知识就是力量：组织学习何以推动公共政策的有效执行?Knowledge as Power: The Role of Organizational Learning in Driving Effective Public Policy Implementation
杨泽斌,张振洋
摘要(Abstract)：
政策制定过程需要组织学习已成为一种共识，但在政策执行中是否也需要进行组织学习?其何以推动政策有效实施?为此，本研究搭建“组织学习-知识生产”的理论框架，对政策执行中地方政府开展组织学习的过程及影响效应展开分析。本文以J市B项目国有土地上房屋征收为观察案例，发现决策者的权威倡导与政策参与者的多元互动，助推了组织学习的启动，助力公共组织汲取了大量外部隐性知识。其后，借助助推、调适与转换等组织学习机制，公共组织实现了不同类型知识的整合与积淀，在提升执行主体认知水平与执行能力的同时推动政策顺利落地。本研究有助于深化学界对公共政策过程中组织学习的讨论，未来研究可进一步关注组织学习模式的类型学划分。
关键词(KeyWords)： 政策执行;组织学习;知识生产;政策知识
基金项目(Foundation): 国家社会科学基金青年项目“特大城市社区综合服务平台化供给能力提升研究”(项目批准号:21CZZ024)的资助
作者(Author): 杨泽斌,张振洋
参考文献(References)：
- 陈国权.2001.组织与环境的关系及组织学习[J].管理科学学报,4(5):39-49.Chen G Q.2001.Relationship between organization and its environment and organizational learning[J].Journal of Management Sciences in China,4(5):39-49.(in Chinese) 韩志明.2018.从官僚知识到个人知识---国家治理转向的知识逻辑[J].中国行政管理,(6):88-93.Han Z M.2018.From bureaucratic knowledge to personal knowledge:The knowledge logic of state governance turn[J].Chinese Public Administration,(6):88-93.(in Chinese) 黄璜.2018.数字政府的概念结构:信息能力、数据流动与知识应用---兼论DIKW模型与IDK原则[J].学海,(4):158-167.Huang H.2018.The conceptual structure of digital government:Information capability,data flow and knowledge application-On the DIKW model and IDK principle[J].Academia Bimestris,(4):158-167.(in Chinese) 黄六招.2021.组织学习与双向赋能:推进社区治理现代化的有效路径---基于一个易地搬迁社区的案例研究[J].探索,(6):103-114.Huang L Z.2021.Organizational learning and bidirectional empowerment:A path to promote the modernization of community governance-Case study on a demonstration site of relocation community[J].Probe,(6):103-114.(in Chinese) 克利福德·吉尔兹.2004.地方性知识:阐释人类学论文集[M].王海龙,张家瑄,译.2版.北京:中央编译出版社:227.Geertz C.2004.Local knowledge:Further essays in interpretive anthropology[M].Wang H L,Zhang J X,trans.2nd ed.Beijing:Central Compilation&Translation Press:227.(trans.into Chinese) 李娉,杨宏山.2022a.科学检验与多元协商:政策试验中的知识生产路径---基于Y市垃圾分类四项试点的比较分析[J].公共管理学报,19(3):71-83.Li P,Yang H S.2022a.Scientific testing and pluralistic negotiation:Knowledge production paths in the policy experimentation-An empirical analysis on the garbage classification pilot projects in Y City[J].Journal of Public Management,19(3):71-83.(in Chinese) 李娉,杨宏山.2022b.危机演化与应急学习:城市风险管理的运作逻辑[J].城市发展研究,29(7):74-80.Li P,Yang H S.2022b.Crisis evolution and emergency learning:Framework and logic of urban risk management[J].Urban Development Studies,29(7):74-80.(in Chinese) 李瑞昌,唐雲.2024.纵向干预下政府公共安全学习论[J].复旦学报(社会科学版),66(1):182-191.Li R C,Tang Y.2024.The“well loop”learning theory of government public safety under hierarchical intervention[J].Fudan Journal (Social Sciences),66(1):182-191.(in Chinese) 林雪霏.2015.政府间组织学习与政策再生产:政策扩散的微观机制---以“城市网格化管理”政策为例[J].公共管理学报,12(1):11-23,153-154.Lin X F.2015.Organizational learning among governments and the policy reproduction:The microscopic mechanisms of policy diffusion-A case study on the policy of“city grid management”[J].Journal of Public Management,12 (1):11-23,153-154.(in Chinese) 满小欧,薛增鑫,甘甜.2025.因何而异:层级治理体系下政策再生产的策略逻辑---基于G省数字政府建设的纵向多案例研究[J].