需求驱动、政府能力与移动政务合作提供:中国地级市的实证研究Demand-Driven Government Capabilities and Cooperation with “Urban Mobile Governments”:An Empirical Study of Chinese Prefectural-level Cities
马亮
摘要(Abstract)：
移动政务是电子政务领域的一种创新服务模式,特别是政府部门与企业第三方平台合作提供移动政务,是"互联网+政务服务"的重要方式之一。但是,对移动政务的驱动因素进行实证研究的文献还不多见。基于政府创新扩散与跨部门合作等领域的理论,使用支付宝"城市服务"的多源数据,本文对中国城市移动政务合作提供情况及其影响因素进行了实证分析。对地级市截面数据的定量分析显示,用户需求、政府动机与能力、府际关系是影响移动政务合作提供的主要因素。具体来说,用户规模较大、政府创新程度较高、行政级别较高和府际竞争程度较激烈的城市,移动政务的合作提供水平更高。这些研究发现解释了为什么城市之间移动政务发展的差距较大,并为推进和深化"互联网+政务服务"提供了经验依据。
关键词(KeyWords)： 智慧城市;政府与社会资本合作;大数据;地方政府;创新扩散
基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金项目“第三方评估如何提升组织绩效:中国地方政府的实证研究”(批准号:71774164)
作者(Author): 马亮
参考文献(References)：
- (1)OECD/ITU.,M-government:Mobile Technologies for Responsive Governments and Connected Societies,Paris:OECD Publishing/International Telecommunication Union,2011.
- (1)郑跃平、黄博涵:《“互联网+政务”报告(2016)——移动政务的现状与未来》,《电子政务》2016年第9期。
- (2)互联网实验室:《2017互联网+城市服务报告》,中国电子商务研究中心,http://b2b.toocle.com/detail-6388578.html,最后访问日期:2018年3月20日。
- (3)陈则谦:《中国移动政务APP客户端的典型问题分析》,《电子政务》2015年第3期;李重照、刘新萍:《中国省级移动政务平台建设现状研究:从WAP到APP》,《电子政务》2014年第11期。
- (4)王芳、王俊平:《移动政务利益相关者研究》,《电子政务》2012年第8期。
- (5)刘淑华、詹华、袁千里等:《移动政务与中国城市治理》,《电子政务》2011年第6期。
- (6)Liu Y.,Li H.,Kostakos V.,et al.,“An Empirical Investigation of Mobile Government Adoption in Rural China:A Case Study in Zhejiang Province,”Government Information Quarterly,2014(3),pp.432-442;Chen Z-J,Vogel D.,Wang Z-H.,"How to Satisfy Citizens?Using Mobile Government to Reengineer Fair Government Processes,"Decision Support Systems,2016(82),pp.47-57;Reddick C.G.,“Citizens and Mobile Government Adoption:A Comparison of Activities and Uses,"International Journal of Civic Engagement and Social Change(IJCESC),2014(1),pp.13-26.
- (1)陈则谦、刘坤:《地方政府政务APP的可用性调查与分析——以河北省为例》,《电子政务》2017年第3期。
- (2)于文轩、许成委:《中国智慧城市建设的技术理性与政治理性——基于147个城市的实证分析》,《公共管理学报》2016年第4期。
- (3)OECD/ITU.,M-government:Mobile Technologies for Responsive Governments and Connected Societies,Paris:OECD Publishing/International Telecommunication Union,2011.
- (4)Chen Z-J,Vogel D.,Wang Z-H.,“How to Satisfy Citizens?Using Mobile Government to Reengineer Fair Government Processes,”Decision Support Systems,2016(82),pp.47-57.
- (5)Liu Y.,Li H.,Kostakos V.,et al.,"An Empirical Investigation of Mobile Government Adoption in Rural China:A Case Study in Zhejiang Province,"Government Information Quarterly,2014(3),pp.432-442.
- (6)刘淑华、詹华、袁千里等:《移动政务与中国城市治理》,《电子政务》2011年第6期。
- (1)UN.,United Nations E-Government Survey 2016:E-Government in Support of Sustainable Development,New York:United Nations,2016.
- (2)陈则谦:《中国移动政务APP客户端的典型问题分析》,《电子政务》2015年第3期;李重照、刘新萍:《中国省级移动政务平台建设现状研究:从WAP到APP》,《电子政务》2014年第11期;陈则谦、刘坤:《地方政府政务APP的可用性调查与分析——以河北省为例》,《电子政务》2017年第3期。
- (3)UN.,United Nations E-Government Survey 2016:E-Government in Support of Sustainable Development,New York:United Nations,2016.
