陈天昊,徐玮,盛誉

• 1:清华大学公共管理学院

摘要(Abstract)：

通过分析Web of Science数据库关于公共行政接受司法监督的文献(1945—2022年),本文提炼司法监督公共行政之“驱动因素—监督模式—监督效果”的研究框架，在此基础上回顾我国法治建设历程，进一步展现公共行政接受司法监督的中国实践。围绕这一议题，我国公共管理学界应系统地利用实证研究推进理论建设，包括构建专门指标测量关键概念，借助数字技术拓展数据来源，引进前沿方法完善因果论述；并应以中国改革经验发展理论框架，包括从整体维度分析驱动司法监督的各影响因素，扩展司法—行政建设性关系视角，并以政治回应、行政绩效、权利保护三个维度综合评估司法监督效果。

关键词(KeyWords)： 市场经济;有为政府;法治政府;司法监督

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 清华大学自主科研计划(项目批准号:2023THZWJC04)资助

作者(Author): 陈天昊,徐玮,盛誉

参考文献(References)：

• 陈天昊，邵建树，王雪纯.2020.检察行政公益诉讼制度的效果检验与完善路径基于双重差分法的实证分析[J].中外法学，32(5):1328-1352.Chen T H,Shao J S,Wang X C.2020.Study for effects and improvement path of administrative public interest litigation filed by the procuratorate an empirical study based on difference-in-differences method[J].Peking University Law Journal,32(5):1328-1352.(in Chinese)
• 程金华.2009.中国行政纠纷解决的制度选择——以公民需求为视角[J].中国社会科学，(6):144-160,207-208.Cheng J H.2009.Institutional options for administrative disputes in China-from the perspective of the needs of the public[J].Social Sciences in China,(6):144-160,207-208.(in Chinese)
• 范子英，赵仁杰.2019.法治强化能够促进污染治理吗?——来自环保法庭设立的证据[J].经济研究，54(3):21-37.Fan Z Y,Zhao R J.2019.Does rule of law promote pollution control?Evidence from the establishment of the environmental court[J].Economic Research Journal,54(3):21-37.(in Chinese)
• 韩万渠.2020.行政自我规制吸纳法治压力：地方政府信息公开绩效及其生成机理[J].中国行政管理，(7):56-63.Han W Q.2020.Administrative self-regulation absorb the pressure of rule of law:The performance of local government information disclosure and its formation mechanism[J].Chinese Public Administration,(7):56-63.(in Chinese)
• 何海波.2009.司法判决中的正当程序原则[J].法学研究，31(1):124-146.He H B.2009.Some indications of due process principle in judicial judgments of China[J].Chinese Journal of Law,31(1):124-146.(in Chinese)
• 何海波.2018.一次修法能有多少进步——2014年《中华人民共和国行政诉讼法》修改回顾[J].清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版),33(3):26-43,190-191.He H B.2018.How much progress can legislation bring?—The 2014 amendment of the administrative litigation law of PRC[J].Journal of Tsinghua University (Philosophy and Social Sciences),33(3):26-43,190-191.(in Chinese)
• 胡卫列，田凯.2017.检察机关提起行政公益诉讼试点情况研究[J].行政法学研究，(2):19-35.Hu W L,Tian K.2017.Pilot project of procuratorial organ initiating administrative public welfare litigation[J].Administrative Law Review,(2):19-35.(in Chinese)
• 黄俊，赵宇，胡丹奇，等.2021.司法改善与企业投资——基于我国巡回法庭设立的经验研究[J].经济学(季刊),21(5):1521-1544.Huang J,Zhao Y,Hu D Q,et al.2021.Judicial improvement and corporate investment—Empirical analysis on the establishment of circuit court[J].China Economic Quarterly,21(5):1521-1544.(in Chinese)
• 黄学贤，丁钰.2011.行政审判中的司法建议制度运行分析——以江苏法院为视角[J].行政法学研究，(3):86-91.Huang X X,Ding Y.2011.Analysis on judicial advice system application to administrative adjudication—From aspect of Jiangsu court[J].Administrative Law Review,(3):86-91.(in Chinese)
• 江必新.2001.《关于执行〈中华人民共和国行政诉讼法〉若干问题的解释》的基本精神[J].法律适用，(7):39-46.Jiang B X.2001.Basic spirit of the interpretation of certain issues concerning the implementation of the Administrative Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China[J].Journal of Law Application,(7):39-46.(in Chinese)
