袁子凌,蔡劲松

• 1:北京航空航天大学人文社会科学学院(公共管理学院)

摘要(Abstract)：

面向不同危机情境，政府应采用何种危机沟通策略以促进公众的政务信息采纳行为，是当前政府危机管理的重要议题。本研究基于情境危机沟通理论与信息采纳理论，从公众政务信息采纳行为视角出发，通过两项双因素组间调查实验，分别探究危机情境对公众政务信息采纳行为的影响及其中介机制，以及危机沟通策略对二者关系的调节机制。研究发现如下。(1)针对危机情境的“危机类型-危机历史”两个维度，在危机类型维度下，相较于无类型信息，意外型危机、可预防型危机均显著负向影响公众政务信息采纳行为，且可预防型危机的负向影响显著强于意外型危机；在危机历史维度下，相较于无危机历史，有危机历史显著负向影响公众政务信息采纳行为。(2)组织责任归因与组织声誉在危机情境与公众政务信息采纳行为的关系中起链式中介作用。(3)危机沟通策略在危机情境与公众政务信息采纳行为的关系中起调节作用，即在“意外型危机-无危机历史”情境下，减少型策略的效果显著优于否认型策略；在“意外型危机-有危机历史”“可预防型危机-无危机历史”“可预防型危机-有危机历史”三种情境下，重建型策略的效果显著优于否认型策略及减少型策略。本研究不仅从理论上拓展了政府危机沟通的研究视角，也为政府针对不同危机情境采用与之适配的危机沟通策略，进而提升政务信息采纳效果提供了实践启示。

关键词(KeyWords)： 危机情境;沟通策略;政务信息;采纳行为;调查实验

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家社会科学基金哲学社会科学领军人才项目“统筹文化发展和安全的理论建构、风险评估及防范机制研究”(项目批准号:22VRC059)的资助

