中国的寻租：从日本与墨西哥的经验中我们能学到什么?Rent-seeking in China:What Can we Learn from a Comparison with Japan and Mexico?
Richard Boyd,陈一林
摘要(Abstract)：
本论文的预期目标不高。通过对日本与墨西哥寻租行为的分析,我们发展出一个理论框架,并试图用这个理论框架来审视最近一些对中国寻租行为的研究。这个理论框架还在不断完善中。我们承认对中国政治经济的了解是远远不够的。
关键词(KeyWords)： 中国;日本;墨西哥;寻租
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): Richard Boyd,陈一林
参考文献(References)：
- ②发展型国家理论的著作多得几乎不用在这里引用。比如Chalmers Johnson,MITI and the Japanese Miracle:the Growth of Industrial Policy,1925-1975.Stanford Ca:Stanford University Press,1982;Meredith Woo-Cumings ed.,The Developmental State.Ithaca and London:Cornell University Press,1999;Robert Wade, Governing the Market:Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asian Industrialization.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press,1990.
- ①对这种方法M．Aoki．K．Murdock and M．Okuno-Fujiwara做出了有趣的阐释。M.Aoki,K.Murdock and M.Okuno-Fujiwara,“Beyond the East Asian Miracle:Introducing the Market Enhancing View”,pp.1-40 in M.Aoki,Hyung-Ki Kim,M.Okuno-Fujiwara eds.,The Role of Government in East Asian Economic Development:Comparative Institutional Analysis,Oxford,Clarendon Paperbacks,1996,p.14.“假设政府的政策为私有部门创造了寻租机会，这种机会的回报高于完全竞争市场的回报，但这种寻租机会不是财富的直接转移。因此，如果政策创造的租金是基于一定的客观准则分配的，那么私有部门可能生产出比在竞争市场条件下更多的商品。这就是‘绩效指数回报'的含义，有点类似‘条件租金'。”
- ①参见Richard Boyd,“Modes of rent-seeking and economic outcomes:a comparison of Japan and Mexico”, pp.148-212 in Richard Boyd,Benno Galjart and Tak-wing Ngo eds.,Political Conflict and Development in East Asia and Latin America,London and New York,Routledge,2006,pp.181-200.
- ③参见Richard Boyd,“Rents and Economic Outcomes in Japan and Taiwan”,pp.151-192,in Luigi Tombs ed.,East As(?)an Capitalism:Conflicts,Growth and Crisis,Annali,Milan:Fondazione Giangiacomo Feltrinelli 2002,and Boyd 2006 a(op.cir.).Mark Tilton,Restrained Trade,Cartels in Japan's Basic Materials Industries. Ithaca and Cornell:Cornell University Press,1996
- ③Boyd,2006(a),p.152.
- ①参见Boyd,2006(a),pp.155-181,and Richard Boyd,“Modes of Rent-Seeking and Economic Outeomes: the case of Mexico”,pp.1-31,in China Public Administration Review,vol 4,2006(b)(in Chinese).P.C.Roberts & K.LaFollette Araujo,The Capitalist Revolution in Latin America,New York and Oxford:Oxford University Press,1997.S.Haber,ed.,Crony Capitalism and Economic Growth in Latin America:Theory and Evidence, Stanford,California:Stanford University,Hoover Institution Press,2002.把墨西哥的寻租方式理解为一种制度化的腐败参见C.Lomnitz ed.,Vicios Publicos,Virtudes Privadas:la Corruption en Mexico:Alvaro Obregon, Mexico:Ciesas,2000.
- ②引自Boyd 2006(a).
- ③参见Boyd 2002.
- ①Boyd 2006(a).pp.189-191.
- ①M.Curtis and G.Miller,“A regulatory model of decisionmaking in Japanese firms,”Zeitachrift fur Japanisches Recht,no.4 Deutsch-Japanische Juristenvereignigung E.V.,Hamburg:Zeitgemasser Druck,1997, pp.18-29,p.23.
- ②毫无疑问，Hutchcroft正确地指出由于研究寻租的学者对国家的不喜欢使得现有的研究出现了这个空白。如果国家天生就是坏的，那么研究不同的国家形态对寻租的影响有什么价值呢?参见P．Hutchcroft．“Obstructive Corruption:The Politics of Privilege in the Philippines,”pp.207-247,in M.H.Khan and Jomo K. S.,Rents,Rent-Seeking and Economic Development:Theory and Evidence in Asia,Cambridge,U.K.:Cambridge University Press,2000,p.210.
- ③A.Macintyre,The Power of Institutions:Political Architecture and Governance,Ithaca and London, Cornell University Press,2003,p.14.