• 姜明安.2015.论新《行政诉讼法》的若干制度创新[J].行政法学研究，(4):12-21.Jiang M A.2015.On several system innovations of new administrative procedure law[J].Administrative Law Review,(4):12-21.(in Chinese)
• 康伟，陈茜，陈波.2014.公共管理研究领域中的社会网络分析[J].公共行政评论，7(6):129-151,166.Kang W,Chen Q,Chen B.2014.Study of social network analysis in the field of public management[J].Journal of Public Administration,7(6):129-151,166.(in Chinese)
• 李文钊，徐文.2022.基于因果推理的政策评估：一个实验与准实验设计的统一框架[J].管理世界，38(12):104-121,9.Li W Z,Xu W.2022.Policy evaluation research based on causal inference:A unified framework for experimental and quasi-experimental designs[J]. Journal of Management World,38(12):104-121,9.(in Chinese)
• 刘艺.2020.我国检察公益诉讼制度的发展态势与制度完善——基于2017—2019年数据的实证分析[J].重庆大学学报(社会科学版),26(4):173-183.Liu Y.2020.The development and improvement of public interest litigation by procuratorate in China:An empirical analysis based on related data from 2017 to 2019[J].Journal of Chongqing University (Social Science Edition),26(4):173-183.(in Chinese)
• 卢超.2015.行政诉讼司法建议制度的功能衍化[J].法学研究，37(3):19-30.Lu C.2015.Functional evolution of the system of judicial suggestion in China[J].Chinese Journal of Law,37(3):19-30.(in Chinese)
• 吕孝礼，朱宪，付帅泽，等.2022.视频研究方法：开辟公共管理研究新思路[J].公共行政评论，15(6):173-195,200.Lyu X L,Zhu X,Fu S Z,et al.2022.Video research methods:A new approach in public administration studies[J].Journal of Public Administration,15(6):173-195,200.(in Chinese)
• 马怀德，解志勇.1999.行政诉讼案件执行难的现状及对策——兼论建立行政法院的必要性与可行性[J].法商研究，(6):100-106.Ma H D,Xie Z Y.1999.Current situation and countermeasures of the difficulty of enforcement in administrative litigation cases—An essay on the necessity and feasibility of establishing administrative courts[J].Studies in Law and Business,(6):100-106.(in Chinese)
• 马怀德.2019.新时代行政公益诉讼制度的发展与实践[J].人民论坛·学术前沿，(5):56-64.Ma H D.2019.The administrative public interest litigation system in the new era[J].Frontiers,(5):56-64.(in Chinese)
• 潘新美，何彬.2017.行政诉讼对街头官僚执法的监督功能：基于交警执法的个案研究[J].中国行政管理，(9):52-57.Pan X M,He B.2017.The supervision function of administrative litigation on street bureaucratic enforcement:A case study based on traffic police enforcement[J].Chinese Public Administration,(9):52-57.(in Chinese)
• 裴俊巍，陈慧荣.2018.碎片化权威主义下协同治理的司法路径——以“中国政府采购第一案”为例[J].经济社会体制比较，(5):95-103.Pei J W,Chen H R.2018.The judicial way of cooperative governance under fragmented authoritarianism:Based on the first case of Chinese government procurement[J].Comparative Economic & Social Systems,(5):95-103.(in Chinese)
• 覃慧，陈俊霆.2023.行政机关负责人出庭应诉的实施情况考察——基于广东省22 471份行政判决书的实证分析[J].苏州大学学报(法学版),10(3):53-66.Qin H,Chen J T.2023.Investigation on the implementation of the appearance of the person in charge of the administrative agency to respond to the Lawsuit:An empirical analysis based on 22 471 administrative judgments in Guangdong province[J].Journal of Soochow University (Law Edition),10(3):53-66.(in Chinese)
• 渠敬东，周飞舟，应星.2009.从总体支配到技术治理——基于中国30年改革经验的社会学分析[J].中国社会科学，(6):104-127,207.Qu J D,Zhou F Z,Ying X.2009.From macromanagement to micromanagement—Reflections on thirty years of reform from the sociological perspective[J].Social Sciences in China,(6):104-127,207.(in Chinese)