- (4)腾讯研究院:《中国“互联网+”指数(2016)》,2016。
- (1)《支付宝发布2015“互联网+”城市服务报告》,人民网,http://it people.com.cn/n1/2016/0115/c1009-28055862.html,最后访问日期:2018年3月5日。
- (2)蚂蚁金服集团研究院:《互联网+百人会·新空间·新生活·新治理——中国新型智慧城市·蚂蚁模式白皮书(2016)》,阿里研究院,2016。
- (3)郑跃平、黄博涵:《“互联网+政务”报告(2016)——移动政务的现状与未来》,《电子政务》2016年第9期。
- (4)Meijer A.,Bolivar M.P.R.,"Governing the Amart City:a Review of the Literature on Smart Urban Governance,"International Review of Administrative Sciences,2016(2),pp.392-408.
- (5)Mergel I.,Rethemeyer R.K.,Isett K.,“Big Data in Public Affairs,"Public Adminitration Review,2016(6),pp.928-937.
- (1)Walker R.M.,"Internal and External Antecedents of Process Innovation:A Review and Extension,"Public Management Review,2014(1),pp.21-44.
- (2)Frambach R.T.,Schillewaert N.,"Organizational Innovation Adoption:A Multi-Level Framework of Determinants and Opportunities for Future Research,"Journal of Business Research,2002(2),pp.163-176.
- (3)Fichman R.G.,Kemerer C.F.,“The Illusory Diffusion of Innovation:An Examination of Assimilation Gaps,”Information Systems Research,1999(3),pp.255-275.
- (4)Walker R.M.,"Internal and External Antecedents of Process Innovation:A Review and Extension,"Public Management Review.2014(1),pp.21-44.
- (1)Mohr L.B.,"Determinants of Innovation in Organizations,"American Political Science Review,1969(1),pp.111-126.
- (2)Berry F.S.,Berry W.D.,“Innovations and Diffusion Models in Policy Research,"in Theories of the Policy Process Sabatier,edited by P.A.,Weible C.,Boulder,CO:Westview Press,2014,pp.307-360.
- (3)Jing Y.,"Outsourcing in China:An Exploratory Assessment,"Public Administration and Development,2008(2),pp.119-128.
- (4)Hefetz A.,Warner M.,Vigoda-Gadot E.,"Concurrent Sourcing in the Public Sector:A Strategy to Manage Contracting Risk,"International Public Management Journal,2014(3),pp.365-386.
- (5)Milward H.B.,Provan K.G.,“Governing the Hollow State,"Public Adm Res Theory,2000(2),pp.359-380.
- (6)Chen C-A.,"Antecedents of Contracting-Back-In:A View beyond the Economic Paradigm,"Administration&Society,2009(1),pp.101-126.
- (7)Hefetz A.,Warner M.,Vigoda-Gadot E.,"Concurrent Sourcing in the Public Sector:A Strategy to Manage Contracting Risk."International Public Management Journal,2014(3),pp.365-386.
- (1)感谢匿名审稿人指出这一点。
- (2)Zhang N.,Zhao X.,Zhang Z.,et al.,“What Factors Drive Open Innovation in China's Public Sector?A Case Study of Official Document Exchange via Microblogging(ODEM)in Haining,Government Information Quarterly,2017(1),pp.126-133.
- (1)Moon M.J.,Norris D.F.,“Does Managerial Orientation Matter?The Adoption of Reinventing Government and E-Government at the Municipal Level,"Information Systems Journal,2005(1),pp.43-60.
- (2)Gonzalez R.,Llopis J.,Casco J.,"Innovation in Public Services:The Case of Spanish Local Government,"Journal of Business Research,2013(10),pp.2024-2033.
- (3)Liu Y.,Li H.,Kostakos V.,et al.,"An Empirical Investigation of Mobile Government Adoption in Rural China:A Case Study in Zhejiang Province,"Government Information Quarterly,2014(3),pp.432-442.
- (4)Reddick C.G.,"Citizens and Mobile Government Adoption:A Comparison of Activities and Uses,"International Journal of Civic Engagement and Social Change(IJCESC),2014(1),pp.13-26.
- (1)Lee M-H,Lio M-C.,"The Impact of Information and Communication Technology on Public Governance and Corruption in China,"Information Development,2016(2),pp.127-141.
- (2)Su Z.,Meng T.,“Selective Responsiveness:Online Public Demands and Government Responsiveness in Authoritarian China,"Social Science Research,2016(1),pp.52-67.
