体系存在根本性的矛盾。但它却是从根本上解决当前国际货币体系问题的方法。扩大特别提款权(SDR)发行及使用范围,并使之逐步取代美元作为国际储备货币的渐进改革方案是建立在当前以权力为基础的国际货币体系的基础之上的。正因为如此,它无法对关键货币发行国和私人资本形成有效的约束,从而无法建立一种真正的世界货币,并从根本上解决当前国际货币体系存在的内在矛盾与问题。在以上分析基础上,本文进一步探讨了国际货币体系改革对我国公共政策选择的含义。

关键词(KeyWords)： 凯恩斯计划;国际货币体系;特别提款权

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation):

作者(Author): 纪锋

参考文献(References)：

• [1]周小川.关于改革国际货币体系的思考.2009-03-24中国人民银行网站.
• [2]有大量文献分析金本位制及其价格铸币流动机制,如S.Knafo的文章。见Knafo S.The Gold Standard and the Origins of the Modern International Monetary System.Review of International Political Economy,2006, 13(1):78-102.
• [1]Kindleberger C.A Financial History of Western Europe.1984.
• [2]Eichengreen B.Globalizing Capital:A History of the International Monetary System.Princeton: Princeton University Press,1996:63-84.
• [3]Eichengreen B.Globalizing Capital:A History of the International Monetary System.Princeton: Princeton University Press,1996:85-88.
• [4]Frieden J A.Global Capitalism:its Fall and Rise in the Twentieth Century.New York: Norton&-Company,2006:249.
• [5]德国的双边和多边清算计划分别由当时的德国经济部长沙赫特(Hjalmar Schacht)和德意志银行行长方克(Walther Funk)制定。Child F C.The Theory and Practice of Exchange Control in Germany.Hague:Martinus Nijhoff,1958.Guillebaud C W.Hitler's New Economic Order for Europe.Economic Journal,1940,(200): 449-460.
• [1]Keynes J M.National Self-Sufficiency.The Yale Review,1939,22(4):759.
• [2]Keynes J M,Moggridge D E.The Collected Writings of J.M.Keynes:volumes 25.London:Macmillan,1940:2.
• [3]同上,8-9页。
• [4]Costabile,L.(2009):“Current global imbalances and the Keynes Plan:A Keynesian approach for reforming the international monetary system”,in Structural Change and Economic Dynamics 2009(20):84-87.
• [5]关于凯恩斯计划的主要目标见I.Vegh文章。Vegh I.The International Clearing Union.in The American Economic Review,1943,33(3):534-556.
• [1]见1943年4月英国政府提交的凯恩斯计划原文。Horsefield J K.The International Monetary Fund 1945-65,Washington:International Monetary Fund,1963,3:24.或者参见Piffaretti N F.Reshaping the international monetary architecture:lessons from the Keynes Plan.in Banks and Bank Systems,2009,4(1):45-54.
• [2]见1943年4月英国政府提交的凯恩斯计划原文第六条第11款。Horsefield J K.The International Monetary Fund 1945-65,Washington:International Monetary Fund,1969,3:24.
• [3]D'Arista J.Reforming the privatized international monetary and financial architecture//Mullineux A, Murinde V.Handbook of International Banking.Edward Elgar,Massachusetts,US,2003:745.本文对原表做了适当调整。
• [1]Ruggie J D.International Regimes,Transactions and Change:Embedded Liberalism in the Postwar Economic Order.International Organization,1982,36(2):379-416.
• [1]Bordo M D.The Bretton Woods International Monetary System:A Historical Overview//Bordo M D, Eichengreen B.A retrospective on the Bretton Woods System.Chicago:Chicago University Press,1993:3-98.
• [2]同上。
• [3]Machlup F.Plans for the Reform of the International Monetary System.Princeton Essays in international economics.Princeton university,1964.
• [4]Triffin R.Gold and the Dollar Crisis.New Haven:Conn,Yale University Press,1960.