• 施芸卿.2013.自我边界的“选择性固化”:公民运动与转型期国家一个人关系的重塑——以B市被拆迁居民集团行政诉讼为例[J].社会学研究，28(2):125-151,244.Shi Y Q.2013.“Selective solidification of self-boundary:Citizens movement and the reconstruction of state-individual relationship during China's social transformation[J].Sociological Studies,28(2):125-151,244.(in Chinese)
• 唐应茂，刘庄.2021.庭审直播是否影响公正审判?——基于西部某法院的实验研究[J].清华法学，15(5):146-162.Tang Y M,Liu Z.2021.Do trial lives influence fairness?An empirical study of a court in China's western region[J].Tsinghua University Law Journal,15(5):146-162.(in Chinese)
• 王天华.2016.案例指导制度的行政法意义[J].清华法学，10(4):34-49.Wang T H.2016.Administrative law implications of the case guidance system[J].Tsinghua University Law Journal,10(4):34-49.(in Chinese)
• 王学辉，程怡.2020.构建中国特色行政判决强制执行制度[J].学习论坛，(1):87-96.Wang X H,Cheng Y.2020.Building the system of compulsory execution of administrative judgment with Chinese characteristics[J].Tribune of Study,(1):87-96.(in Chinese)
• 向淼，郁建兴.2021.法治行政：中国公共行政学的法律路径——一项新的研究议程[J].公共管理学报，18(4):1-9,165.Xiang M,Yu J X.2021.Rule of law as the foundation of public administration:The legal approach to public administration in China—A new research agenda[J].Journal of Public Management,18(4):1-9,165.(in Chinese)
• 向淼，郁建兴.2022.司法如何影响政策过程?——基于对地方政府中心工作的案例比较分析[J].公共行政评论，15(2):78-94,197-198.Xiang M,Yu J X.2022.How does the judiciary influence the policy process?A comparative case study of local governments' central task[J].Journal of Public Administration,15(2):78-94,197-198.(in Chinese)
• 杨立华，何元增.2013.公共管理定性研究的基本路径[J].中国行政管理，(11):100-105.Yang L H,He Y Z.2013.A concise roadmap to public administration qualitative research[J].Chinese Public Administration,(11):100-105.(in Chinese)
• 杨伟东.2015.行政诉讼制度和理论的新发展——行政诉讼法修正案评析[J].国家检察官学院学报，23(1):60-69,173-174.Yang W D.2015.New developments of administrative litigation system and theory—comments on amendments to administrative litigation act[J].Journal of National Prosecutors College,23(1):60-69,173-174.(in Chinese)
• 姚锐敏.2014.县级政府依法行政动力系统存在的主要问题及改善途径——基于我国23个省市区的调查统计数据[J].政治学研究，(5):25-36.Yao R M.2014.Major problems and ways to improve the power system of county-level government administration in accordance with the law—Based on the survey statistics of 23 provinces and municipalities in China[J].CASS Journal of Political Science,(5):25-36.(in Chinese)
• 应松年.2017.中国行政法发展的创新之路[J].行政法学研究，(3):44-51.Ying S N.2017.The innovation of administrative law in China[J].Administrative Law Review,(3):44-51.(in Chinese)
• 余凌云.2008.法院如何发展行政法[J].中国社会科学，(1):87-99,206.Yu L Y.2008.How the courts develop administrative law[J].Social Sciences in China,(1):87-99,206.(in Chinese)
• 于晓虹.2014.策略性服从：我国法院如何推进行政诉讼[J].清华法学，8(4):103-124.Yu X H.2014.Strategic obedience:How our courts advance administrative litigation[J].Tsinghua University Law Journal,8(4):103-124.(in Chinese)
• 郁建兴，高翔.2012.地方发展型政府的行为逻辑及制度基础[J].中国社会科学，(5):95-112,206-207.Yu J X,Gao X.2012.Behavioral logic and institutional basis of local developmental states[J].Social Sciences in China,(5):95-112,206-207.(in Chinese)