- ①R.McKinnon,Market-preserving Fiscal Federalism.Working paper,Department of Economics,Stanford University 1994.G.Montinola,Y.Qian and B.Weingast,“Federalism,Chinese Style:The Political Basis for Economic Success in China”,pp.50-81,World Politics 48(1) 1995.B.Weingast,“The Economic Role of Political Institutions:Market-preserving Federalism and Economic Growth,”pp.1-31,in Journal of Law,Economics and Organization,11(1),1995
- ②A.Macintyre,“Funny Money:Fiscal Policy,Rent-seeking and Economic Performance in Indonesia”, pp.248-273,in Khan & Jomo,2000,p.249.
- ③M.T.Rock,Thailand's Old Bureaucratic Polity and Its New Semi-democracy,pp.182-206,in Khan & Jomo 2000,p.185.
- ④Hutchcroft,2000,p.212.
- ⑤J.O.Haley,“The paradox of weak power and strong authority in the Japanese state”,pp.67-82,in Richard Boyd and Tak-Wing Ngo eds.,Asian States:Beyond the developmental perspective,London and New York:Routledge,2005.
- ⑦Haley,2005,pp.70-71.
- ①关于这个论断．详尽的说明参见Richard Boyd,“The making of state-bureaucracy relations in Japan”pp.53-90,in Richard Boyd and Tak-Wing Ngo eds.,State Making in Asia,London and New York:Routledge, 2006.(henceforth Boyd 2006(c)).
- ①H.A.Camin & L.Meyer,In the Shadow of the Mexican Revolution,Austin:University of Texas Press, 1993,p.254.
- ③H.A.Camin & L.Meyer,In the Shadow of the Mexican Revolution,Austin:University of Texas Press, 1993,p.255.
- ④P.Smith,Labyrinths of Power,Princeton NJ:Princeton University Press 1979,p.218.
- ⑤Alan Knight,The Modern Mexican State:Theory and Practice,pp,177-218,in Miguel Angel Centeno and Fernando Lopez-Alves eds.,The Other Mirror:Grand Theory through the Lens of Latin America,Princeton NJ:Princeton University Press 2001,pp.190-195.
- ⑥Alan Knight,The Modern Mexican State,2001,p.182.
- ①D.W.Brinkerhoff and A.A.Goldsmith,Clientelsim,Patrimonialism and Democratic Governance,report prepared for the US Agency for International Development,Office of Democracy and Governance,December 2002, http://www.abtassociates.com/reports/2002601089183_30950,pdf viewed 7 May 2006.
- ②Brinkerhoff and Goldsmith,2002,p.2.
- ③Fred Riggs,Administration in Developing Countries:The Theory of Prismatic Society,Houghton Mifflin Co.1964.
- ④F.G.Bailey,Stratagems and Spoils:A Social Anthropology of Politics,Oxford:Basil Blackwell,1970.
- ⑤Hutchcroft,2000,pp.209-211.Roberts & Lafollette Arajuo,1997.
- ⑥Hutchcroft,2000,p.209.
- ①M.Aoki,“The Role of Community Norms and Government in East Asian Rural-Inclusive Development and Institutional Building”,pp.529-551,in Y.Hayami and M.Aoki eds.,The Institutional Foundations of East Asian Economic Development,Proceedings of the IEA Conference,Basingstoke UK:Macmillan Press,1998.J.P. Platteau and Y.Hayami,Resource Endowments and Agricultural Development:Africa versus Asia,pp.357-410, in Hayami and Aoki 1998.Y.Hayami ed.,Rural Based Development of Commerce and Industry:Selected Experiences from East Asia,Washington DC:The World Bank,1998.
- ②J.O.Hayley,Authority without Power:Law and the Japanese Paradox.
- ③New York and Oxford,Oxford University Press,1991.Haley,1991,p.61.
- ④T.Okazaki and M.Okuno-Fujiwara,“Gendai Nihon no keizai shisutemu to sono rekishiteki genryuu”(The economic system of contemporary Japan and its historical origins) in T.Okazaki and M.Okuno-Fujiwara eds.,Gendai Nihon keizai shisutemu no genryuu(Origins of the contemporary Japanese economic system),Tokyo: Nihon Keizai Shinbunsha,1993.
- ⑤Haley,The paradox of weak power,Boyd and Ngo,2005;p.69.
- ⑥Haley,The paradox of weak power,Boyd and Ngo,2005,p.70.
- ①S.N.Eisenstadt and L.Roniger,Patrons,clients and friends.Interpersonal relations and the structure of trust in society.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1984,p.116.
- ②Glen Dealey,The Public Man,An interpretation of Latin American and other Catholic Cultures, Amherst:University of Massachusetts Press,1972.Merilee Grindle,“Patrons and Clients in the Bureaucracy: Career Networks in Mexico,”Latin American Research Review.
- ③Roderic A.Camp,“Camarillas as in Mexican Politics:the case of the Salinas Cabinet”,pp.85-107,in Mexican Studies/Estudios Mexicano,6(1),Winter 1990,p.107.
- ④Camp,同上,p.86.
