段哲哲

• 1:深圳大学政府管理学院、廉政研究院、全球特大型城市治理研究院
• 2:广东省习近平新时代中国特色社会主义思想研究中心深圳大学基地
• 3:深圳市社会科学院现代化与全球城市研究中心

摘要(Abstract)：

长期以来，公众的政府观论争常常关注“大政府”与“小政府”之优劣对比，即聚焦于政府规模这一维度。改革开放后，我国一方面着力于简政放权，另一方面政府又主导和引领改革进程，两种取向并存的现状促使笔者关注中国民众政府观的演进和发展。立足于改革开放以来中国民众政府观变迁的时代背景，本研究利用“世界价值观调查—中国卷”(1990—2018)的数据逐步检视民众政府观的年龄-时期-世代效应，检验了文化因素对政府观的影响。实证结果表明，中国民众政府观存在年龄-时期-世代效应，改革开放40年后现代性价值观对中国社会影响有限，“无声革命”在中国没有发生，历史悠久且具有独特性的中华传统文化持续影响着民众政府观。

关键词(KeyWords)： 政府观;传统性;现代性;年龄-时期-世代;中国式现代化

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 2021年国家社会科学基金青年项目“少数基层干部‘空忙’现象及矫治机制研究”(项目批准号：21CZZ036)的资助