• 郁建兴，向淼.2016.从分离到整合：公共行政与法律间关系的理论演进与实践变迁[J].中国行政管理，(8):6-12.Yu J X,Xiang M.2016.From separation to combination:The theoretical development and practical change of the relationship between law and public administration[J].Chinese Public Administration,(8):6-12.(in Chinese)
• 张翔.2018.我国国家权力配置原则的功能主义解释[J].中外法学，30(2):281-303.Zhang X.2018.The principle of distribution of state power in the Chinese constitution a functional interpretation[J].Peking University Law Journal,30(2):281-303.(in Chinese)
• 张彦娥.2021-07-28.对建立府院联动化解行政争议机制的思考[N].检察日报.
• 章志远.2020.中国行政诉讼中的府院互动[J].法学研究，42(3):3-19.Zhang Z Y.2020.Government-court interaction in Chinese administrative litigation[J].Chinese Journal of Law,42(3):3-19.(in Chinese)
• 赵仁杰，张家凯.2022.地方司法体制改革与企业投资——来自地方法院人财物省级统管的证据[J].经济学(季刊),22(2):505-526.Zhao R J,Zhang J K.2022.Reform of local judicial system and corporate investment—Evidence from universal management of local courts below province[J].China Economic Quarterly,22(2):505-526.(in Chinese)
• 周尚君.2017.党管政法：党与政法关系的演进[J].法学研究，39(1):196-208.Zhou S J.2017.The system of the party's leadership over political and legal work in China[J].Chinese Journal of Law,39(1):196-208.(in Chinese)
• 周雪光.2011.权威体制与有效治理：当代中国国家治理的制度逻辑[J].开放时代，(10):67-85.Zhou X G.2011.Authoritative institutions and effective governance:The institutional logic of state governance in contemporary China[J].Open Times,(10):67-85.(in Chinese)
• Allred S.2002.End of an era:The 11th amendment and public personnel administration[J].Public Personnel Management,31(3):263-274.
• Amado R.2001.Checks,balances,and appointments in the public service:Israeli experience in comparative perspective[J].Public Administration Review,61(5):569-584.
• Baum L.1978.Police response to appellate court decision:Mapp and Miranda[J].Policy Studies Journal,7(S1):425-431.
• Bertelli A M.2004.Strategy and accountability:Structural reform litigation and public management[J].Public Administration Review,64(1):28-42.
• Blankenau W F,Skidmore M L.2004.School finance litigation,tax and expenditure limitations,and education spending[J].Contemporary Economic Policy,22(1):127-143.
• Blauberger M.2012.With Luxembourg in mind…the remaking of national policies in the face of ECJ jurisprudence[J].Journal of European Public Policy,19(1):109-126.
• Blauberger M,Weiss M.2013.‘If you can't beat me,join me!’ How the Commission pushed and pulled member states into legislating defence procurement[J].Journal of European Public Policy,20(8):1120-1138.
• Bullock III C S,Regens J L.1982.The courts as a source of regulatory revitalization:External agenda setting and equal education programs[J].Review of Policy Research,1(3):565-571.
• Buttrick S M.1995.Remedy and remorse:Judicial control of social welfare[J].Administration in Social Work,19(3):75-82.
• Carroll J L,Haveman R H,Karaganis J V.1983.When complex facts threaten court reviews:Litigation over navigation projects[J].Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,2(3):418-431.
• Christensen R K,Goerdel H T,Nicholson-Crotty S.2011.Management,law,and the pursuit of the public good in public administration[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,21(S1):i125-i140.