作者(Author): 袁子凌,蔡劲松

参考文献(References)：

• 陈超,李响.2019.逻辑因果与量化相关:少案例比较方法的两种路径[J].公共管理评论,(1):3-22.Chen C,Li X.2019.Boolean causality and quantitative association:Two approaches to the small-N comparative method[J].China Public Administration Review,(1):3-22.(in Chinese) 陈旖旎,周晓英,岳丽欣,等.2022.移动UGC社区用户健康信息采纳行为意愿的影响因素[J].图书情报知识,39(5):82-95.Chen Y N,Zhou X Y,Yue L X,et al.2022.Factors influencing adoption willingness of the health information in the mobile UGC community[J].Documentation,Information&Knowledge,39(5):82-95.(in Chinese) 高学德,王镇江.2024.危机沟通策略对地方政府信任的影响研究[J].公共管理评论,6(3):76-98.Gao X D,Wang Z J.2024.How does a government crisis communication strategy affect public trust in local government?Evidence based on a survey experiment[J].China Public Administration Review,6(3):76-98.(in Chinese) 宫贺,韩冬,张庆园.2019.多元归因与信任重建:危机传播情境理论的中国情境---以2018年问题疫苗事件为例[J].新闻与传播研究,26(6):16-35.Gong H,Han D,Zhang Q Y.2019.Rethinking the Chinese situation of the situational crisis communication theory:Diversified attributions and trust reconstruction-Taking the2018 vaccine crisis as an example[J].Journalism&Communication,26(6):16-35.(in Chinese) 金锐,姜景.2025.我国高校舆情事件的形象修复研究---基于20个师德师风类舆情事件的实证分析[J].高教探索,(2):58-63.Jin R,Jiang J.2025.Research on image restoration of public opinion events in Chinese universities:An empirical analysis based on 20 public opinion events related to teacher morality and conduct[J].Higher Education Exploration,(2):58-63.(in Chinese) 赖胜强,唐雪梅.2018.政府网络舆情回应策略的内容分析[J].现代情报,38(10):108-114.Lai S Q,Tang X M.2018.Content analysis of the government's response strategy to online public opinion[J].Journal of Modern Information,38 (10):108-114.(in Chinese) 李红霞.2023.公共危机回应时间策略对地方政府组织声誉的影响机制研究[D].广州:华南理工大学.Li H X.2023.Study on the impact mechanism of public crisis response time strategy on organizational reputation of local government[D].Guangzhou:South China University of Technology.(in Chinese) 李红霞,郑石明,要蓉蓉.2024.危机情境、危机回应策略与政府回应有效性---基于40个案例的定性比较分析[J].公共行政评论,17(2):45-63,197.Li H X,Zheng S M,Yao R R.2024.Crisis situation,crisis response strategies,and government response effectiveness:Qualitative comparative analysis of 40 cases[J].Journal of Public Administration,17(2):45-63,197.(in Chinese) 李锦辉,张缘.2022.信息疫情视角下儿童家长的疫苗犹豫机制研究[J].全球传媒学刊,9(3):16-34.Li J H,Zhang Y.2022.Investigating the mechanism of parental COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy:From the perspective of infodemic[J].Global Journal of Media Studies,9(3):16-34.(in Chinese) 刘嘉琪,康天姝.2023.建设性沟通与政务健康信息采纳---基于31个省级卫健类政务微博的数据[J].新闻与传播研究,30(9):91-108.Liu J Q,Kang T S.2023.Constructive communication and adoption of government health information:Based on data from 31 provincial health commission's official microblogs[J].Journalism&Communication,30(9):91-108.(in Chinese) 刘银喜,吴京阳.2025.生成式人工智能嵌入政府治理的应用前景、潜在风险和防范机制[J].北京航空航天大学学报(社会科学版),38(1):103-112.Liu Y X,Wu J Y.2025.Application prospects,potential risks,and prevention mechanisms of integrating generative artificial intelligence into government governance[J].Journal of Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics(Social Sciences Edition),38(1):103-112.(in Chinese) 孟猛,尤剑,刘晨晖,等.2024.健康信息采纳行为研究---概念界定、理论模型与未来展望[J].现代情报,44(6):157-167.Meng M,You J,Liu C H,et al.2024.Review of research on health information adoption behavior-Conceptual definition,theoretical model,and future prospects[J].Journal of Modern Information,44(6):157-167.(in Chinese) 任莉颖.2018.用问卷做实验:调查实验法的概论与操作[M].重庆:重庆大学出版社.Ren L Y.2018.Survey experiment:A new technique of causal study[M].Chongqing:Chongqing University Press.(in Chinese) 宋雪雁,王萍.2010.信息采纳行为概念及影响因素研究[J].情报科学,28(5):760-762,767.Song X Y,Wang P.2010.Research on concept and effective factors of information adoption behavior[J].Information Science,28(5):760-762,767.(in Chinese) 粟路军,冯姗.2023.公共危机信息响应模式对公众应对行为的影响机制[J].管理评论,35(1):324-338.Su L J,Feng S.2023.The mechanism of how public crisis information response influences public reaction[J].Management Review,35(1):324-338.(in Chinese) 唐雪梅,袁熳,朱利丽.2021.政务舆情回应策略对政府形象修复的影响---情绪认知视角的有调节中介模型[J].公共行政评论,14(1):114-131,221-222.Tang X M,Yuan M,Zhu L L.2021.Repairing the government's image during a public opinion crisis-A moderated mediating model from the perspective of emotional cognition[J].Journal of Public Administration,14(1):114-131,221-222.(in Chinese) 吴宜蓁.2005.