作者(Author): 段哲哲

参考文献(References)：

• 蔡长昆.2015.从“大政府”到“精明政府”:中国政府职能转变的逻辑——交易成本政治学的视角[J].公共行政评论，8(2):99-124.Cai C K.2015.From “Huge Government” to “Smart Government”:The logic of China's government function transformation from the perspective of transaction cost politics[J].Journal of Public Administration,8(2):99-124.(in Chinese)
• 陈立明，刘炳辉.2019.复兴一代：“95后”大学生的时代特性剖析[J].华东理工大学学报(社会科学版),34(4):107-116.Chen L M,Liu B H.2019.Revival generation:An analysis of the characteristics of the post-95 college students[J].Journal of East China University of Science and Technology (Social Science Edition),34(4):107-116.(in Chinese)
• 陈远星，陈明明.2021.有限政府与有效政府：权力、责任与逻辑[J].学海，(5):98-111.Chen Y X,Chen M M.2021.Limited government and effective government:Power,responsibility,and logic[J].Academia Bimestris,(5):98-111.(in Chinese)
• 陈咏媛，韦庆旺.2020.流动性社会下文化自信的心理建设进路[J].广西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),56(4):117-132.Chen Y Y,Wei Q W.2020.The psychological construction approach to cultural confidence in a mobile society[J].Journal of Guangxi Normal University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition),56(4):117-132.(in Chinese)
• 范晓慧.2023.中国式现代化的制度优势及其文明史意义[J].湖湘论坛，36(6):88-100.Fang X H.2023.The institutional advantages of Chinese modernization and its significance in the history of civilization[J].Huxiang Forum,36(6):88-100.(in Chinese)
• 房宁，丰俊功.2021.小康之后：后现代价值观的浮现与挑战[J].文化纵横，(3):130-137.Fang N,Feng J G.2021.Living beyond Xiao-Kang:The emergence of post-modern value and the challenges it brings[J].Beijing Cultural Review,(3):130-137.(in Chinese)
• 冯小红.2019.全面抗战初期“财政无政府”状态下的赋税征收和农民负担——以1938年涉县甘泉村为中心的考察[J].近代史研究，(3):116-133.Feng X H.2019.Tax collection and peasants' burden in the “financial anarchy” in the early stage of the total war of resistance against the Japanese aggression:A case study based on the Ganquan village of the Shexian county in 1938[J].Modern Chinese History Studies,(3):116-133.(in Chinese)
• 付茜茜.2023.新国潮：消费语境下中华传统文化的潮流形态[J].学习与实践，(5):121-131.Fu Q Q.2023.New China-Chic:The trend pattern of Chinese traditional culture in the context of consumption[J].Study and Practice,(5):121-131.(in Chinese)
• 高海燕，王鹏，谭康荣.2022.中国民众社会价值观的变迁及其影响因素——基于年龄-时期-世代效应的分析[J].社会学研究，37(1):156-178.Gao H H,Wang P,Tan K R.2022.Chinese social value change and its relevant factors:An age-period-cohort effect analysis[J].Sociological Studies,37(1):156-178.(in Chinese)
• 高旭繁，陆洛.2006.夫妻传统性/现代性的契合与婚姻适应之关联[J].本土心理学研究，(25):47-100.Gao F X,Lu L.2006.The Relationship of congruence in psychological traditionality/modernity to marital adjustment[J].Indigenous Psychological Research in Chinese Societies,(25):47-100.(in Chinese)
• 李水金，李龙.2019.美国公共行政的三大传统：模式、内涵及逻辑演进[J].甘肃行政学院学报，(3):69-78.Li S J,Li L.2019.Traditions of American public administration:Model,connotation and evolution logic[J].Journal of Gansu Administration Institute,(3):69-78.(in Chinese)
• 卢燕娟.2018.和解、反思、征用与新的可能性——再论“唱红歌”及其引发的争论[J].文艺理论与批评，(5):92-101.Lu Y J.2018.Reconciliation,reflection,requisition and new possibilities:A reanalysis of “singing Red Songs” and the controversy it triggered[J].Theory and Criticism of Literature and Art,(5):92-101.(in Chinese)
• 唐亚林.2022.人民本位观：基于经典现代化理论反思的多维度考察及其构建路径[J].行政论坛，29(4):5-13.Tang Y L.2022.People-oriented view:Multi-dimensional investigation and its construction path based on the reflection of classical modernization theory[J].Administrative Tribune,29(4):5-13.(in Chinese)
• 王继平，张晶宇.2018.论国民政府时期湖南的乡村社会治理[J].湖南科技大学学报(社会科学版),21(2):122-131.Zhang J P,Zhang J Y.2018.On rural social governance in Hunan province during the period of the national government[J].Journal of Hunan University of Science and Technology (Social Science Edition),21(2):122-131.(in Chinese)
• 王若磊.2023.党和国家机构改革的政法逻辑[J].浙江工商大学学报，(3):5-14.Wang R L.2023.Political and legal logic of the reform of party and state institutions[J].Journal of Zhejiang Gongshang University,(3):5-14.(in Chinese)
• 王小良，孙婷婷.2022.儒家政治思想与美国民主制度的形成[J].国际汉学，31(2):5-18.Wang D,Sun T T.2022.Confucian political idea in the making of American democracy[J].International Sinology,31(2):5-18.(in Chinese)
• 肖唐镖，刘元贺.2021.民众政府观的概念建构及其测量[J].治理研究，37(5):14-28.Xiao T B,Liu Y H.2021.The citizens’ view of government in China:Conceptual and measuement[J].Governance Studies,37(5):14-28.(in Chinese)
• 新华社.(2009-08-24)[2024-08-10].共和国的足迹——1966年：“文化大革命”十年内乱开始[EB/OL].https://www.gov.cn/zhuanti/2009-08/24/content_2754101.htm.Xinhua News Agency.(2009-08-24)[2024-08-10].Footprints of the People's Republic of China—1966:The “Cultural Revolution” decade of civil unrest begins[EB/OL].https://www.gov.cn/zhuanti/2009-08/24/content_2754101.htm.(in Chinese)