• Cobarzan B V,Drago? D D,Neam?u B.2008.Free access to public information:Enforcement,appeals and judicial review.A comparative perspective from Cee countries[J].Transylvanian Review of Administrative Sciences,4(24):53-63.
• Conant L,Hofmann A,Soennecken D,et al.2018.Mobilizing European law[J].Journal of European Public Policy,25(9):1376-1389.
• Cooper P J.1985.Conflict or constructive tension-the changing relationship of judges and administrators[J].Public Administration Review,45(11):643-652.
• Cramton R C.1976.Judicial law making and administration[J].Public Administration Review,36(5):551-555.
• Daniel C.1992.Constitutionalizing merit?Practical implications of Elrod,Branti,and Rutan[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,12(2):26-34.
• Deters H,Falkner G.2021.Remapping the European agenda-setting landscape[J].Public Administration,99(2):290-303.
• Drewry G.1990.Judicial review—Quite enough of a fairly good thing?[J].Public Policy and Administration,5(1):20-32.
• Duncombe W D,Straussman J D.1993.The impact of courts on the decision to expand jail capacity[J].Administration & Society,25(3):267-292.
• Evans W N,Murray S E,Schwab R M.1997.Schoolhouses,courthouses,and statehouses after Serrano[J].Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,16(1):10-31.
• Feldman D.1988.Judicial review:A way of controlling government?[J].Public Administration,66(1):21-34.
• Finder S.1989.Like throwing an egg against a stone?Administrative Litigation in the People's Republic of China[J].Journal of Chinese Law,3(1):1-28.Fisher E,Pascual P,Wagner W.2014.Rethinking judicial review of expert agencies[J].Texas Law Review,93(7):1681-1722.
• Gailmard S,Patty J W.2017.Participation,process and policy:The informational value of politicised judicial review[J].Journal of Public Policy,37(3):233-260.
• Galanter M.1983.The radiating effects of courts[M]//Boyum K,Mather L.Empirical Theories about Courts.New York:Longmans,117:117-142.
• Gallagher M,Yang Y.2017.Getting schooled:Legal mobilization as an educative process[J].Law & Social Inquiry,42(1):163-194.
• Gallas E C.1971.The court as a social force[J].Public Administration Review,31(2):125-133.
• Gantz D T,Plant J F.1988.Statistics,discrimination,and the courts:The Fairfax county example[J].The American Review of Public Administration,18(4):389-400.
• Goodnow F J.1900.Politics and administration:A study in government[M].New York:Macmillan.
• Hale G E.1979.Federal courts and the state budgetary process[J].Administration & Society,11(3):357-368.
• Hamilton D K.1993.The staffing function in Illinois state government after Rutan[J].Public Administration Review,53(4):381-386.
• He X.2013.Judicial innovation and local politics:Judicialization of administrative governance in east China[J].The China Journal,(69):20-42.
• Hicklin A.2007.The effect of race-based admissions in public universities:Debunking the myths about Hopwood and Proposition 209[J].Public Administration Review,67(2):331-340.
• Howard S K.1985.A message from Garcia[J].Public Administration Review,45(Law and Public Affairs):738-741.
• Intoccia G F.2002.Reassessing judicial capacity to resolve complex questions of social policy[J].Journal of Legal Studies,11:127-154.
• Jackson D W.1990.A conceptual framework for the comparative analysis of judicial review[J].Policy Studies Journal,19(1):161-171.
• James S.1996.The political and administrative consequences of judicial review[J].Public Administration,74(4):613-637.
• Johnson C A.1979.Judicial decisions and organizational change:A theory[J].Administration & Society,11(1):27-51.
• Jones E S,Taylor C P.1995.Litigating agency change:The impact of the courts and administrative appeals process on the forest service[J].Policy Studies Journal,23(2):310-336.
• Kagan R A.1991.Adversarial legalism and American government[J].Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,10(3):369-406.
• Kim J.2007.The judiciary's role in good governance in Korea[J].Policy and Society,26(2):15-32.