公共管理学报,22(2):75-87,171-172.Man X O,Xue Z X,Gan T.2025.How it varies:Strategic types and logics of policy reproduction within a hierarchical governance system-A longitudinal multi-case study based on digital government construction in G Province[J].Journal of Public Management,22(2):75-87,171-172.(in Chinese) 庞明礼,马璇.2024.会议中的知识共享:协同治理研究的新视角[J].中国行政管理,40(11):49-57.Pang M L,Ma X.2024.Knowledge sharing in meetings:A new perspective on collaborative governance research[J].Chinese Public Administration,40(11):49-57.(in Chinese) 钱蕾,何艳玲.2024.从经验惯习到规章制度:组织隐性知识如何显性化?[J].中国行政管理,40(5):98-108.Qian L,He Y L.2024.From experience and habit to regulation:How to make organizational tacit knowledge explicit?[J].Chinese Public Administration,40(5):98-108.(in Chinese) 田凯.2020.组织理论:公共的视角[M].北京:北京大学出版社:183-217.Tian K.2020.Organization theory:A public perspective[M].Beijing:Peking University Press:183-217.(in Chinese) 王礼鑫.2018.公共政策的知识基础与决策权配置[J].中国行政管理,(4):98-104.Wang L X.2018.The knowledge foundations of public policy and the arrangements of decision-making power[J].Chinese Public Administration,(4):98-104.(in Chinese) 王礼鑫,莫勇波.2017.基于知识视角的政策制定基本问题探析[J].中国行政管理,(6):90-96.Wang L X,Mo Y B.2017.The fundamental questions of policy-making based on perspective of knowledge[J].Chinese Public Administration,(6):90-96.(in Chinese) 王锡锌,章永乐.2003.专家、大众与知识的运用---行政规则制定过程的一个分析框架[J].中国社会科学,(3):113-127,207-208.Wang X X,Zhang Y L.2003.Experts,the public and use of knowledge:An analytical framework for administrative rule making[J].Social Sciences in China,(3):113-127,207-208.(in Chinese) 魏淑艳,郑美玲.2022.政策转移推动政策创新生成机理探究---基于福建省排污权交易政策转移个案的分析[J].中南大学学报(社会科学版),28(3):165-176.Wei S Y,Zheng M L.2022.Exploration into the mechanism of policy innovation driven by policy transfer:An analysis based on the case of the transfer of emission trading policy in Fujian Province[J].Journal of Central South University (Social Sciences),28(3):165-176.(in Chinese) 文宏,李风山.2022.中国地方政府危机学习模式及其逻辑---基于“央地关系议题属性”框架的多案例研究[J].吉林大学社会科学学报,62(4):81-92,235.Wen H,Li F S.2022.Different models of learning from crises and their logic:A multicas case study based on the“central-local relations and issue attribution”framework[J].Jilin University Journal Social Sciences Edition,62(4):81-92,235.(in Chinese) 向玉琼.2012.中国转型期地方政府政策移植研究[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社.Xiang Y Q.2012.Policy transplantation in local governments during China's transition period[M].Beijing:China Social Sciences Press.(in Chinese) 向玉琼,冯钰婷.2023.双层学习交互:地方数字政务服务创新过程与生成机理---基于N市经验的分析[J].城市问题,(10):14-23.Xiang Y Q,Feng Y T.2023.Dual-layer learning interaction,local digital government service innovation process and generation mechanism:Analysis based on the experience of N city[J].Urban Problems,(10):14-23.(in Chinese) 阎波,吴建南.2018.非正式问责、组织学习与政策执行:J市政府职能转变综合改革的案例研究[J].中国行政管理,(2):27-34.Yan B,Wu J N.2018.Informal accountability,organizational learning and policy implementation:A case study of municipal government comprehensive reform in city J[J].Chinese Public Administration,(2):27-34.(in Chinese) 杨宏山.2016.情境与模式:中国政策执行的行动逻辑[J].学海,(3):12-17.Yang H S.2016.Context and mode:The action logic of policy implementation in China[J].Academia Bimestris,(3):12-17.