危机传播:公共关系与语艺观点的理论与实证[M].苏州:苏州大学出版社.Wu Y Z.2005.Crisis communication:Theory and empirical studies from the perspectives of public relations and rhetorical views[M].Suzhou:Soochow University Press.(in Chinese) 张静,雍会.2023.棉农绿色农业技术采纳意愿与行为的响应路径研究[J].干旱区资源与环境,37(8):23-31.Zhang J,Yong H.2023.Cotton farmers'willingness and behavior to adopt green agricultural technology and the response path[J].Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment,37(8):23-31.(in Chinese) 张向先,耿荣娜,郭顺利.2017.政务新媒体用户信息采纳行为及关键影响因素识别研究[J].情报理论与实践,40(10):62-68.Zhang X X,Geng R N,Guo S L.2017.A study on users'information acceptance behavior and the key influencing factors of government new media[J].Information Studies:Theory&Application,40(10):62-68.(in Chinese) Adebesin F,Mwalugha R.2020.The mediating role of organizational reputation and trust in the intention to use wearable health devices:Cross-country study[J].JMIR m Health and u Health,8(6):e16721. An S K,Gower K K.2009.How do the news media frame crises?A content analysis of crisis news coverage[J].Public Relations Review,35(2):107-112. Benoit W L.1997.Image repair discourse and crisis communication[J].Public Relations Review,23(2):177-186. Capolupo N,Piscopo G,Annarumma C.2020.Value co-creation and co-production in the interaction between citizens and public administration:A systematic literature review[J].Kybernetes,49(2):313-331. Claeys A S,Cauberghe V,Vyncke P.2010.Restoring reputations in times of crisis:An experimental study of the Situational Crisis Communication Theory and the moderating effects of locus of control[J].Public Relations Review,36(3):256-262. Coombs W T.2013.Situational theory of crisis:Situational crisis communication theory and corporate reputation[M]//Carroll C E.The Handbook of Communication and Corporate Reputation.Chichester:John Wiley&Sons:262-278. Coombs W T.2004.Impact of Past Crises on Current Crisis Communication[J].Journal of Business Communication,41(3):265-289. Coombs W T.2006.The protective powers of crisis response strategies:Managing reputational assets during a crisis[J].Journal of Promotion Management,12(3/4):241-260. Coombs W T.2007.Protecting organization reputations during a crisis:The development and application of situational crisis communication theory[J].Corporate Reputation Review,10(3):163-176. Coombs W T.2010.Parameters for crisis communication[M]//Coombs W T,Holladay S J.The Handbook of Crisis Communication.Hoboken:Blackwell Publishing:17-53. Coombs W T.2016.Reflections on a meta-analysis:Crystallizing thinking about SCCT[J].Journal of Public Relations Research,28(2):120-122. Coombs W T.2017.Revising situational crisis communication theory:The influences of social media on crisis communication theory and practice[M]//Jin Y,Austin L L.Social Media and Crisis Communication.New York:Routledge:21-37. Coombs W T.2022.Situational Crisis Communication Theory (SCCT):Refining and clarifying a cognitive-based theory of crisis communication[M]//Coombs W T,Holladay S J.The Handbook of Crisis Communication.2nd ed.Hoboken:John Wiley&Sons:193-204. Coombs W T,Holladay S J.1996.Communication and attributions in a crisis:An experimental study in crisis communication[J].Journal of Public Relations Research,8(4):279-295. Coombs W T,Holladay S J.2001.An extended examination of the crisis situations:A fusion of the relational management and symbolic approaches[J].Journal of Public Relations Research,13(4):321-340. Coombs W T,Holladay S J.2002.Helping crisis managers protect reputational assets:Initial tests of the situational crisis communication theory[J].Management Communication Quarterly,16(2):165-186. Coombs W T,Holladay S J.2005.An exploratory study of stakeholder emotions:Affect and crises[M]//Ashkanasy N M,Zerbe W J,H??rtel C E J.The Effect of Affect in Organizational Settings.Bingley:Emerald Group Publishing Limited:263-280. Coombs W T,Tachkova E R.2022.Elaborating the concept of threat in contingency theory:An integration with moral outrage and situational crisis communication theory[J].Public Relations Review,48(4):102234. Eaddy L L,Jin Y.2018.Crisis history tellers matter:The effects of crisis history and crisis information source on publics'cognitive and affective responses to organizational crisis[J].Corporate Communications:An International Journal,23(2):226-241. Han