• 姚广利.2014.改革中政府与市场的角色定位—基于政府与市场关系演变的研究[J].人民论坛，(20):87-89.Yao G L.2014.The role positioning of government and market in reform:Based on the study of the evolution of the relationship between government and market[J].People's Tribune,(20):87-89.(in Chinese)
• 臧雷振，黄建军.2013.大政府还是小政府：灵巧型政府建构进路[J].中国行政管理，(7):18-21.Zang Z L,Huang J J.2013.Smaller government or bigger government:Study on smarter government[J].Chinese Public Administration,(7):18-21.(in Chinese)
• 赵晓歌.2017.我国80后、90后青年福利意识形态比较研究——基于CSS2013数据的对比分析[J].中国青年研究，(10):86-91.Zhao X G.2017.A comparative study of the welfare ideology between the post-80s generation and the post-90s youth in China[J].China Youth Study,(10):86-91.(in Chinese)
• 张群梅.2017.街道民主改革运动与城市基层社会治理——以新中国初期的开封为个案[J].史学月刊，(4):64-73.Zhang X M.2017.Democracy reform movement of street and social governance of city grassroots:Focusing on Kaifeng at the beginning PRC[J].Journal of Historical Science,(4):64-73.(in Chinese)
• 朱富强.2017.如何保障政府的积极“有为”?——兼评林毅夫“有为政府论”的社会基础[J].财经研究，43(3):4-16.Zhu F Q.2017.How to ensure governments to take on their responsibility positively?A comment on the social foundation of Lin Yifu’s active government[J].Journal of Finance and Economics,43(3):4-16.(in Chinese)
• 朱光磊.2022.现代新儒家的阳明学研究[J].江苏师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),48(1):102-114.Zhu G L.2022.Research on Yangming school of modern neo-confucianism[J].Journal of Jiangsu Normal University (Philosophy and social Sciences Edition),48(1):102-114.(in Chinese)
• Abramson P R,Inglehart R.1994.Education,security,and postmaterialism:A comment on Duch and Taylor's “Postmaterialism and the Economic Condition”[J].American Journal of Political Science,38(3):797-814.
• Bean C,Papadakis E.1998.A comparison of mass attitudes towards the welfare state in different institutional regimes,1985—1990[J].International Journal of Public Opinion Research,10(3):211-236.
• Béland D,de Chantal F V.2004.Fighting “big government”:Frames,federalism,and social policy reform in the United States[J].Canadian Journal of Sociology/Cahiers Canadiens de Sociologie,29(2):241-264.
• Bergh A.2020.Hayekian welfare states:Explaining the coexistence of economic freedom and big government[J].Journal of Institutional Economics,16(1):1-12.
• Breznau N.2019.The underlying public attitude toward government responsibility to intervene in socioeconomics,30 years of evidence from the ISSP[J].International Journal of Sociology,49(3):182-203.
• Brooks A C.2003.Public opinion and the role of government arts funding in Spain[J].Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis,5(1):29-38.
• Brym R.2016.Ronald Inglehart’s comment on “After Postmaterialism”:A reply[J].Canadian Journal of Sociology,41(2):223-228.
• Chen J,Huhe N,Yan T.2022.Is a “silent revolution” in the making in China?Postmaterialist values,and political attitudes and behavior[J].Asian Survey,62(2):302-329.
• Christensen T,Lisheng D,Painter M.2008.Administrative reform in China's central government—How much learning from the West' [J].International Review of Administrative Sciences,74(3):351-371.
• Dalton R J,Ong N N T.2005.Authority orientations and democratic attitudes:A test of the ‘Asian values’ hypothesis[J].Japanese Journal of Political Science,6(2):211-231.
• Dobewall H,Strack M.2014.Relationship of Inglehart's and Schwartz's value dimensions revisited[J].International Journal of Psychology,49(4):240-248.
• Elder G H Jr.1994.Time,human agency,and social change:Perspectives on the life course[J].Social Psychology Quarterly,57(1):4-15.
• Fosse E,Winship C.2019.Analyzing age-period-cohort data:A review and critique[J].Annual Review of Sociology,45(1):467-492.
• Frederickson H G.2002.Confucius and the moral basis of bureaucracy[J].Administration & Society,33(6):610-628.
• Graaf N D D,Evans G.1996.Why are the young more postmaterialist?A cross-national analysis of individual and contextual influences on postmaterial values[J].Comparative Political Studies,28(4):608-635.
• Helbling M,Teney C.2015.The cosmopolitan elite in Germany:Transnationalism and postmaterialism[J].Global Networks,15(4):446-468.
• Im T,Campbell J W,Cha S.2013.Revisiting Confucian bureaucracy:Roots of the Korean government's culture and competitiveness[J].Public Administration and Development,33(4):286-296.