(in Chinese) 杨宏山,李娉.2019.政策创新争先模式的府际学习机制[J].公共管理学报,16(2):1-14,168.Yang H S,Li P.2019.Inter-governmental learning mechanism for the championship model of policy innovation[J].Journal of Public Management,16(2):1-14,168.(in Chinese) 杨宏山,李悟.2023.政策试验中的组织学习:一个过程框架[J].学海,(5):25-32,50.Yang H S,Li W.2023.Organizational learning in policy experiments:A process framework[J].Academia Bimestris,(5):25-32,50.(in Chinese) 杨淑琼,沈治宏.2006.政府知识管理探微[J].现代情报,26(7):44-46,49.Yang S Q,Shen Z H.2006.A brief exploration of government knowledge management[J].Journal of Modern Information,26(7):44-46,49.(in Chinese) 杨志,魏姝.2020.政府考察学习如何影响政策扩散?---以县级融媒体中心政策为例[J].公共行政评论,13(5):160-180,209-210.Yang Z,Wei S.2020.How does horizontal onsite learning affect policy diffusion?-Acase study of county-level converged media center policy[J].Journal of Public Administration,13(5):160-180,209-210.(in Chinese) 杨智,刘新燕,万后芬.2004.国外组织学习研究综述[J].外国经济与管理,26(12):15-20.Yang Z,Liu X Y,Wan H F.2004.A review of foreign organizational learning research[J].Foreign Economics&Management,26(12):15-20.(in Chinese) 余光胜,刘卫,唐郁.2006.知识属性、情境依赖与默会知识共享条件研究[J].研究与发展管理,18(6):23-29.Yu G S,Liu W,Tang Y.2006.Research on the knowledge attributes,context-dependency and the conditions for sharing tacit knowledge[J].R&D Management,18(6):23-29.(in Chinese) 赵远跃.2024.政策试验中的议题学习机制---以X市“多规合一”改革为例[J].公共管理学报,21(2):40-52,171-172.Zhao Y Y.2024.Topic learning mechanism in policy experimentation:A case study of the“multi-plan integration”reform in X City[J].Journal of Public Management,21(2):40-52,171-172.(in Chinese) Michaels S,Goucher N P,McCarthy D.2006.Policy windows,policy change,and organizational learning:Watersheds in the evolution of watershed management[J].Environmental Management,38(6):983-992. Nonaka I.1994.A dynamic theory of organizational knowledge creation[J].Organization Science,5(1):14-37. Ricco G,Schultz C A.2019.Organizational learning during policy implementation:Lessons from U.S.forest planning[J].Journal of Environmental Policy&Planning,21(3):275-287. Schofield J.2001.Time for a revival?Public policy implementation:A review of the literature and an agenda for future research[J].International Journal of Management Reviews,3(3):245-263. Szulanski G.2000.The process of knowledge transfer:A diachronic analysis of stickiness[J].Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,82(1):9-27. Teece D J.2000.Strategies for managing knowledge assets:The role of firm structure and industrial context[J].Long Range Planning,33(1):35-54. Yin R K.2009.Case study research:Design and methods[M].4th ed.Los Angeles:Sage Publications:19-51. Zhu X F.2013.Policy change and expert involvement in China[J].Public Administration,91(2):281-302.
- (1)SECI模型认为:显性知识主要通过正式或系统的语言表达,可依靠文本化方式存储和传输;隐性知识主要以根植于理念、价值观等可在观察或交流中加以概括的高度个性化知识为主。 (2)本文沿用SECI模型中四种知识转化方式的命名,因为从知识属性看,它们都属于知识显性、隐性间的互动转化。 (3)本文访谈资料的编码规则为“人名拼音缩写-年月日”。按照学术惯例,本文涉及的人名、地名均采用化名处理。 (4)据田野调查收集的资料,专题培训的内容主要包括:一是为测绘人员现场讲解房屋征收工作线上操作平台的基本框架与功能,并演示其具体使用的流程方法;二是结合具体案例,为业务骨干讲解地上物的拆迁补偿等政策要求,并在现场展开讨论。