中国公共管理研究的国际化:基于2019年英文期刊论文的分析The Internationalization of Chinese Public Administration Research:An Analysis of 2019 English-Language Journals
史晓姣,马亮
摘要(Abstract):
国际化是中国公共管理研究发展的一个重要方面。本文梳理分析了中国大陆学者2019年发表于公共管理SSCI源期刊的中国主题论文,以评估其国际化现状。评估内容包括论文出处、作者特征、合作情况、署名顺序、研究主题、研究方法、具体分析方法、数据类型等方面。在评估的基础上,本文发现国际学术界的中国公共管理研究处于发展和进步中,学者们在努力讲好中国故事并发展一般性理论。中国学者未来仍需强化研究能力,植根于中国实践大地,发展具有中国特色的公共管理理论体系,让世界读懂中国。
关键词(KeyWords): 学科发展;中国学者;国际发表;公共管理;中国故事
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 史晓姣,马亮
参考文献(References):
- 陈那波.2015.公共行政学研究方法应用前沿及其中国借鉴[J].公共行政评论,8(4)69-77.Chen N B.2015.The research methods in public administration of English academic circles and the implication for China[J].Journal of Public Administration,8(4):69-77.(in Chinese)
- 杜运周,贾良定.2017.组态视角与定性比较分析(QCA):管理学研究的一条新道路[J].管理世界,(6):155-167.Du Y Z,Jia L D.2017.Configuration perspective and qualitative comparative analysis(QCA):A new road for management research[J].Management World,(6):155-167.(in Chinese)
- 何艳玲.2007.问题与方法:近十年来中国行政学研究评估(1995-2005)[J].政治学研究,(1):93-104.He Y L.2007.An Evaluation of the public administration study during the last 10 years[J].Cass Journal of Political Science,(1):93-104.(in Chinese)
- 李晓倩,马亮.2021.公共管理实验研究中的实验报告:现状与评价---以国际期刊论文为例[J].公共管理与政策评论,10(1):55-65.Li X Q,Ma L.2021.Analyzing and assessing the report of experiments in international experimental public administration research[J].Public Administration and Policy Review,10(1):55-65.(in Chinese)
- 刘润泽,巩宜萱.2020.回顾与反思:定量研究在公共管理学科的滥用[J].公共管理学报,17(1):152-158.Liu R Z,Gong Y X.2020.Review and reflection:The misuse of quantitative research in public administration[J].Journal of Public Management,17(1):152-158.(in Chinese)
- 吕芳,王梦凡,陈欢舸.2015.对21世纪以来中国公共行政学研究的评估与反思---基于2001~2013年间的4659篇论文[J].政治学研究,(2):92-103.Lv F,Wang M F,Chen H G.2015.Evaluation and reflection on the research of Chinese public administration since the 21st century-Based on 4659 papers from 2001 to 2013[J].Cass Journal of Political Science,(2):92-103.(in Chinese)
- 马骏.2012.中国公共行政学:回顾与展望[J].中国行政管理,(4):7-11.Ma J.2012.The review and prospect of Chinese public administration[J].Chinese Public Administration,(4):7-11.(in Chinese)
- 马亮.2017.实证公共管理研究日趋量化:因应与调适[J].学海,(5):194-201.Ma L.2017.Empirical public management research is increasingly quantified:Response and adaptation[J].Academia Bimestris,(5):194-201.(in Chinese)
- 杨开峰,邢小宇,刘卿斐,等.2021.我国治理研究的反思(2007-2018):概念、理论与方法[J].行政论坛,28(1):119-128.Yang K F,Xing X Y,Liu Q F,et al.2021.Reflection on governance research in China(2007-2018):Concept,theory and method[J].Administrative Tribune,28(1):119-128.(in Chinese)
- 杨立华,常多粉.2019.中国行政学三十年的范式变迁:从行政管理到公共治理[J].中国行政管理,(6):94-102.Yang L H,Chang D F.2019.Paradigm shifts of Chinese public administration in past thirty years (1986-2016):From traditional public administration to public governance[J].Chinese Public Administration,(6):94-102.(in Chinese)
- 杨立华.2019.中国公共管理学的危机与出路:恢复重建三十年后的反思[J].行政论坛,26(5):74-82.Yang L H.2019.Crises and countermeasures of Chinese public administration:Reflections after 30 Years of reconstruction[J].Administrative Tribune,26(5):74-82.(in Chinese)
- 叶林.2012.中国公共管理研究的国际化道路[J].复旦公共行政评论,(2):104-115.Ye L.2012.The globalization of China's public administration research[J].Fudan Public Administration Review,(2):104-115.(in Chinese)
- 于文轩,樊博.2020.公共管理学科的定量研究被滥用了吗?---与刘润泽、巩宜萱一文商榷[J].公共管理学报,17(1):159-166.Yu W X,Fan B.2020.Is quantitative research methods abused in public management research?[J].Journal of Public Management,17(1):159-166.(in Chinese)