• Kochtcheeva L V.2009.Administrative discretion and environmental regulation:Agency substantive rules and court decisions in U.S.air and water quality policies[J].Review of Policy Research,26(3):241-265.
• Koenig H,Kise A.1996.Law and the city manager:Beginning to understand the sources of influence on the management of local government[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,6(3):443-459.
• Kramarz T,Cosolo D,Rossi A.2017.Judicialization of environmental policy and the crisis of democratic accountability[J].Review of Policy Research,34(1):31-49.
• Langer L,Brace P.2005.The preemptive power of state supreme courts:Adoption of abortion and death penalty legislation[J].Policy Studies Journal,33(3):317-340.
• Lee S.1986.Judicial review of public administration[J].Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy.Public Money,6(3):35-38.
• Lewis G B.1997.Lifting the ban on gays in the civil service:Federal policy toward gay and lesbian employees since the Cold War[J].Public Administration Review,57(5):387-395.
• Li J.2013.Suing the leviathan—An empirical analysis of the changing rate of administrative litigation in China[J].Journal of Empirical Legal Studies,10(4):815-846.
• Limbocker S,Resh W G,Selin J L.2022.Anticipated adjudication:An analysis of the judicialization of the US administrative state[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,32(3):610-626.
• Lubow A,Schmidt S K.2021.A hidden champion?The European Court of Justice as an agenda-setter in the case of posted workers[J].Public Administration,99(2):321-334.
• Martin P L.1973.The Hatch Act in court:Some recent developments[J].Public Administration Review,33(5):443-447.
• Martinsen D S,Blauberger M,Heindlmaier A,et al.2019.Implementing European case law at the bureaucratic frontline:How domestic signalling influences the outcomes of EU law[J].Public Administration,97(4):814-828.
• Miaz J,Achermann C.2022.Bureaucracies under judicial control?Relational discretion in the implementation of immigration detention in Swiss cantons[J].Administration & Society,54(4):629-659.
• Mitchell C E.2009.Retaliation lawsuits held applicable for federal employees under the age discrimination in Employment Act:A victory for older federal workers:The Supreme Court's decision in Gomez-Perez v.Potter,postmaster general[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,29(1):89-94.
• Mnookin R H,Kornhauser L.1979.Bargaining in the shadow of the law:The case of divorce[J].The Yale Law Journal,88(5):950-997.
• Moffet J.1994.Judicial review and environmental policy:Lessons for Canada from the United States[J].Canadian Public Administration,37(1):140-166.
• Nelson R H.1985.NRDC v.MORTON:The role of judicial policy making in public rangeland management[J].Policy Studies Journal,14(2):255-264.
• O'Brien K J,Li L J.2004.Suing the local state:Administrative litigation in rural China[J].The China Journal,(51):75-96.
• O'Leary R,Wise C R.1991.Public managers,judges,and legislators:Redefining the “New Partnership”[J].Public Administration Review,51(4):316-327.
• O' Leary R,Straussman J.1993.The impact of courts on public management:What do we know and how do we know it[M]//Bozeman B.Public Management.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
• Osorio A,O'Leary R.2017.The impact of courts on public management:New insights from the legal literature[J].Administration & Society,49(5):658-678.
• Panke D.2007.The European Court of Justice as an agent of Europeanization?Restoring compliance with EU law[J].Journal of European Public Policy,14(6):847-866.
• Pei M X.1997.Citizens v.mandarins:Administrative litigation in China[J].The China Quarterly,152:832-862.
• Platt L,Sunkin M,Calvo K.2010.Judicial review litigation as an incentive to change in local authority public services in England and Wales[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,20(S2):i243-i260.
• Pletenik B,Cooper P J.1992.Administration at the cusp of science:The case of recombinant DNA[J].Administration & Society,24(2):132-162.
• Rawlings H F.1986.Judicial review and the ‘control of government’[J].Public Administration,64(2):135-145.
• Reardon S F,Grewal E T,Kalogrides D,et al.2012.Brown fades:The end of court-ordered s