- (3)Mohr L.B.,"Determinants of Innovation in Organizations,"American Political Science Review,1969(1),pp.111-126.
- (4)Moon M.J.,Norris D.F.,"Does Managerial Orientation Matter?The Adoption of Reinventing Government and E-Government at the Municipal Level,"Information Systems Journal,2005(1),pp.43-60.
- (5)Boehmke F.J.,Skinner P.,“State Policy Innovativeness Revisited,"State Politics&Policy Quarterly,2012(3),pp.303-329.
- (1)Berry F.S.,“Innovation in Public Management:The Adoption of Strategic Planning,"Public Administration Review,1994(4),pp.322-330.
- (2)Nohria N.,Gulati R.,“Is Slack Good or Bad for Innovation?”Academy of Management Journal,1996(5),pp.1245-1264.
- (3)Grimmelikhuijsen S.G.,Feeney M.K.,"Developing and Testing an Integrative Framework for Open Government Adoption in Local Governments,"Public Administration Review,2017(77).
- (4)樊博、陈璐:《政府部门的大数据能力研究——基于组织层面的视角》,《公共行政评论》2017年第1期。
- (5)Janssen M.,Charalabidis Y.,Zuiderwijk A.,“Benefits,Adoption Barriers and Myths of Open Data and Open Government,"Information Systems Management,2012(4),pp.258-268.
- (1)Chien S-S.,"Prefecture and Prefecture-level Cities-Political Economy of Administrative Restructuring,"in China's Local Administration:Traditions and Changes in the Sub-National Hierarchy,edited by Chung J.H.,Lam T-C,London:Routledge,2010,pp.127-148.
- (2)Li H.,Wang Q.,Zheng C.,"Interjurisdictional Competition and Intracity Fiscal Disparity across Chinese Prefectural Cities,"Governance,2017(3),pp.365-385.
- (3)Chien S-S.,"The Isomorphism of Local Development Policy:A Case Study of the Formation and Transformation of National Development Zones in Post-Mao Jiangsu,China,"Urban Studies,2008(2),pp.273-294.
- (4)Cai H.,Treisman D.,"Political Decentralization and Policy Experimentation,"Quarterly Journal of Political Science,2009(1),pp.35-58.
- (5)Zhu X.,Zhang Y.,“Political Mobility and Dynamic Diffusion of Innovation:The Spread of Municipal ProBusiness Administrative Reform in China,"Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,2016(3).
- (1)《晒一晒你的城市“触网”有多深》,新华网,http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/20171h/2017-03/05/c_1120571255.htm,最后访问日期:2018年3月25日。
- (1)腾讯研究院:《中国“互联网+”指数(2016)》,2016。
- (2)Chen Q.,Song Z.,“Accounting for China's Urbanization,”China Economic Review,2014(30),pp.485-494.
- (1)张光、江依妮:《为什么财政教育投入达不到占GDP百分之四的目标:一个基于跨省多年度数据分析的实证研究》,《公共行政评论》2010年第4期。
- (2)Walker R.M.,Jeanes E.,Rowlands R.,“Measuring Innovation-Applying the Literature-Based Innovation Output Indicator to Public Services,”Public Administration,2002(1),pp.201-214.
- (3)中国软件评测中心:《2016年中国政府网站绩效评估总报告》,2017。
- (4)Berry F.S.,"Innovation in Public Management:The Adoption of Strategic Planning."Public Administration Review,1994(4),pp.322-330.
- (5)中国软件评测中心:《2016年中国政府网站绩效评估总报告》,2017。
- (6)Li H.,Wang Q.,Zheng C.,"Interjurisdictional Competition and Intracity Fiscal Disparity across Chinese Prefectural Cities,"Governance,2017(3),pp.365-385.
- (1)《对于微博、蚂蚁金服和阿里巴巴,“城市服务”可能是一个好机会》,钛媒体,http://www.tmtpost.com/227301.html,最后访问日期:2018年3月20日。
- (2)Kraemer K.L.,Perry J.L.,“The Federal Push to Bring Computer Applications to Local Governments,"Public Administration Review,1979(3),pp.260-270.
- (1)Zhang N.,Zhao X.,Zhang Z.,et al.,"What Factors Drive Open Innovation in China's Public Sector?A Case Study of Official Document Exchange via Microblogging(ODEM)in Haining,"Government Information Quarterly,2017(1),pp.126-133.
- (2)Fan B.,"Achieving Horizontal Integration of Municipal E-government in China:Assessment of Managerial Mechanisms,"Information Development,2013(4),pp.333-348.