- ⑤Dealy,1972.p.12.
- ⑥Boyd,2002,2006(a)、(b).
- ①Kang对韩国政商关系的研究很具有启发性。我们认为他对政商关系的衡量，也就是集中程度，只是其中一个方面。D.C.Kang,Crony Capitalism:Corruption and Development in South Korea and the Philippines, Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2002.See also Haber,2002.
- ①Ricardo Carrillo Arronte,“The Role of the State and the Entrepreneurial Sector in Mexican Development”pp.45-63,in Sylvia Maxfield and Ricardo Anzaldua Montoya eds.,Government and Private Sector in Contemporary Mexico,Center for US-Mexican Studies,University of California,San Diego UCSD 1987,p.45.
- ②Blanca Heredia,Mexican Business and the State:The Political Economy of a“Muddled”Transition. Working Paper,182 October,1992,The Helen Kellogg Institute for International Studies,University of Notre Dame.p.7.
- ①Eric Thun,Changing Lanes in China:Foreign Direct Investment,Local Governments,and Auto Sector Development,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2006.
- ②A.H.Wedeman,From Mao to Market:rent-seeking,Local Protectionism,and Marketization in China, Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2003,Yi-min Lin,Between Polities and Markets:Firms,Competition, and Institutional Change in Post-Mao China,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2001.
- ③T.Saich,“The Blind Man and the Elephant:Analysing the Local State in China”,pp.75-100,in L. Tomba,2002,p.77.
- ④D.L.Wank,Commodifying Communism:Business,Trust,and Politics in a Chinese City,Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,1999.
- ①N.H.Leff,“Economic Development through Bureaucratic Corruption,”in A.J.Heidenheimer,M. Johnston and V.T.LeVine eds.,Political Corruption:A Handbook,New Brunswick:Transaction Publishers 1989,pp.396-397.
- ②A.O.Krueger,“The Political Economy of the Rent-seeking Society,”American Economic Review,64(3) 1974,pp.195,292.
- ③Jomo K.S.and E.T.Gomez,“Rents,Rent-seeking and Rent Deployment in Malaysia.”Unpublished ms Kuala Lumpur 1995 cited by Hutchcroft,2000,p.211.
- ④Jomo K.S.and Gomez E.T,“Rents,Rent-seeking and Rent Deployment in Malaysia”,Unpublished ms Kuala Lumpur 1995 cited by Hutchcroft,2000,p.211.
- ①Yi-min Lin,2001,p.18
- ②A.H.Wedeman,2003,p.242.
- ③Fred C.Teiwes and David Shambaugh tell us in David Shambaugh,“The Chinese State in the Post-Mao Era”,pp.161-187,in David Sham baugh ed.,The Modern Chinese State,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press 2000,p.161.
- ④Shambaugh,2000,p.167.
- ①A.H.Wedeman,2003,p.15.
- ②Yi-min Lin,2001,p.17.
- ①D.A.Yates,The Rentier state in Africa:Oil Rent Dependency and Neocolonialism in the Republic of Gabon,Trenton NJ:Africa World Press,1996.J.S.Ismael,.Kuwait:Dependency and Class in a Rentier State, Gainesville Florida:University Press of Florida.1993.T.L.Karl,The Paradox of Plenty:Oil Booms and Petro- States,Berkeley,Los Angeles,London:University of California Press,1997.
- ②T.Saich,2002,p.87.
- ③A.H.Wedeman,Budgets,“Extra-Budgets,and Small Treasuries:Illegal Monies and Local Autonomy in China,”Journal of Contemporary China,November 2000.
- ④M.Blecher and V.Shue,Tethered Deer.Government and Economy in a Chinese County,Stanford: Stanford University Press,1996.
- ⑤J.C.Oi,Rural China Takes Off:Institutional Foundations of Economic Reform,Berkeley:University of California Press,1999.
- ⑥M.Edin,“Local state structure and developmental incentives in China”,pp.110-128,in Boyd and Ngo 2005.Edin is frank in noting her reasons for focusing upon the local state“is not that it is necessarily conceptually different from the central state,but it is more a research method or strategy”,p.124
- ⑦Saich,2002,p.76.
- ⑧D.L.Wank,1999,p.4.
- ①参见Wedeman,2003.
- ②BBC,2006年9月4日.
- ③E.Steinfeld,Forging Reform,1998.
- ①C.A.McNally,“China's State-Owned Enterprises:Thriving or Crumbling”,Asia Pacific Issues,Analysis from the East-West Center,no 59,March 2002 p.4. http://www.eastwestcenter.org/stored/pdfs/api059.pdf accessed February 2 2007.
- ②同上.p.6.
- ③McNally,2002,p.6.
- ④Richard Boyd and Tak-Wing Ngo,“Emancipating the political economy of Asia from the growth paradigm”,pp.1-18 in Boyd and Ngo,2005.