• Inglehart R.1971.The silent revolution in Europe:Intergenerational change in post-industrial societies[J].American Political Science Review,65(4):991-1017.
• Inglehart R.2000.Globalization and postmodern values[J].The Washington Quarterly,23(1):215-228.
• Inglehart R,Abramson P R.1999.Measuring postmaterialism[J].American Political Science Review,93(3):665-677.
• Inglehart R,Baker W E.2000.Modernization,cultural change,and the persistence of traditional values[J].American Sociological Review,65(1):19-51.
• Jin S,Zhou Y J.2021.An authoritarian undercurrent in the postmaterialist tide:The rise of authoritarianism among the younger generation in China[J].Social Science Quarterly,102(1):90-106.
• Kubat A.2018.Morality as legitimacy under Xi Jinping:The political functionality of traditional culture for the Chinese communist party[J].Journal of Current Chinese Affairs,47(3):47-86.
• Lima M E O,de Fran?a D X,Jetten J,et al.2021.Materialist and post-materialist concerns and the wish for a strong leader in 27 countries[J].Journal of Social and Political Psychology,9(1):207-220.
• Marquis C,Qiao K Y.2020.Waking from Mao’s dream:Communist ideological imprinting and the internationalization of entrepreneurial ventures in China[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,65(3):795-830.
• Martin A.2011.Partisan identification and attitudes to big versus small government in Australia:Evidence from the ISSP[J].Australian Journal of Political Science,46(2):243-256.
• Milton S,Buckner S,Salway S,et al.2015.Understanding welfare conditionality in the context of a generational habitus:A qualitative study of older citizens in England[J].Journal of Aging Studies,34:113-122.
• Mooney P.2007-04-20.Confucius comes back:In China,once-banned works by the country's most influential philosopher are studied and celebrated[N].The Chronicle of Higher Education.
• Ornatowski G K.1996.Confucian ethics and economic development:A study of the adaptation of Confucian values to modern Japanese economic ideology and institutions[J].The Journal of Socio-Economics,25(5):571-590.
• Persson A,Rothstein B.2015.It's my money:Why big government may be good government[J].Comparative Politics,47(2):231-249.
• Qian L C.2024.Behind the history and sociology of memory:A review of dominic Meng-Hsuan yang’s The Great Exodus from China:Trauma,Memory,and Identity in Modern Taiwan (2021,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press)[J].International Journal of Politics,Culture,and Society,37(2):291-298.
• Stubager R.2008.Education effects on authoritarian-libertarian values:A question of socialization1[J].The British Journal of Sociology,59(2):327-350.
• Swartz T T,Blackstone A,Uggen C,et al.2009.Welfare and citizenship:The effects of government assistance on young adults' civic participation[J].The Sociological Quarterly,50(4):633-665.
• Vilhjalmsson R.2016.Public views on the role of government in funding and delivering health services[J].Scandinavian Journal of Public Health,44(5):446-454.
• Wade R.1985.East Asian financial systems as a challenge to economics:Lessons from Taiwan[J].California Management Review,27(4):106-127.
• Waldo D.1980.The enterprise of public administration:A summary view[M].Novato,CA:Chandler & Sharp Publishers.
• Wang J G,Smyth R,Hwee T D.2000.The role of Confucian values in East Asian development:Before and after the financial crisis[J].Journal of International and Area Studies,7(1):115-135.
• Wei-Ming T.1989.The rise of industrial East Asia:The role of Confucian values[J].The Copenhagen Journal of Asian Studies,4:81-81.
• Wei-Ming T.2005.Cultural China:The periphery as the center[J].Daedalus,134(4):145-167.
• Yang Y,Schulhofer-Wohl S,Fu W J,et al.2008.The intrinsic estimator for age-period-cohort analysis:What it is and how to use it[J].American Journal of Sociology,113(6):1697-1736.
• Yeganeh H.2017.Cultural modernization and work-related values and attitudes:An application of Inglehart’s theory[J].International Journal of Development Issues,16(2):130-146.
• Zhai Y D.2018.Traditional values and political trust in China[J].Journal of Asian and African Studies,53(3):350-365.
• Zhang T H,Brym R,Andersen R.2017.Liberalism and postmaterialism in China:The role of social class and inequality[J].Chinese Sociological Review,49(1):65-87.
• Zhong Y.2014.Do Chinese people trust their local government,and why?An empirical study of political trust in urban China[J].Problems of Post-Communism,61(3):31-44.