- 张建民,江华.2009.国际学术界对中国公共管理的研究现状---论题、理论视角与方法[J].公共管理学报,6(2):1-13.Zhang J M,Jiang H.2009.The current state of international research on public administration in China-Topics,theoretical perspectives,and methods[J].Journal of Public Management,6(2):1-13.(in Chinese)
- Groeneveld S,Tummers L,Bronkhorst B,et al.2015.Quantitative methods in public administration:Their use and development through time[J].International Public Management Journal,18(1):61-86.
- Gulrajani N,Moloney K.2012.Globalizing public administration:Today's research and Tomorrow's agenda[J].Public Administration Review,72(1):78-86.
- Houston D J,Delevan S M.1990.Public administration research:An assessment of journal publications[J].Public Administration Review,50(6):674-681.
- Kim M H,Li H F,Holzer M,et al.2019.Public administration research in China's mainland:A systematic review of Chinese public administration in English language journals (1996-2016)[J].International Journal of Public Administration,42(9):753-764.
- Lan Z Y,Anders K K.2000.A paradigmatic view of contemporary public administration research:An empirical test[J].Administration&Society,32(2):138-165.
- Li Y W,Ma L.2019.What drives the governance of ride sharing?A fuzzy-set QCA of local regulations in China[J].Policy Sciences,52(4):601-624.
- Mele V,Belardinelli P.2019.Mixed methods in public administration research:Selecting,sequencing,and connecting[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,29(2):334-347.
- Ospina S M,Esteve M,Lee S.2018.Assessing qualitative studies in public administration research[J].Public Administration Review,78(4):593-605.
- Perry J L,Kraemer K L.1986.Research methodology in the“public administration review,”1975-1984[J].Public Administration Review,46(3):215-226.
- Pitts D W,Fernandez S.2009.The state of public management research:An analysis of scope and methodology[J].International Public Management Journal,12(4):399-420.
- Shen Y D,Yu J X,Li Y,et al.2019.Government funding and nonprofit revenues in China:Across-regional comparison[J].Public Performance&Management Review,42 (6):1372-1395.
- Stallings R A,Ferris J M.1988.Public administration research:Work in PAR,1940-1984[J].Public Administration Review,48(1):580-587.
- Stroik P,Chakraborty D,Ge W,et al.2019.Effect of reciprocity on public opinion of international climate treaties:experimental evidence from the US and China[J].Climate Policy,19(8):959-973.
- Walker R M,Brewer G A,Choi Y.2014.Public administration research in east and southeast Asia:A review of the English language evidence,1999-2009[J].The American Review of Public Administration,44(2):131-150.
- Wu X,He Y L,Sun M T W.2013.Public administration research in China's mainland and Taiwan:An assessment of journal publications,1998-2008[J].Public Administration,91(2):261-280.
- Zhang W,Xu X L,Evans R,et al.2018.Towards Internationalization:A critical assessment of China's public administration research in a global context 2000-2014[J].International Public Management Journal,21(1):74-104.
- Zhu J N,Huang H,Zhang D.2019.“Big Tigers,Big Data”:Learning social reactions to China's anticorruption campaign through online feedback[J].Public Administration Review,79(4):500-513.
- Zhu L,Witko C,Meier K J.2018.The public administration manifesto II:Matching methods to theory and substance[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,29 (2):287-298.