• [1]Dooley M P,Folkerts-Landau D,Garber P M.An Essay on the Revived Bretton Woods System.NBER Working Paper,No.9971,September 2003.
• [2]根据联合国国际货币与金融体系改革专家委员会的报告,2007年发展中国家向发达国家以低利率转移了3.7万亿美元。发展中国家向发达国家贷款的利率与发达国家向发展中国家贷款的利率之差造成的资源转移超过了发达国家向发展中国家的援助。见UN.Report of the Commission of Experts of the President of the United Nations General Assembly on Reforms of the International Monetary and Financial System.2009.
• [3]Summers L.The US current account deficit and the global economy,The Per Jacobsson Lecture,Sunday, October 3,Washington,D.C.,The Per Jacobson Foundation.2004:10.
• [4]余永定.国际货币体系改革和中国外汇储备资产保值.国际经济评论,2009,(5～6):18.
• [1]Williamson J.The Failure of World Monetary Reform,1971-1974.New York:New York University Press,1997.
• [2]Carbaugh R,Hedrick D.Losing faith in the dollar.in Challenge May-June,2008:99.
• [1]Henderson J.Uneven crisis:international foundations of East Asian economic turmoil.Economy and Society,1999,28(3):346.
• [2]Walter A.Understanding financial globalization in international political economy//Phillips N. Globalizing International Political Economy.New York:Palgrave,2005:152-153.
• [3]Goodman J,Pauly L.The obsolescence of capital controls?:economic management in an age of global markets.World Politics,1993,46(1):50-82.
• [1]Helleiner E.States and the Reemergence of Global Finance.New York:Cornell University Press,1994.
• [2]东亚金融危机之后有大量这方面的研究,如Wade R,Veneroso F.The gathering world slump and the battle over capital controls.New Left Review,1998,231:13-42.
• [3]Cooper Richard N.The Future of the Dollar.Policy Briefs in International Economics.Washington: Peterson Institute for International Economics,2009.
• [4]余永定.国际货币体系改革和中国外汇储备资产保值.国际经济评论,2009(5-6):18.
• [5]黄梅波,熊爱宗.特别提款权与国际货币体系改革.国际金融研究,2009,(8).
• [1]早在特别提款权发行之初,特里芬便对特别提款权的发行机制提出质疑。特里芬将储备货币创造和发展金融联系在一起。由于特别提款权要按份额分配,因此世界上最富裕的两个国家(美国和英国)得到约三分之一的特别提款权,因此他认为这种按份额分配的决定“无论在经济上还是道义上都是不合理的”。参见Triffin R. Our International Monetary System:Yesterday,Today and Tomorrow.New York:Random House,1968:194.
• [2]Soros G.Soros on Globalization.New York:Public Affairs,2002.
• [3]Wade R H.On Soros:Are Special Drawing Rights the Deus ex Machina of the World Economy?. Challenge,2002,September-October.112-124.
• [4]UN.Report of the Commission of Experts of the President of the United Nations General Assembly on Reforms of the International Monetary and Financial System.2009.
• [1]替代账户的建议最早由基金组织于1971年提出,之后不断有学者提出相关建议,在本次金融危机之后又成为热点,参见黄梅波,熊爱宗.“特别提款权与国际货币体系改革”.国际金融研究.2009(8).Richard N. Cooper,The Future of the dollar,Policy briefs in International Economics.Washington,2009.
• [2]参见Bergsten F.We Should Listen to Beijing's Currency Idea.Financial Times,2009.
• [3]Eichengreen B.Commercialize the SDR.Project Syndicate Comments,available at http://www.project-syndicate. org/commentary/eichengreen4.
• [4]参见Aiyar S S A.An International,Monetary Fund Currency to Rival the Dollar?.Washington:Cato Institute,2009.及Williamson J.Why SDRs Could Rival the Dollar?.Washington:Institute for International Economics,2009.