X,Baird C.2024.Government crisis messaging on social media,citizen online engagement and compliance with policies[J].Public Management Review,26 (3):613-634. Hirschfeld G,Thielsch M T.2022.Impact of crisis communication strategies on people's attitudes toward behavioral guidelines regarding COVID-19 and on their trust in local officials[J].International Journal of Disaster Risk Science,13(4):495-506. Ho S M,Ocasio-Velázquez M,Booth C.2017.Trust or consequences?Causal effects of perceived risk and subjective norms on cloud technology adoption[J].Computers&Security,70:581-595. Huo C G,Zhang M,Ma F C.2018.Factors influencing people's health knowledge adoption in social media:The mediating effect of trust and the moderating effect of health threat[J].Library Hi Tech,36(1):129-151. Ji Y R,Tao W T,Wan C.2025.A systematic review of attribution theory applied to crisis events in communication journals:Integration and advancing insights[J].Communication Research:1-36. Kent M L,Taylor M.1998.Building dialogic relationships through the World Wide Web[J].Public Relations Review,24(3):321-334. Kim S H,Seock Y K.2019.The roles of values and social norm on personal norms and proenvironmentally friendly apparel product purchasing behavior:The mediating role of personal norms[J].Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services,51:83-90. Kim Y.2016.Understanding publics'perception and behaviors in crisis communication:Effects of crisis news framing and publics'acquisition,selection,and transmission of information in crisis situations[J].Journal of Public Relations Research,28(1):35-50. Lee D.2022.Managing bureaucratic reputation in the face of crises:An experimental examination of the effect of strategic communication[J].Public Administration Review,82(6):1124-1137. Lee D,Van Ryzin G G.2019.Measuring bureaucratic reputation:Scale development and validation[J].Governance,32(1):177-192. Ndone J,Kyriakopoulos V.2024.The effects of crisis type and CSR fit on organizational outcomes:The moderating role of authentic leadership in shaping organizational reputation,word-of-mouth,and purchase intentions[J].Public Relations Review,50(5):102517. Overman S,Busuioc M,Wood M.2020.A multidimensional reputation barometer for public agencies:A validated instrument[J].Public Administration Review,80(3):415-425. Reynolds B,Seeger M W.2005.Crisis and emergency risk communication as an integrative model[J].Journal of Health Communication,10(1):43-55. Shim K,Yang S U.2016.The effect of bad reputation:The occurrence of crisis,corporate social responsibility,and perceptions of hypocrisy and attitudes toward a company[J].Public Relations Review,42(1):68-78. Soroya S H,Farooq A,Mahmood K,et al.2021.From information seeking to information avoidance:Understanding the health information behavior during a global health crisis[J].Information Processing&Management,58(2):102440. Sussman S W,Siegal W S.2003.Informational influence in organizations:An integrated approach to knowledge adoption[J].Information Systems Research,14(1):47-65. Tachkova E R,Coombs W T.2022.Communicating in extreme crises:Lessons from the edge[M].London:Routledge. Walster E.1966.Assignment of responsibility for an accident[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,3(1):73-79. Warkentin M,Gefen D,Pavlou P A,et al.2002.Encouraging citizen adoption of egovernment by building trust[J].Electronic Markets,12(3):157-162. Whitmarsh L,O'Neill S.2010.Green identity,green living?The role of pro-environmental self-identity in determining consistency across diverse pro-environmental behaviours[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology,30(3):305-314. Zhang X Y,Zhou Z Y.2020.Do instructing and adjusting information make a difference in crisis responsibility attribution?Merging fear appeal studies with the defensive attribution hypothesis[J].Public Relations Review,46(5):101979. Zhou Z Y,Ki E J.2018.Does severity matter?:An investigation of crisis severity from defensive attribution theory perspective[J].Public Relations Review,44(4):610-618. Zoizner A,Sheafer T,Castro L,et al.2022.The effects of the COVID-19 outbreak on selective exposure:Evidence from 17 countries[J].Political Communication,39(5):674-696.
• (1)SCCT中对应英文“prior relational reputation”,在中文语境下通常被译为先前声誉或关系史,指组织过去与利益相关者之间的互动关系。